Sola scriptura?

I’m not saying that Scripture does not support the Trinity, mind you. I’m saying that Scripture doesn’t rule out other, contradictory views, as impossible to defend on a biblical and rational basis.

The fathers got that from the apostolic faith they received and from the protection ecumenical Councils receive from the Holy Spirit.

Which is also what the early Church believed about the Ecumenical Councils.

From the historical reconstruction I have provided above

Ecumenical councils possessed supreme and final authority as I have already shown

Reference: History of the Christian Church, Volume III, §65, “The Synodical System. The Ecumenical Councils.” Philip Schaff: History of the Christian Church, Volume III: Nicene and Post-Nicene Christianity. A.D. 311-600 - Christian Classics Ethereal Library

“The authority of these councils in the decision of all points of controversy was supreme and final.”

Schaff explains that the doctrinal decisions of ecumenical councils came to be regarded as infallible because the Church understood them as enjoying the promised guidance of the Holy Spirit.

Schaff explicitly recognizes that the ancient Church regarded conciliar judgments as binding, rather than leaving the final resolution of doctrinal disputes to individual biblical interpretation. He nevertheless distinguishes the authority of ecumenical councils from that of local and provincial synods.

‘Authoritative’ and ‘erroneous’ are not incompatible. Nor are ‘non-authoritative’ and ‘correct’.

Correct, Roy. But it’s also beside the point.

@St.Roymond

I will reply to your latest rebuttal as soon as I can.

It’s not beside the point.

The Council’s interpretation could be authoritative and erroneous.

1 Like

Not for the early Church. The interpretation of Councils, for the entire early Church and for the Catholic Church to this day, is supremely authoritative because it is guaranteed by the Holy Spirit Himself.

Sure, if you remove the Holy Spirit or if you do not think that He protects the Church when she defines doctrines to be definitively believed, even the Councils can be dismissed.

From the documentation I provided above, let me quote Schaff (who was a Protestant)

Schaff explains that the doctrinal decisions of ecumenical councils came to be regarded as infallible because the Church understood them as enjoying the promised guidance of the Holy Spirit.

My point was not that one could dismiss an Ecumenical Council’s judgment because he doesn’t believe that they are protected from errors by the Holy Spirit.

MY POINT WAS THAT AFFIRMING THAT ECUMENICAL COUNCILS CAN TEACH HERESIES AND COMMAND THE FAITHFULS TO BELIEVE THEM WITH DIVINE AND CATHOLIC ASSENT OF FAITH IS CONTRARY TO THE FAITH OF THE EARLY CHURCH.

ONE CAN AFFIRM THAT THE EARLY CHURCH HAS BEEN WRONG FOR 1000 YEARS. ONE CANNOT AFFIRM HIS FAITH TO BE COMPATIBLE WITH THE FAITH OF THE EARLY CHURCH.

I AFFIRM THAT MUSLIMS ARE WRONG, I WOULD NEVER AFFIRM THAT MY BELIEFS ARE COMPATIBLE WITH MUSLIM BELIEFS OR EVEN WITH “EARLY MUSLIM” BELIEFS.

IF PROTESTANTS FEEL THE NEED TO FIND ROOTS IN THE EARLY CHURCH TO GROUND THEIR BELIEFS ON SOMETHING MORE THAN THE XVI CENTURY REVOLUTION, IT IS THEIR PROBLEM, NOT MINE.

I AFFIRM AND DEFEND THEIR RIGHT TO BELIEVE THAT THE ENTIRE EARLY CHURCH WAS WRONG AND CORRUPTED FROM THE START UNTIL THE REFORMERS RECOVERED TRUE CHRISTIANITY, A TRUE CHRISTIANITY THAT HAD BEEN APPARENTLY BURIED FROM THE VERY START. HOW DO THEY RECONCILE THIS WITH JESUS’S PROMISES IS THEIR PROBLEM, NOT MINE.

