Sola scriptura?

I agree. Which means that all Protestant denominations are in disagreement with Scripture because they ALL maintain Scripture as the sole infallible rule of Faith. They have many differences but the Scripture as the sole infallible rule of Faith is what is shared among them all (the hatred for Rome is the other thing they share). I’ll reply on the council later.

I have in the past cited important Fathers, including Athanasius, who disagreed, maintaining that scripture is the “referee”. That means doctrine has to be founded in the (primary) canon.

There were indeed fathers who disagreed with my view. But there were also fathers who agreed with it

John Chrysostom — Homily 4 on 2 Thessalonians

“Hence it is manifest, that they did not deliver all things by Epistle, but many things also unwritten, and in like manner both the one and the other are worthy of credit.”

Chrysostom immediately adds:

“Therefore let us think the tradition of the Church also worthy of credit. It is a tradition, seek no farther.”

Chrysostom is commenting on 2 Thessalonians 2:15, where Paul instructs believers to hold fast to the traditions they received, whether orally or by letter.

Chrysostom explicitly recognizes the authority of unwritten apostolic traditions.

Source: CHURCH FATHERS: Homily 4 on Second Thessalonians (Chrysostom)

Basil the Great — On the Holy Spirit, 27.66

“Of the beliefs and practices whether generally accepted or publicly enjoined which are preserved in the Church some we possess derived from written teaching; others we have received delivered to us ‘in a mystery’ by the tradition of the apostles; and both of these in relation to true religion have the same force.”

Basil is defending the liturgical formula “with the Spirit,” which had been challenged because it was not directly attested in Scripture in the relevant form.

He appeals to several unwritten ecclesiastical practices, including making the sign of the cross, facing east during prayer, and certain baptismal rites.

This is, I think, the strongest patristic testimony supporting the authority of unwritten traditions.

Basil explicitly states that such traditions can possess the same authority as written teachings. Crucially, however, he attributes their origin to the apostles. He does not present them as later innovations justified merely by their compatibility with Scripture.

Souurce : CHURCH FATHERS: De Spiritu Sancto (Basil)

3. Epiphanius of Salamis — Panarion 61.6

“But it is also necessary to use tradition; for not all things can be taken from the divine scripture.”

He continues:

“Therefore, the holy apostles handed down some things in scriptures, and others in traditions”

Source: https://christian-reality.com/biblical-apologetics/church-history-articles/epiphanius-sacred-tradition

Epiphanius is responding to the Apostolics, an ascetic group, and discussing marriage and continence, particularly marriage following a vow of virginity.

He argues that apostolic tradition contributes to the correct interpretation of Paul’s teachings, including the distinction between ordinary marriage and marriage following a religious vow.

Epiphanius explicitly recognizes the existence of unwritten and authoritative apostolic traditions.

This just means that the fathers disagreed on the subject (the necessity for a doctrine to be explicitly found in Scripture) , just like they disagreed on the indissolubility of marriage, or even the ontological status of Jesus (some were explicitly subordinationist before Nicaea and I can quote them if requested).

Because they were authoritative but not infallible: ecumenical Councils are needed to establish infallible doctrine, rather than relying on the words of the Fathers + Scripture.

I have worked too long as an Academic researcher to trust blindly on what the other scholars write. I have some understanding about both the strengths and possible pitfalls in scholarly texts.

My professional experience is from natural sciences but I have recently read texts about the ancient Mesopotamian cultures and some of the writings lift up critically the assumptions and early misunderstandings that drive much of the prevailing historical interpretation of Mesopotamian cultures.
The weakness of historical interpretation is that there are limited possibilities to test the assumptions and hypotheses - no possibilities for experimental approach.

Claims in theological handbooks may have even weaker justification. I once tried to find the original justifications for some claims in the textbooks that were used in a respected university. The results of the search were very disappointing. The original publications from the 19th century included speculations about what could explain some observations. Later theologians had accepted the speculations like they would be demonstrated facts and those ideas then started to prevail in various textbooks.

Historical research on the early church has a better foundation than the studies of many other cultures because there are usable writings from that era. Therefore, my starting point towards the conclusions is positive: I assume that the conclusions are probably correct but recognize the possibility that they may include skewed opinions. The credibility of the conclusions can then be estimated by taking into account the different possible factors that may mislead the thinking. Such factors include:

  • historians may base their conclusions on what the earlier scholars have written about the topic. There is a need to consider how much the conclusions are based on the opinions of the earlier scholars and how much on independent study of the original material?
  • the context of the early churches changed relatively rapidly during the first centuries as the status of Christianity in the empire changed, the leadership structures in the churches developed and the networks strengthened, the early diversity in the local practices started to become more homogeneous among the churches, etc. It is important to consider the exact context where each writer lived to understand the motivation and purpose of the writing better.
  • there is a need to consider how representative the original material was. Preservation of the writings was selective and only a minority could write long texts, so we may have a limited viewpoint to the diversity. For example, what we know of some heresies is mainly based on writings that attacked against these heresies.
  • historians are humans and suffer from the same limitations as the other readers, especially before modern critical thinking. There is a need to estimate how limited the interpretation is: were the interpretations done by persons who had ‘blinders on’, how critical their analyses about the opinions of the earlier scholars were, did they demonstrate any selfcriticism by discussing the reliability of their conclusions and possible other interpretations.
  • Etc.
1 Like

I would think that if by the time of Basil something from the Apostles hadn’t been written down then it wasn’t trustworthy. Otherwise you get a license for making things up.

