Understanding atheist

Actions are not declarations.

My understanding is that Arius was exiled either before or very shortly after the Nicene creed was produced, and so did not have the opportunity to accept or reject the council’s decision before being exiled.

If so, you are still misrepresenting history.

He could have accepted the Council after the decree was issued, though. Or an I wrong?

If you don’t know, you shouldn’t have made the claims you did.

AFAICT Arius was exiled with no chance to accept the council’s decree, was given no reason to accept their decree, did modify his claims, was refused permission to rejoin the church anyway, and when the emperor insisted that Arius be allowed to rejoin, Arius was poisoned.

Whether the above is correct or not, there is no reason whatsoever to think Arius or any other member of the Catholic church hierarchy is protected from theological error by the Holy Spirit. Your claim that they are is contrary to reality.

Christians in the first millenium believed that ecumenical councils could not err, they didn’t believe them to be fallible.

Can you show me any evidence of the contrary? You don’t have to tell me what you believe, I know that already, I’m talking about the faith of Christians in the first millenium.

Obviously heretical sects don’t count; I’m talking about orthodox Christians.

Did he ever ask to rejoin the Church after the Council?

Athanasius was exiled following his condemnation by the First Synod of Tyre in 335 (though he was later recalled), and the Synod of Jerusalem the following year restored Arius to communion. The emperor directed Alexander of Constantinople to receive Arius, despite the bishop’s objections; Alexander responded by earnestly praying that Arius might perish before this could happen.

Source.

So yes, he did ask, and was accepted back by part of the church, but rejected by the church in Alexandria.

No doubt you’ll find some way to spin this as church unity and/or Arius’s choice.

There is no clear evidence that Arius actually renounced his original theology.

In Ecclesiastical History II.27, Sozomen explicitly states that Arius avoided his earlier controversial terminology and submitted an ambiguous profession of faith. Sozomen adds that many believed this statement was deliberately worded to remain compatible with Arius’s previous doctrines.

Furthermore, Socrates Scholasticus (Ecclesiastical History I.27) reports that, after returning to Alexandria, Arius continued spreading his heresy.

So being readmitted by some bishops does not prove that Arius had abandoned Arianism. His later profession of faith did not explicitly affirm the central Nicene doctrine of the Son’s consubstantiality with the Father.

The evidence establishes his profession of orthodoxy, not an unequivocal renunciation of his earlier theology.

And let me ask you something: even if Arius had renounced his heresy (which he did not), how would that change the fact that the Church, through the Council of Nicaea, formally condemned Arianism as incompatible with the apostolic faith, and that those who persisted in its teachings were consequently excluded from communion with the Church?

More importantly, how does the mere existence of heretics in any way disprove that, for Christians throughout the first millennium, the Church possessed genuine teaching authority, divinely protected by the Holy Spirit from error in matters of faith? The existence of heresy does not negate that authority; if anything, the Church’s ability to identify and condemn heresy presupposes it.

Logical fallacies have pervaded your entire reasoning from start to finish. It’s begging the question to assume a definition of atheism is not correct if it is not given from a materialistic worldview (your atheist perspective). You have not, cannot and will not ever demonstrate otherwise. I have zero intention of adopting your incorrect worldview and defining everything from an intellectually inferior position that is really often just a masquerade for avoiding any burden of proof.

The second half where this statement supposedly lacks empathy is just a category error (something you are well versed in committing). When I give definitions of metaphysical terms, I am l concerned with ontological precision, not emotional validation. You are just trying to create friction where none exists. You further claiming we are being misleading with this definition is another even more grotesque error on your part. This thread has not cast a good light on your brand of atheism. It comes across as sophomoric and blind. Something your posting style which consists mainly of minimalistic nitpicking does not help.

Vinnie

1 Like

I would say He would also be spiteful if He withdrew the Eucharist from those who believe and follow His words.

But any council can declare itself to be ecumenical, so disagreeing with one is not an issue. It is only afterward that a council gets acknowledged as ecumenical.

To have the Eucharist you need to have a proper priesthood, there is no way out of that. If you don’t have it, all you have is bread. But Christ is still present among them as Matthew teaches “whenever two or three are gathered in my name”, just not in the Eucharist.

And neither the Catholic Church nor the apostolic Churches of the east recognize the existence of the real presence in any Protestant ecclesial community.

I think your argument introduces a crucial ambiguity that needs to be clarified.

Are you saying that an ecumenical council possesses binding doctrinal authority which the Church subsequently recognizes, or that its decisions acquire binding authority only after the Church has examined them and determined that they conform to Scripture?

These are two fundamentally different propositions.

