Understanding atheist

That isn’t quite accurate: I know of one Episcopal and another Lutheran congregation that obviously didn’t have a ‘proper’ institutional origin that voted to leave their denominations and become RC when their pastor/priests did.

Good question since the point is the freedom to hold differing views.
To a Lutheran the question would be “Is this essential to the Gospel or does it qualify as adiaphora?”

This shows a really warped understanding of authority.

As I noted before, that leading definite article is dubious – but also that it makes only a slight difference.
Personally I see the word – which is found written in the scriptures – and the church kind of like two strands of DNA: they support each other and are intertwined.

Wasn’t that a reference to church bodies (denominations, whatever) and not individuals?

Not really – they didn’t have Rome deciding who could be a bishop and appointing them for every congregation!

1 Like

That was exactly the point: if even the Church fathers reached mutually incompatible conclusions about the indissolubility of a validly celebrated marriage, this most definitely meant that:

  1. Scripture could rationally and theologically be interpreted in different and incompatible ways.
  2. An higher authority establishing the correct interpretation was needed.

And that’s just one example among many, the most powerful one remains the trinitarian controversy.

I would just disagree with the “must”.

In fact, the early Church distinguished between several different questions: whether already-married men could be ordained, whether celibacy was preferable, whether married clergy should practice continence after ordination, and whether unmarried priests could marry after being ordained.

1. The ordination of married men

St. John Chrysostom, commenting on 1 Timothy 3:2 (Homily 10 on First Timothy), explained that Paul’s reference to a bishop being the husband of one wife did not mean that bishops were required to marry. It simply established qualifications for candidates who were already married.

Likewise, the Council of Gangra (fourth century), Canon 4, condemned those who refused to receive the Eucharist from a married presbyter merely because he was married.

Thus, the early Church recognized the legitimacy of married clergy. But that is not equivalent to requiring the Church to permit every priest to marry.

2. Fathers who defended celibacy and continence

St. Jerome, in Against Vigilantius, Chapter 2, defended the practice of admitting to the ministry virgins, continent men, or married men who renounced conjugal relations. Significantly, he associated this discipline not only with Rome but also with Eastern and Egyptian Churches.

St. Ambrose, in On the Duties of the Clergy, I.50, criticized clerics who continued to beget children after ordination, defending a particularly demanding standard of priestly continence.

These Fathers certainly did not believe that Scripture obliged the Church to permit priests to exercise every right ordinarily associated with marriage.

3. Fathers who admitted married priests but required perpetual continence

This distinction is particularly important.

St. Jerome, in Against Jovinianus, I.34, argued that Paul’s references to married bishops did not imply that they should continue begetting children after ordination.

St. Ambrose, in Letter 63, §§62–64, made essentially the same distinction.

Pope St. Leo the Great, in Letter 167, Question 3, explicitly defended the continence of ordained men who were already married, without requiring them to abandon their wives or dissolve their marriages.

The Council of Carthage (419), Canons 3–4, likewise prescribed continence for bishops, presbyters, and deacons, presenting this discipline as an inheritance from apostolic tradition.

These are fourth- and fifth-century testimonies, not medieval inventions of the Roman Church.

4. The prohibition against marriage after ordination

Even more significantly, the Eastern Church itself prohibited priests from contracting marriage after ordination.

The Council of Neocaesarea (c. AD 315), Canon 1, declared:

“If a presbyter marry, let him be removed from his order.”

The Council in Trullo (692), Canon 6, reaffirmed this prohibition, while Canon 13 permitted men already married before ordination to continue conjugal relations.

This distinction remains fundamental to Eastern Orthodox discipline today: married men may be ordained priests, but priests generally may not marry after ordination.

Therefore, even the Orthodox tradition does not accept the unrestricted principle that priests must be allowed to marry.

5. Were all the Fathers unanimous?

Of course not.

The account of Paphnutius at Nicaea, preserved by Socrates Scholasticus (Church History, I.11), describes opposition to imposing perpetual continence upon married clergy, although the historical reliability of this account remains debated.

The point is that different disciplines existed within ancient Christianity, and Scripture was not universally understood as requiring one particular arrangement.

6. So your conclusion about Rome does not follow

The Catholic Church does not teach that marriage is intrinsically incompatible with the priesthood. The Eastern Catholic Churches ordain married men to this very day.