Roymond, your objection confuses three distinct things: a council’s claim to ecumenicity, the criteria by which that claim could be evaluated, and its subsequent historical reception.

I agree that merely calling oneself an ecumenical council does not make one ecumenical. But it simply does not follow that there were no objective criteria for determining ecumenicity until centuries later.

Nicaea II (787) explicitly proves otherwise.

At its sixth session, the council rejected Hieria’s (754) claim to ecumenicity partly because it lacked the cooperation of the Bishop of Rome, whether through representatives or an official letter, “as is the rule in the councils” (Mansi XIII, 208D–209A).

Notice the significance: the Eastern bishops were appealing to an already established conciliar norm, not inventing a retrospective criterion.

Whether Rome had cooperated was an objectively ascertainable fact, not something that could only be discovered centuries later.

Nor was this a novelty of 787. Already in the fifth century, Pope Leo I discussed the importance of his ratification of Chalcedon’s doctrinal decisions (Letter 117).

Even the joint Catholic–Orthodox Chieti document (2016), §18, acknowledges that Roman cooperation was among the criteria invoked at Nicaea II for determining ecumenicity.

You are confusing the time required for a council’s authority to achieve widespread recognition with the existence of criteria by which that authority could be assessed.

The fact that some councils falsely claimed ecumenicity does not render those criteria meaningless. On the contrary, it explains precisely why such criteria were necessary.

And this brings us back to my original argument: the Catholic requirement of Roman recognition was not invented by the modern Catechism and retroactively imposed upon the ancient Church. Nicaea II itself explicitly invoked Roman cooperation as an established conciliar norm.

Your objection does nothing to refute that historical fact.

Sources:

Roymond, there is nothing inherently circular about that argument. You are confusing two distinct questions: which bishops belong to the ecclesiastical communion exercising conciliar authority, and what makes a council ecumenical.

Nobody is defining “schismatics” as those who happen to disagree with the conclusions of a particular council.

Ecclesiastical communion, including its institutional continuity and historical ruptures, can be investigated independently of the council whose ecumenicity is being assessed.

Nor does the ancient evidence establish that every separated Christian community possesses a perpetual veto over ecumenical councils.

Consider Ephesus (431). The council proceeded amid opposition from John of Antioch and his bishops, whose rival assembly it condemned. Yet Ephesus was subsequently recognized as ecumenical.

Or consider Chalcedon (451), whose decisions were rejected by substantial Eastern Christian communities. Their rejection did not prevent its recognition as ecumenical by the Chalcedonian Churches.

The historical point is that ecumenicity was not made conditional upon the unanimous agreement of every competing ecclesiastical body.

Now consider Nicaea II (787), which explicitly invoked Roman cooperation as an established conciliar norm, even though, as Richard Price documents, its supposed representatives of three Eastern patriarchates lacked formal authorization from those patriarchs.

This is precisely why Walter Brandmüller distinguishes historically contingent forms of patriarchal representation from what he considers the enduring requirements of ecumenical authority.

You may dispute his conclusion that the episcopate in communion with Rome retains that universal authority after a schism. But that requires an argument about ecclesiastical continuity and authority, not simply an accusation of circularity.

Indeed, your objection appears to assume that every separated patriarchate must retain an effective veto over subsequent ecumenical councils. Where is the historical evidence establishing that principle?

The absence of separated bishops does not, by itself, prove that a council is ecumenical. But neither does their absence automatically prove that it is not.

The question is which ecclesiastical communion legitimately possesses universal conciliar authority. Merely calling the Catholic answer circular does not settle that question.

I think you have your objection exactly backwards.

Where, precisely, does Jesus say that His promise to the apostles is conditional upon the presence or unanimous agreement of every single one of their successors?

The fact that Jesus addresses the apostles collectively does not grammatically establish that every apostolic successor must personally participate in, or approve, every exercise of the Church’s universal teaching authority.

That qualification is nowhere to be found in the text. You are the one introducing it.

Furthermore, Scripture itself distinguishes between the collective authority of the apostles and the particular responsibility entrusted to Peter.