In fact, the Anglican–Roman Catholic International Commission explicitly rejected the idea that a conciliar definition possesses no authority until it has been received by the whole Church, or that its authority derives exclusively from such reception (Elucidations on Authority in the Church, 1981, §3).

The distinction is between recognizing an authority that already exists and conferring authority upon something through one’s subsequent approval.

More importantly, your statement that “disagreeing with one is not an issue” does not follow from the fact that ecumenical recognition may occur subsequently.

And this brings me to the central question: Once the Church has recognized a council as genuinely ecumenical, are its dogmatic definitions binding even upon Christians who personally believe that those definitions contradict Scripture?

If your answer is yes, then you acknowledge an ecclesiastical authority that is not ultimately subject to each individual’s private judgment.

If your answer is no, then in what meaningful sense do you regard the doctrinal definitions of ecumenical councils as infallible and binding?

That is precisely the distinction I’m asking you to clarify.

Binding? Yes. Infallible? I think the possibility of that was broken at Chalcedon.

This assessment of yours would not have been accepted in the first millenium, in the west as well as in the east, so…

You are still putting your own judgement as the highest court of appeal, and this is not a caricature at all, it is what you are doing. You pick and choose which councils should be considered infallible (which is still a progress compared to the Westminster confession) and you do that on the basis of your own personal evaluations.

You also contradict yourself because a few days ago you told me that the councils after the west and the east should not be considered ecumenical (thus infallible, as the understanding of the early Church was that ecumenical councils were infallible in their dogmatic decrees), which is an assessment that needs to be proven (otherwise even the post-Calchedon councils would not qualify as ecumenical, if the absence of some apostolic Churches, even very important ones, were enough to discard the ecumenicity of a Council), not you come up and say that not even the first seven ecumenical councils (recognized as such by the apostolic Churches of the west as well as the east) were truly ecumenical and thus infallible (and the fact that ecumenical councils were considered infallible in the early Church can be demonstrated historically).

That’s quite a conundrum we got here.

Unless of course with what you said you meant that there are Christians who didn’t consider the post-Calchedon councils infallible without being justified in doing so.

And that makes them right?

Is God ruler of the earth or those who claim Apostolic succession.

Richard

I say that apostolic Churches have far greater authority than man-made Christian sects. Because apostolic Churches were built upon the apostles who received a divine mandate from Christ Himself.

Luke 10:16: “He who listens to you listens to me”.

And I do not.

I guess by the Law of Contradiction one of us must be wrong.

Well I am used to be called wrong. it goes with the teritory.
(And it seems to be the popular opinion around here)

Richard

Precisely. And I have 15 centuries of Christianity, the lives of countless saints and the teaching of the Church fathers backing me up. You have yourself and people like Luther (a criminal who advocated the persecution of Jews and was complicit in the violent repression of the peasants when they revolted).

Yes, only one of us can be right. That is for sure, but the odds are not in your favour at all.

I have 15 centuries of Christians who lived and died considering God their father and the Church their mother (as St Cyprian said), who believed in the real presence and the Sacraments, who never put their own judgement above the judgment of the Church (not even the Church fathers did that).

And the entire first millenium of the undivided Church.

Millennia of saints and martyrs, doctors of the faith and fathers of the Church are backing me up. You have the backup of yourself and criminals like Luther.

No, we cannot both be right.

And I stop here before the moderators delete even this. If you want to talk to me do it privately please, otherwise they are going to eff up the both of us.:sweat_smile:

And rightly so. :sweat_smile:

THIS IS LITERALLY THE LAST TIME I REPLY TO YOU PUBLICLY, I SWEAR TO GOD, WRITE ME PRIVATELY, THERE WE CAN HAPPILY DUKE IT OUT UNTIL THE COWS COME HOME.

I WILL READ YOUR POSTS, EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM, AND REPLY TO YOU, I WILL NOT IGNORE YOU. BUT ONLY PRIVATELY. PLEASE.

A man is driving down the highway when his phone rings. His wife is on the other line, sounding panicked:

“Honey, please be careful! I just heard on the radio that there is a crazy driver going the wrong way on the highway!”

The man replies, while dodging one vehicle after the other: “One? There aren’t just one—there are hundreds of them!”

That would make an excellent conclusion, but it’s a lousy beginning.

Some-one adept at identifying fallacies would clearly recognise ‘poisoning the well.’ An informal fallacy, a form of ad hominem argument, that consists of announcing at the start that one’s opponent or disputant is of poor quality, either in their arguments or their character. The aim is to bias any audience against them so that subsequent statements by them are viewed skeptically, misconstrued, or even ignored.

It can be effective when the audience don’t notice that (as is the case here) no specifics are given and that they are simply being played, or when the audience already has a bias that is being confirmed. But anyone whose opinion matters will recognise it immediately and it’ll have the reverse of the intended effect.