The general requirement of priestly celibacy in the Latin Church is an ecclesiastical discipline, not an immutable dogma.

Nor does requiring celibacy for a particular ministry constitute the condemnation of marriage prohibited in 1 Timothy 4:3. There is an obvious difference between declaring marriage evil and requiring celibacy as a condition for admission to the priesthood.

Indeed, St. Paul himself praises celibacy for its advantages in undivided devotion to the Lord (1 Corinthians 7:32–35).

So the question is not whether Scripture recognizes married ministers, the issue is whether Scripture commands the Church to permit every priest to marry.

And it doesn’t. Like I said it is a matter of discipline, changeable and all but subjected to prudential judgment.

True, but in the West the church was a de facto state.

That depends on how you define “man-made” and how you measure whether the Spirit is active.

I would submit that no congregation where the Spirit is active can be called “man-made”.

1 Like

Sure, but… who ever claimed that the Pope personally appointed every bishop in the first millennium?

Let’s distinguish the recognition of papal primacy with a particular administrative mechanism for exercising ecclesiastical authority. They are not the same thing.

One of my favorite examples is Theodore Studite.

This testimony is particularly remarkable.

Writing to Pope Leo III, Theodore addressed him as: “O most divine head of all heads.”

But the significance of his letter goes considerably beyond an honorific title.

Theodore explicitly taught that Christ had entrusted Peter with the keys of the Kingdom and the dignity of chief shepherd, and that doctrinal innovations within the Catholic Church had to be referred to Peter or his successor.

Even more remarkably, Theodore invoked Roman authority precisely during a controversy concerning the ecclesiastical approval of Emperor Constantine VI’s adulterous second marriage.

He appealed to the Pope to intervene against an Eastern synod that had defended this arrangement and condemned its opponents.

He even argued that a legitimate synod should be convened through the Pope’s primatial authority.

Here we have an Eastern saint recognizing a distinctive authority in the successor of Peter, appealing to that authority against decisions made by Eastern ecclesiastical authorities themselves.

This is particularly significant because it concerns not merely honorary precedence, but the resolution of an actual ecclesiastical and moral controversy.

Even the beginning of the letter is significant: “Since to the great Peter Christ our God gave, after the keys of the kingdom of heaven, also the dignity of chief shepherd of the flock, it is necessary that to Peter, that is, to his successor, whatever is newly innovated in the catholic Church by those who have strayed from the truth be referred”

P.s

I would say of human origins (unlike the Churches founded by the apostles who were humans indeed but received divine authority from Christ Himself) but enjoying divine presence among them.

The real problem for me is that they teach many things that are nowhere to be found in the first millenium and are directly contrary to the early Church. The most obvious example being sola Scriptura.

Forbidding to marry makes the application of the admonition about one wife impossible.
IMO it is also why Rome has a shortage of priests.

But the verse doesn’t say that – it doesn’t impose that condition.

It is discipline contrary to Paul’s teaching about celibacy being a gift. You can’t demand that someone must have a certain gift.

YES. WHAT YOU WROTE IS THE MOST PERFECT WAY TO DESCRIBE IT.

The Church is not above the word of God, she is her servant as Dei Verbum teaches. At the same time, Scripture without the Church becomes a huge source of divisions, errors and heresies.

They are interwined indeed. The Church is the servant of the word but at the same time she is the only one who can authoritatively interpret it and establish the correct meaning when disputes that threaten unity arise.

I’m not opposed to the idea of changing the current discipline. I was simply taking issue with the word “must.”

Even in the early Church, many ecclesiastical authorities required married men seeking ordination to commit themselves to perpetual continence. So this is clearly a matter of ecclesiastical discipline rather than an immutable doctrinal requirement.

Personally, I think allowing married men to be ordained to the priesthood, without necessarily requiring them to abstain from conjugal relations, could be a good idea.

But that is merely my personal opinion. I would never go so far as to claim that the Church “must” adopt such a practice, as though Scripture imposed a binding obligation upon her to do so.

It isn’t accurate and it definitely isn’t empathic because it is based on your own Thomist perspective, which is not an atheist perspective.

The Holy Spirit clearly didn’t impede Anglican churches from ordaining female priests.

They are a Protestant movement, what is surprising about it?

They were also born because a king wanted the relation with his concubine to be legitimized by the Church. And when the Church didn’t bow down to the king, the king separated himself from communion with Rome.