I REJECT AND REFUTE THEIR CLAIMS THAT THEIR PRINCIPAL DOCTRINES (THE DOCTRINES THAT SET PROTESTANTISM APART FROM THE APOSTOLIC CHURCHES) CAN BE EVEN REMOTELY COMPATIBLE WITH THE FAITH PROFESSED BY THE EARLY CHURCH AND BY THE UNDIVIDED CHURCH FOR MORE THAN A MILLENIA. AND I REJECT AND REFUTE THESE CLAIMS ON THE BASIS OF HISTORICAL EVIDENCE.

I try to answer something, from a general viewpoint:

  1. This question is anachronistic, as I explained in an earlier message above.

  2. The universal priesthood of the laity is based on interpretations of the NT scriptures.
    In the earliest church, there happened a relatively rapid development in the leadership systems, from a leading group of elders towards churches lead by a single episcopos. After this, the other ‘levels’ of workers got their defined places. Simultaneously, the universal priesthood of believers seems to have faded and vanished from the general picture. How rapidly this development happened is something I do not know.

  3. Interpretations about how the Eucharist was understood among the early Fathers are complicated by them using expressions copying or reflecting the words of Jesus. To solve this question, we should return to what Jesus told and teached. Whatever Jesus meant, that is more important than what the early Fathers believed. There are similar kind of schools of interpretation regarding the words of Jesus.

  4. Ecumenical councils were mostly seen as authoritative gatherings of leaders. Mostly because the agreement or disagreement with the decisions influenced the attitudes - it was authoritative if you could agree with the decisions.
    It is probable that the catholic Christians of that era believed that the Holy Spirit was involved in the process of making the decisions. Whether they believed that there could not be errors in the slightest may have varied. I do not doubt that many believed that. Most Christians probably just accepted what the leaders told because the leadership systems were already strongly hierarchical and the leaders defined what the members (laity) of the church should believe.

It is not anacronistic. I’m covering the entire faith of the first millenium. Can you find a single Church father who believed that a Christian could contradict the teaching of the Church on the basis of his own understanding of the meaning of Scripture? Even evidences from the ninth century are ok.

Precisely. Can you find me a single evidence that in the first 15 centuries of Christianity the universal priesthood of the laity was an interpretation that was compatible with the faith of the Church?

Otherwise we run in circle .

I have provided ample historical documentations that show that the fathers were virtually universally “realist”. Here and here

They were not seen in this reductive manner. They were seen as assemblies of ordained Bishops that were protected from error by the Holy Spirit. Do you have any evidence to the contrary?

Again let me quote Schaff

Schaff explains that the doctrinal decisions of ecumenical councils came to be regarded as infallible because the Church understood them as enjoying the promised guidance of the Holy Spirit.

Schaff also said

“The authority of these councils in the decision of all points of controversy was supreme and final.”

Can you find me evidences that ecumenical councils in the early Church were actually believed to be authoritative but far from infallible gatherings of elders who were merely expressing their own “human all too human” interpretations of the Scriptures?

I remember now why we stopped discussing and disagree agreeably. Your faith in the authority of the ecumenical councils is of course subjective and yet you do have every right to hold it. The only problem I saw was that the foundation of that belief was formed by the ecumenical councils themselves. However, if that is perfectly all right with you, then peace my brother.

Kind of like the Council of Jerusalem.

Acts 15:28: “It seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us”

Can you provide any evidence for the idea that the early Church didn’t believe that apostolic authority survived in their successors? Because every historical record we possess shows the exact opposite.

understandbly since you hold the ecumenical councils as authoritative as the council of Jerusalem. I hear you.

Yes but it’s not “me”. The entire early Church believed them to be infallible and protected by God from error. And a billion and a half of Catholics still believe that to this day. Can you see the difference between sharing a belief with the entire first millenium of the early Church and having an understanding (the fallibility of Councils, the scripture as the sole infallible rule of Faith, the symbolic Eucharist etc etc etc) that directly and inexorably contradicts 10 (actually 15) centuries of Christianity?

I’m just pointing out that this is not “methinks” vs “theethinks”

I’m professing what the entire early church professed.

You are professing a novelty that was introduced only 5 centuries ago.

