Understanding atheist

Codswallop. Arius and his followers were exiled. They did not “put themselves out”, they were ejected.

Via forgiveness.[1]


  1. Plus a side order of acknowledgement that they were honest errors, not deliberate choices. ↩︎

1 Like

Of course. Once you declare your own teaching to be right when it is not how do you expect not to be ejected? Is the affirmation that Christ is God compatible with the affirmation that He is a creature? How can you not be ejected by the Church when you fail to recognize her in her teaching authority?

As for forgiveness this applies to individuals

Not to errors themselves. I firmly believe that a lot of Arians were saved because they were subjectively inculpable and genuinely and innocently convinced of their errors, but how would this make their error not an error at all?

Affirming that Christ is a creature is wrong and a sin because it deprives Christ from The worship and universal recognizement of His divinity and majesty that is due to Him. And failing to submit to the Church when she formally declares your error is also a sin. Forgiveness can be applied to the single Arian (and like I said I believe that many if not most of them were saved because most of them were most likely seriously and genuinely convinced, through not fault of their own, that they were right; but this judgement belongs to God alone), not to Arianism itself.

So Arius and co did not “put themselves out”.

You are misrepresenting the history of your church.

AFAICT Arius thought he was right, and no-one demonstrated he wasn’t. He was ejected was because his was the minority view. It was politics, not truth, that was the deciding factor.

If Arius and his followers were wrong, they were not protected from error. So there’s no reason to think anyone else in the Catholic church will be so protected. Hence no reason to think there will never be female Catholic priests (if that is an error).

1 Like

When you declare yourself more authorititative than the Church what do you think you are doing?

Arianism indeed became the majority view.

Exactly.

Complete non sequitur. We affirm the infallibility of ecumenical councils and Arianism was condemned in one of them. What you said is a non sequitur.

When did Arius do that?

Pope John Paul II declared that female priesthood will never be allowed. And even the apostolic churches of the east always rejected female ordination. Despite the fact that these churches are not in communion with Rome.

What do you think rejecting the solemn decree of an ecumenical Council means? It means that you put your own judgement above the judgement of the Church .

And that you don’t recognize her as being the pillar and foundation of the truth as 1 Timothy 3:15 teaches.

So if Arius and co weren’t protected from error, other members of the church may also be not protected from error, so one group may determine that female priests are permitted and ordain some.

Even if their ordainment gets overturned at the next ecumenical council, it will still have happened.

That’s what ecumenical councils are for. The Church as a whole, gathered in ecumenical council, cannot err. The first Council was the one in Jerusalem.

They would not be able to do that without departing from Catholic faith and being excommunicated.

That would just mean a schism. But there is no way that the Catholic Church and the body of Bishops throughout the world that compose the entirety of her body, would ever assent to it.

So Arius didn’t do that.

Rejecting a decree means thinking it is wrong. It might mean regarding oneself as correct and the church council as wrong. It could even mean putting ones own judgement above that of the church.

It does not mean putting oneself as “more authoritative”.

You are still misrepresenting history.

You cannot possibly know that.

There were some in the Anglican church who felt the same way. They were wrong, and you might be too.

What do you mean? If you believe that an ecumenical council is wrong, you are obviously placing your own judgment above its authority.

And this is particularly relevant in the case of Arius, because it was certainly not self-evident from Scripture that his interpretation was correct. Nor, for that matter, was its falsity so immediately obvious from the biblical text that no serious interpretative dispute could arise.

Yet Arius placed his own understanding of a highly contested doctrinal question above the solemn judgment of the Church assembled in council.

It’s not as though he were rejecting a council that had declared Christians ought to eat children’s hearts. He was rejecting a doctrinal definition intended to settle a genuine theological controversy involving disputed and far-from-unambiguous biblical passages.

He effectively regarded his own interpretation of Scripture as more authoritative than the collective doctrinal judgment of the Church.

And yes, that is precisely what heretics have always done: they have treated their own understanding of divine revelation as the ultimate criterion by which even the Church’s authoritative judgments must be accepted or rejected.

I know that by faith. Just like I know by faith that Jesus would never appear and order me to rape my wife.

That wasn’t what you wrote.

You wrote:

Arius did not do that.

More misrepresentation. The council judgement happened after Arius made his views known. He did not, and could not have rejected that doctrinal definition, because it did not yet exist.

I see no point continuing this. You have misrepresented the actual history often enough that there is no need to keep correcting you.

So you don’t know that, you only believe it.

Learn the difference.

1 Like

Actions speak far louder than words.

Sorry, I think there has been a misunderstanding. The point is that he continued to reject orthodoxy even after the Council had solemnly declared his position incompatible with the Catholic and apostolic faith.

Had he merely held those views before the Council and subsequently submitted to its solemn doctrinal decree, that would have been an entirely different matter.

For a Christian there is no difference .

Hebrews 11:1: “Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.”