I don’t know whether you’re ‘poisoning the well’ deliberately or subconsciously. It’s possible you picked up the habit from Feser, who also ‘argues’ this way, and don’t know any better. Though whether it’s deliberate or subconscious, the outcome is the same - you’re complaining about fallacies while employing one yourself.

I’m not assuming it’s incorrect, I’m pointing out that it’s incorrect. It’s incorrect (as much as a definition can be) not because of any worldview, but because it doesn’t match other definitions given elsewhere. Nor is the definition I use “given from a materialistic worldview”. It doesn’t include any claim that there is no God or gods, only that there is a lack of belief in them.

Though if it was to be given from a particular perspective, an atheist/materialist perspective would be the correct one to use. You’re doing the equivalent of insisting that ‘Christian’ be defined by non-Christians, something I suspect you would object to instantly and strenuously.

As for “begging the question”, there isn’t a question to beg. That would only apply if an argument is being made, and none has been. It’s just a matter of defining terms. If there is a fallacy here, its the ‘persuasive definition’ fallacy - “purport[ing] to describe the true or commonly accepted meaning of a term, while in reality stipulating an uncommon or altered use” - and you’re the one employing that fallacy by insisting on your own definition.

I demonstrated otherwise by citing the definition given on Wikipedia and showing that it doesn’t match the one you insist on.

But once again, there is no argument being made, just a request not to use a biased and inaccurate definition. Since there is no argument, there is nothing to refute or demonstrate, and very little scope for fallacies. The best you could hope for is an accusation of ‘persuasive definition’ on my part, or maybe ‘dictionary war’, but since I’ve cited an independent source and you haven’t, you’ve come unarmed.

Again, some-one with expertise in fallacies would readily recognise the difference between an argument vs a definition, and know that all formal fallacies and most informal ones are only applicable to the former.

No-one, least of all myself, has asked you to adopt any worldview. I’m only requesting that you recognise, acknowledge and correctly describe a worldview held by others. Apparently that’s beyond you.

If I was requesting you accept a definition of atheism along the lines of ‘Lack of belief in any of the non-existent and interchangeable deities proposed by credulous fools’, you might have a point - but I’m not, so you don’t.

“intellectually inferior”? :rofl: That’s an ‘ipse dixit’ par excellence!

So was “incorrect worldview”.

Since I’m not attempting to support atheism, or even claiming that it is correct - I’m only requesting that it be appropriately defined - there is no burden of proof to avoid. You, on the other hand, have just claimed that atheism is incorrect, without even attempting to provide any support/argument/evidence.

Empathy is generally described as the ability to perceive and understand another person’s perspective. Refusing to consider an atheistic perspective of atheism is lacking empathy by definition. This isn’t the slightest bit debatable. The only escape would be to retreat once again to a Humpty-Dumptyish realm of personalised definitions.

As for “category error”, that’s just ‘argument from repetition’ combined with ‘ad hominem’. If there is a category error anywhere, it’s your lumping of all deities of other religions into the ‘contingent’ category even though some other religions have deities (Ptah, Mbombo, Chimichagua etc) that fit the category of Grounds of Being / creators just as well as the Christian deity does.

Claptrap. There’s no ontological precision in your definition of atheist, just an emotional refusal to accept that another’s point-of-view may be as rational as your own.

First, I didn’t start this thread; second, it consists mostly of back-and-forth between Arvis, Massimiliano and Richard. Despite the title, there is very little about atheism herein. The few posts about atheism consist mostly of your antipathic refusal to consider any religion other than your own.

Accusations of blindness, sophomorism and ‘logic-chopping’ aren’t just fallacious (‘Courtier’s reply’, etc), they don’t work when made by some-one who has been scattering fallacies like an incontinent sheep. While fallacy bingo can be fun, it takes time, it doesn’t lead to anything substantial and it starts to pall a after a while.

Which reminds me - I don’t think I’ve ever seen you attempt any argument for anything using formal logic. There certainly isn’t anything remotely resembling logic in the above post - just insults, fallacies, hypocrisy, misconceptions and unsupported assertions of superiority. Maybe you could try formal logic philosophy for a change. It couldn’t be worse than regurgitating poorly-understood second-hand centuries-old apologetics.[quote=“Roy, post:240, topic:59810, full:true”]

That would make an excellent conclusion, but it’s a lousy beginning.

Some-one adept at identifying fallacies would clearly recognise ‘poisoning the well.’ An informal fallacy, a form of ad hominem argument, that consists of announcing at the start that one’s opponent or disputant is of poor quality, either in their arguments or their character. The aim is to bias any audience against them so that subsequent statements by them are viewed skeptically, misconstrued, or even ignored.