In Luke 22:31–32, Jesus initially addresses the apostles in the plural but then deliberately switches to the singular when addressing Peter, praying specifically for his faith and commanding him to strengthen his brothers.

Likewise, in Matthew 16:18–19, the keys of the kingdom are entrusted to Peter personally.

Now, these passages do not, by grammar alone, establish every subsequent Catholic doctrine concerning papal authority. But they certainly undermine your suggestion that the collective character of Christ’s promises excludes a distinctive Petrine responsibility.

More importantly, you are confusing the unconditional character of Christ’s promise with the conditions under which a particular episcopal assembly can legitimately claim to exercise the infallible teaching authority protected by that promise.

Christ did not promise that every assembly of bishops claiming universal authority would necessarily be protected from error. Otherwise, how could the ancient Church have rejected councils that claimed ecumenicity?

And this is precisely where the historical evidence becomes decisive.

At Nicaea II (787), the Eastern bishops explicitly invoked the absence of Roman cooperation, according to established conciliar practice, as a reason for rejecting Hieria’s claim to ecumenicity. They also invoked the lack of agreement among the Eastern patriarchates.

Thus, the ancient Church itself recognized that not every assembly of bishops could legitimately claim the authority of an ecumenical council, and it explicitly identified Roman cooperation among the relevant criteria.

This is not a qualification invented by the modern Catholic Catechism and retroactively imposed upon the ancient Church. It is a criterion explicitly invoked by an ecumenical council in the eighth century.

And notice the crucial distinction: the promise of Christ does not depend upon the arbitrary will of the Bishop of Rome. Rather, Roman cooperation belongs to the historically attested criteria for identifying the authentic exercise of universal conciliar authority to which that promise applies.

You may dispute the theological significance of that criterion, but you cannot dismiss its historical existence.

Meanwhile, your own proposed qualification—that the presence or unanimous agreement of all apostolic successors is necessary for Christ’s promise to apply—is neither explicitly stated in Scripture nor established by the historical practice of the ecumenical councils.

In fact, Nicaea II itself did not have formally authorized representatives of all the Eastern patriarchates, as Richard Price documents in his critical edition of the council’s acts. Yet it was eventually recognized as ecumenical.

So the question remains: where does Jesus establish your supposed requirement that every apostolic successor must participate in or consent to a council for His promise to apply?

A plural pronoun does not establish such a rule.

And if you insist that it does, you must explain why the ancient Church itself appealed to specific ecclesiastical criteria, including Roman cooperation, rather than treating the collective character of Christ’s promise as sufficient to establish the authority of any episcopal assembly.

You are accusing me of introducing an unwarranted qualification while introducing one yourself. The difference is that the Roman criterion has an explicit foundation in ancient conciliar practice, whereas your supposed requirement of unanimous apostolic succession has yet to be demonstrated.

But your objection actually makes Nicaea II even more relevant.

You claim that the requirement of Roman participation is circular because Rome itself defines ecumenicity in terms of its own involvement. But that is precisely what the historical evidence contradicts.

At Nicaea II (787), the Eastern conciliar fathers explicitly invoked the absence of Roman cooperation as a reason for rejecting Hieria’s claim to ecumenicity, specifying that such cooperation should occur through papal representatives or an official letter, “as is the rule in the councils” (Mansi XIII, 208D–209A).

Notice what this establishes.

It was not Rome arbitrarily declaring that its participation was indispensable. It was an Eastern ecumenical council appealing to an already established conciliar norm.

Even the joint Catholic–Orthodox Saint Irenaeus study, Serving Communion, §7.10, acknowledges that the pope’s position was distinguished from that of the other patriarchs and that “his approval of a council carries a special weight.”

The council also required agreement with the Eastern patriarchates. I have never denied that. The point is that Roman cooperation was expressly identified as a distinct requirement, independently of any modern Catholic definition.

And this exposes the weakness of your circularity accusation.

You cannot dismiss a criterion as a self-serving Roman invention when that very criterion was explicitly invoked by the Eastern bishops themselves centuries before the East–West schism.

Whether the separated patriarchates retain an unconditional veto over subsequent councils is a different question, requiring its own historical and ecclesiological argument.

But you cannot establish such a veto merely by calling the Roman criterion circular.

The historical question you still have not answered is simple: why did the Eastern fathers of Nicaea II invoke Roman cooperation as an established conciliar norm if it was merely a self-serving Roman definition?

That is what your objection needs to explain.

Are you seriously suggesting that Protestant historians (because that’s exactly what they were) could have had “blinders on” that led them to conclude that Protestantism and its distinctive tenets were nowhere to be found in the early Church and were actually incompatible with her faith?

A Protestant biased against Protestantism, who proposes a historical reconstruction that dismantles any pretense of Protestantism’s compatibility with the faith of the early Church? According to you, that was the result of having blinders on, rather than simply acknowledging the historical evidence?