Nothing at all.

What would be surprising would be the Holy spirit being inconsistent.

Since I do not believe that the Holy Spirit protects Protestant communities from error in the slightest, there is no inconsistency whatsoever.

To establish an inconsistency, you would first have to demonstrate that the Church has held since antiquity that schismatic and heretical movements enjoy the same protection of the Holy Spirit as the Church herself.

Moreover, many Protestant communities today endorse same-sex marriage, and some (though certainly not all, thank God) even endorse abortion, alongside many other errors.

So, is the Holy Spirit being inconsistent, or is this simply evidence that man-made churches are influenced by the world and its ever-changing social mores?

And I would consider it borderline blasphemous to attribute the founding (and the subsequent protection and assistance ) of the Anglican Church to the Holy Spirit, when its very origins lie in a king’s rebellion against Rome for refusing to legitimize and condone his sins. (“How dare the Church refuse to sanction my desire to sleep with my mistress without feeling guilty about it?! I’m the king, for heaven’s sake!” THE KING!!!”)

And then they have the nerve to call US idolaters. :sweat_smile::sweat_smile::sweat_smile::sweat_smile:

They were born out of the desire of a king to legitimize his sin and they call us idolaters. :sweat_smile::sweat_smile::sweat_smile::sweat_smile:

The shamelessness in that is a sight to behold.

What you believe does not change reality.

I see no reason why the Holy Spirit would protect Catholic communities from error but not protect Anglican ones from error, and you haven’t provided one.

Do you really think the Holy Spirit would abandon half of modern Christianity because of an event that happened 500 years ago over which they have no control? Is the Holy Spirit really that petty and spiteful?

Christ promised protection to His apostles and their successors, not to everyone. And this has always been the faith of the Church even in the first millenium.

Christ is still present among them because of the promise of Matthew “when two or three are gathered in my name etc”.

And their Baptism is most definitely valid.

This doesn’t mean that they are protected from error, otherwise even the Arians would have been protected from error.

So do you think that the Holy Spirit was protecting from error orthodox Christianity at Nicaea when we defined solemnely the triune nature of God and at the same He was protecting from error the Arian communities who denied precisely what we affirmed?

The Holy Spirit is not petty and spiteful but He is certainly truthful. So again, if we concede that He exists (I write if because you are an atheist, but you have to make this concession for argument’s sake ), do you think it’s rational to affirm that He can protect the apostolic Church when she affirms something and also protect heretical movements when they affirm the exact opposite of that something? Is it possible for God to lie? From the Scripture it doesn’t look like the answer would be positive.

You could affirm that even if He exists (again, from your atheist perspective, that’s why I write “if”) He doesn’t protect anyone so we are all just spewing human all too human bullshit, but how would you square that with John 16:13 and with 1 Timothy 3:15?

1 Like

So Christ was also petty and spiteful?

My understanding was that Jesus would protect everyone, and not refuse to protect people just because one of their predecessors did something wrong a few centuries earlier.

If the Arians, who were part of the Catholic church, weren’t protected from error, there’s no reason to think the rest of the Catholic church will be protected from error.

No. Not even from your perspective. It looks more like the Holy Spirit wasn’t protecting any of them from error.

Nor does the HS seem to be protecting the modern Catholic church from error.

He would be spiteful if He said that salvation for them is impossibile (individually) but nobody ever said that. That’s a far cry from saying that their teaching is truthful.

Non sequitur. The Arian, like every heretical sects, put themselves out of the Catholic Church. You cannot be part of the Catholic Church while putting yourself above the Catholic Church.

Care to tell me how would you square this with Jesus’ promise. I had already considered this option.

I don’t.

I think it’s rational to conclude that He isn’t protecting either group from affirming anything.

1 Like

Which is the same conclusions that Protestant reach. You have not established how this assessment can be squared with the explicit promise of Jesus, though.

Affirming something doesn’t make it true, much less rational or tenable.

John 16:13: “But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all the truth. He will not speak on his own; he will speak only what he hears”

1 Timothy 3:15: “if I am delayed, you will know how people ought to conduct themselves in God’s household, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and foundation of the truth”

You affirm that He doesn’t protect anyone from error. How is this compatible with the promise of Jesus and the way Scripture itself defines the Church?