And you have every right to profess abd believe that novelty, mind you. I respect and defend your right to believe that the early Church got it all wrong for a millenia until the reformers came along to teach us the true Gospel.

from the internal witness of the Scripture. Didn’t Jesus Himself appoint those 12 apostles to be special? Did Jesus ever gave those authorities to their successors? (If there is such a thing as successor to the apostle)

I will reply very soon.

And let me add something to this Sola scriptura? - #153 by 1Cor15.54 post : no, they didn’t accept that because they were clueless ignorant sheeps, Knor. Even the CHURCH FATHERS, who were exceptionally well learned (far more than you are, believe me), professed that same faith and belief. So if you want to suggest that Christians believed the councils to be infallible only because they were ignorant peasants not as enlightened as modern Protestants I’m afraid you are going to run into a wall.

And a very big one at that.

‘Your have been told … but I tell you …’ is such authoritative speech that Jesus could say but none of his disciples could. When the later followers tried to justify something, they did not normally use expressions that leaned on what the person was thinking or believed.

Every time someone defended an interpretation or doctrine by lifting up what Jesus, one of the Apostles or a canonical text told, that is de facto claiming that ‘his own understanding’ about the early tradition is correct. Claiming that authoritative characters or sources agreed with him does not change the point.

I assume that the writers of the first millennium were mostly skillful enough to express their understanding without provoking a direct conflict with the teaching of the dominating church. If they were more straight, their writings probably did not survive the condemnation by the rulers.

In short, I have asked you to provide evidence that your beliefs would not have been condemned as heterodox in the early Church, but were, in fact, shared by the early Church and the Church Fathers. And you have provided zero evidence. (beautifully written and enjoyable word salads are not evidence.)

I don’t blame you at all. Providing something that does not exist would be rather problematic.

If I’m wrong, and you do have evidence more authoritative than “methinks,” by all means, let me know. Anytime, anywhere.

I shall be entirely at your disposal (within reason, of course… let’s not get carried away​:laughing::sweat_smile:), and you will have my undivided attention.

P.s: from my documentation (Newman was still an Anglican when he wrote this)

Newman is referring specifically to a Protestant who attempts to establish the historical legitimacy of Protestant doctrine by appealing to the surviving records of early Christianity.

He argues that such an attempt encounters a fundamental difficulty: the documentary record depicts a visible, hierarchical, sacramental Church whose theological assumptions are profoundly different from those of the sixteenth-century Reformation.

Newman continues by arguing that, if a recognizably Protestant system, or one that was even remotely compatible with the later reformation, had existed in the apostolic age, one would have to explain its disappearance from the surviving historical record.

He can be read more extensively here

This is probably just waste of time and effort but I lift up one viewpoint:

There were critical voices among the Christians during the first millennium. They are not counted among the Church Fathers because they did not support the dominant interpretations - a selective choice that left only the ‘orthodox’ voices. ‘Orthodox’ was defined by the dominating majority.

Most of those critical voices were such that I cannot support (‘heresies’). Condemning such ‘heretical’ voices was probably justified.
Despite this, it shows that there were conflicting opinions, attempts to correct such teachings that were seen as deviations from the original teaching. These voices were silenced. We do not know if there were other critical voices that were silenced so well that there is no historical evidence left.

Such critical voices included, for example, the Iconoclasts, Pelagianists and those writing critically about Papal Primacy and the Filioque.

I was referring to mainstream Christianity, of course. There were certainly plenty of sects that professed heretical doctrines and rejected the Church’s apostolic interpretation of the faith.

My question is simply whether your interpretation would have been condemned as heretical and classified alongside those sects, or whether, as Protestants so often claim, it would have been compatible with the faith of the early, undivided Church of East and West during the first millennium.

Many of the beliefs professed by Protestants are arguably even more fundamentally at odds with the faith of the early Church than Marcionism, Sabellianism, Nestorianism, and the like.

Yo brother, I hope you are not playing a number game here. Our search is to find the truth, not what the majority has held and how long it has been held.

I don’t think I care how long that novelty had existed. I just care to hold to the truth that Jesus declared even if it was found out as recently as today. I am glad however that the written Scripture that I hold in high regard has internal witness of It’s authority.