Wouldn’t you expect a Protestant historian to have a bias in favor of a historical reconstruction favorable to Protestantism? How can a Protestant historian be biased against Protestantism and arrive at a historical reconstruction that dismantles any claim of Protestantism’s compatibility with the early Church, if not because of the evidence they gathered? Why would a Protestant historian arrive at the conclusion I documented in my post, if not because the evidence compelled him to do so?

This is also why I never cite Catholic authors. Not because their scholarship is invalid, but because they could be accused of pro-Catholic bias.

Their arguments can be found here Sola scriptura? - #94 by 1Cor15.54

If anyone wants to show where they are wrong and why and provide evidence of their errors, by all means, do so.

hmm, very tempted to do, but no. I respect Knor. This is his space.

Not sure about being a principle utterly foreign. It is always my understanding that the letters of the NT were going around the early Church and view as authoritative.

“I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting him who called you in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel— not that there is another one, but there are some who trouble you and want to distort the gospel of Christ. But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed. As we have said before, so now I say again: If anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to the one you received, let him be accursed.” (Gal 1:6-9)

Apparently, there were many other so called “gospel” running around the early churches (perhaps Judaism) that distorted the truth of the true Gospel. While the Gospel was taught thru oral teaching and written scriptures (letters) in the very early Church, it changed as the apostle were persecuted. Of course oral teaching were still circulated during that time with the disciples of the apostles. Even during that time, how did one know whether that oral teaching that was taught by those followers of the Way were correct Gospel or not. They were scrutinised thru the written Scripture that were unchanging and much less corrupted. (I say this because even copying the original letters produced corruption and sometimes purposely as the copyist disagree with the wording of the letter). Therefore, the principle of sola scriptura was there at work without any specific mentioned even among the Fathers because it should be a common sense truth.

If I ask you whether a saying from an early church Father is biblical or not, then how do you defend that saying? By going to the reliable source available to us, that is the written Scripture. Even all the traditions of the Church thru all the millennia and all other teachings must be seen thru the written Scripture.

Granted. But the subjectivism could not be avoided even in the ecumenical councils. You leave the correct interpretation of Scripture to the Church (or Magisterium). That is of course your choice and I respect that though I disagree with that. Does that mean that the decision of the Magisterium held more truth than my personal study of the Bible? Maybe or maybe not.

this is a good common ground to remember by. Thanks Vinnie.

While this was not contradicting scripture, it is also reasonable to view these doctrines carefully and perhaps not treating these doctrines as dogmas.

Open a new topic! I’d be more than happy to show that your anti-trinitarian view can be perfectly defended using sola Scriptura without twisting anything. I’m not going to refute your position (it would not even be possible with Scripture alone, not conclusively at least, otherwise the fathers would not have introduced an unbiblical term to settle the matter in the first place), I’m going to steelman the absolute hell out of it.

I’ll become Arius’s latest descendant, brother. :sweat_smile:

I can be an exceptionally good heretic if I want to.:laughing::laughing::laughing::smiley::smiley::smiley:

P.s it would also be perfectly on topic as this topic is named sola Scriptura. Showing the consequences of the application of this principle (which are already evident in your refusal of the trinitarian doctrine on the grounds that you cannot reconcile it with your understanding of the Bible) would be perfectly on topic.

Who said they were not? But scripture as the sole infallible rule of Faith is something entirely different, brother.

Only if you maintain that Ecumenical Councils were as protected by the Holy Spirit as a gathering of 318 fat and drunk West Virginia televangelists.

But the early Church had faith indeed in the divine protection of those Council . And the Holy Spirit is truthful.

Oh maybe it doesn’t. But if that is the case someone would need to show why all these people who personally study the Bible come up with incompatible and mutually contradictory interpretations of that same Bible.

We have an incredible amount of Protestant denominations that disagree on fundamental matters of faith and morals. If the study of the Bible is sufficient to understand the Bible, why do they come up with mutually contradictory understanding of the very same Bible?

Let’s grant for argument’s sake that the Magisterium is bunk.

What are the fruits of sola Scriptura? Does it produce unity in the faith and orthodoxy or does it produce the exact opposite of both?

I regard Chalcedon as broken because there was no disagreement on doctrine, only on terminology. The schism was completely artificial, and forced by the emperor.
That the two sides had the same Christology means they were both orthodox, the division was because they had different terminology. So unless you can show that the theology of the eastern churches deviated after that council, then excluding them from later councils renders them not ecumenical.

Where is the evidence that merely calling an orthodox group schismatic justifies excluding them subsequently?
The promise was to all the apostles, so if it extends to their successors it requires all their successors.

The promise was to the group.

Which was violated when Rome called perfectly orthodox Christians schismatics and thus excluded them.

The participation or at least the invitation of all orthodox is assumed.

Enough said

Richard