It can be effective when the audience don’t notice that (as is the case here) no specifics are given and that they are simply being played, or when the audience already has a bias that is being confirmed. But anyone whose opinion matters will recognise it immediately and it’ll have the reverse of the intended effect.

I don’t know whether you’re ‘poisoning the well’ deliberately or subconsciously. It’s possible you picked up the habit from Feser, who also ‘argues’ this way, and don’t know any better. Though whether it’s deliberate or subconscious, the outcome is the same - you’re complaining about fallacies while employing one yourself.

I’m not assuming it’s incorrect, I’m pointing out that it’s incorrect. It’s incorrect (as much as a definition can be) not because of any worldview, but because it doesn’t match other definitions given elsewhere. Nor is the definition I use “given from a materialistic worldview”. It doesn’t include any claim that there is no God or gods, only that there is a lack of belief in them.

Though if it was to be given from a particular perspective, an atheist/materialist perspective would be the correct one to use. You’re doing the equivalent of insisting that ‘Christian’ be defined by non-Christians, something I suspect you would object to instantly and strenuously.

As for “begging the question”, there isn’t a question to beg. That would only apply if an argument is being made, and none has been. It’s just a matter of defining terms. If there is a fallacy here, its the ‘persuasive definition’ fallacy - “purport[ing] to describe the true or commonly accepted meaning of a term, while in reality stipulating an uncommon or altered use” - and you’re the one employing that fallacy by insisting on your own definition.

I demonstrated otherwise by citing the definition given on Wikipedia and showing that it doesn’t match the one you insist on.

But once again, there is no argument being made, just a request not to use a biased and inaccurate definition. Since there is no argument, there is nothing to refute or demonstrate, and very little scope for fallacies. The best you could hope for is an accusation of ‘persuasive definition’ on my part, or maybe ‘dictionary war’, but since I’ve cited an independent source and you haven’t, you’ve come unarmed.

Again, some-one with expertise in fallacies would readily recognise the difference between an argument vs a definition, and know that all formal fallacies and most informal ones are only applicable to the former.

No-one, least of all myself, has asked you to adopt any worldview. I’m only requesting that you recognise, acknowledge and correctly describe a worldview held by others. Apparently that’s beyond you.

If I was requesting you accept a definition of atheism along the lines of ‘Lack of belief in any of the non-existent and interchangeable deities proposed by credulous fools’, you might have a point - but I’m not, so you don’t.

“intellectually inferior”? :rofl: That’s an ‘ipse dixit’ par excellence!

So was “incorrect worldview”.

Since I’m not attempting to support atheism, or even claiming that it is correct - I’m only requesting that it be appropriately defined - there is no burden of proof to avoid. You, on the other hand, have just claimed that atheism is incorrect, without even attempting to provide any support/argument/evidence.

Empathy is generally described as the ability to perceive and understand another person’s perspective. Refusing to consider an atheistic perspective of atheism is lacking empathy by definition. This isn’t the slightest bit debatable. The only escape would be to retreat once again to a Humpty-Dumptyish realm of personalised definitions.

As for “category error”, that’s just ‘argument from repetition’ combined with ‘ad hominem’. If there is a category error anywhere, it’s your lumping of all deities of other religions into the ‘contingent’ category even though some other religions have deities (Ptah, Mbombo, Chimichagua etc) that fit the category of Grounds of Being / creators just as well as the Christian deity does.

Claptrap. There’s no ontological precision in your definition of atheist, just an emotional refusal to accept that another’s point-of-view may be as rational as your own.

First, I didn’t start this thread; second, it consists mostly of back-and-forth between Arvis, Massimiliano and Richard. Despite the title, there is very little about atheism herein. The few posts about atheism consist mostly of your antipathic refusal to consider any religion other than your own.

Accusations of blindness, sophomorism and ‘logic-chopping’ aren’t just fallacious (‘Courtier’s reply’, etc), they don’t work when made by some-one who has been scattering fallacies like an incontinent sheep. While fallacy bingo can be fun, it takes time, it doesn’t lead to anything substantial and it starts to pall a after a while.

Which reminds me - I don’t think I’ve ever seen you attempt any argument for anything using formal logic. There certainly isn’t anything remotely resembling logic in the above post - just insults, fallacies, hypocrisy, misconceptions and unsupported assertions of superiority. Maybe you could try formal logic philosophy for a change. It couldn’t be worse than regurgitating poorly-understood second-hand centuries-old apologetics.

Added: I didn’t calculate the fallacy-to-sentence ratio, but I’d be surprised if it wasn’t greater than 1:1.

1 Like