Sola scriptura?

Now I am going to present further historical evidence, directed particularly at an obnoxious individual here whose outwardly calm and composed demeanor conceals a deeply arrogant, rebellious, and prideful spirit.

This same individual has even invoked St. Athanasius’s words, “You have the buildings, but we have the faith,” in an attempt to suggest that my faith has departed from orthodoxy, while his own sect somehow represents a more faithful continuation of it. The irony of such a claim will become abundantly clear in light of the historical evidence I am about to present.

I’m going to quote Philipp Schaff, the Protestant Philpp Schaff, again.

1. The Early Church regarded doctrinal separation from the Catholic Church as heresy

Reference: History of the Christian Church, Volume II, Ante-Nicene Christianity, A.D. 100–325, §53, “The Catholic Unity.” “In the view of the fathers, every theoretical departure from this empirical, tangible, catholic church is heresy” Philip Schaff: History of the Christian Church, Volume II: Ante-Nicene Christianity. A.D. 100-325 - Christian Classics Ethereal Library

Schaff goes on to explain that disobedience to ecclesiastical authorities was regarded as schism, and that both heresy and schism were understood as rebellion against divine authority.

He expressly identifies this ecclesiology as the position of the ante-Nicene Fathers, including Ignatius of Antioch, Irenaeus, and Cyprian.

Schaff acknowledges that the early Fathers did not understand the Church merely as a voluntary association of believers sharing their individual biblical interpretations. They regarded the visible Catholic Church as an institution possessing divinely established authority.

2. The Church’s tradition provided the authoritative interpretation of Scripture

Reference: History of the Christian Church, Volume III, Nicene and Post-Nicene Christianity, A.D. 311–600, §118, “Sources of Theology. Scripture and Tradition.” “the church tradition determines the canon, furnishes the key to the true interpretation of the Scriptures”

Schaff explains that, in the ancient Church, Scripture and apostolic Tradition together constituted the rule of faith. He compares their relationship to that between the supreme law of a country and the courts authorized to interpret that law and settle disputes.

He also explicitly acknowledges that Protestantism permits substantially greater freedom of private judgment in interpreting Scripture than either the Roman or Nicene Church.

According to Schaff, the ancient Church recognized an ecclesiastical authority responsible for preserving the correct interpretation of Scripture, rather than treating competing private interpretations as equally authoritative.

https://www.ccel.org/ccel/schaff/hcc3.iii.xii.ii.html

3. Ecumenical councils possessed supreme and final authority as I have already shown

Reference: History of the Christian Church, Volume III, §65, “The Synodical System. The Ecumenical Councils.” Philip Schaff: History of the Christian Church, Volume III: Nicene and Post-Nicene Christianity. A.D. 311-600 - Christian Classics Ethereal Library

“The authority of these councils in the decision of all points of controversy was supreme and final.”

Schaff explains that the doctrinal decisions of ecumenical councils came to be regarded as infallible because the Church understood them as enjoying the promised guidance of the Holy Spirit.

Schaff explicitly recognizes that the ancient Church regarded conciliar judgments as binding, rather than leaving the final resolution of doctrinal disputes to individual biblical interpretation. He nevertheless distinguishes the authority of ecumenical councils from that of local and provincial synods.

4. The Fathers were far away from Protestant orthodoxy

Reference: History of the Christian Church, Volume II, §160, “A General Estimate of the Fathers. Philip Schaff: History of the Christian Church, Volume II: Ante-Nicene Christianity. A.D. 100-325 - Christian Classics Ethereal Library

“ WE SEEK IN VAIN AMONG THEM for the evangelical doctrines of the exclusive authority of the Scriptures, justification by faith alone, the universal priesthood of the laity”

By contrast, he acknowledges that already in the second century there was considerable respect for ecclesiastical traditions and strong sacerdotal, sacramental, liturgical, and ascetical tendencies.

This is one of the clearest admissions by a Protestant historian that the doctrinal and ecclesiastical outlook of the early Fathers ARE NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THAT OF THE REFORMATION

5. A form of papal authority was already exercised in the first century

Reference: History of the Christian Church, Volume II, §50, “Germs of the Papacy.” Philip Schaff: History of the Christian Church, Volume II: Ante-Nicene Christianity. A.D. 100-325 - Christian Classics Ethereal Library

“The first example of the exercise of a sort of papal authority is found towards the close of the first century in the letter of the Roman bishop Clement (d. 102) to the bereaved and distracted church of Corinth”

Schaff applies this description to Clement of Rome’s intervention in the Corinthian Church near the end of the first century.

He acknowledges that Rome intervened in the affairs of an important Eastern congregation, sent representatives, and addressed the Corinthians with a tone of ecclesiastical authority.

He also recognizes that the Roman Church’s conduct suggested a consciousness of superiority over ordinary Christian congregations.

II. John Henry Newman (1801–1890)

Religious affiliation: Anglican priest until 1845; subsequently Roman Catholic.

His writings must be divided into two periods. His Primitive Christianity essays were originally written in 1833–1836, WHILE HE WAS STILL ANGLICAN. His Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine was published in 1845, during his conversion to Catholicism.

7. Primitive Christianity was not the religion of Luther

Reference: Historical Sketches, Volume I, Primitive Christianity, Chapter IV, “And what say Jovinian and his Companions?”, p. 416.

“WHATEVER PRIMITIVE CHRISTIANITY WAS OR WAS NOT, IT WAS NOT THE RELIGION OF LUTHER .” Newman Reader - Primitive Christianity - Jovinian

Newman reaches this conclusion after examining the ecclesiology, doctrinal teaching, and religious practices of early Christian authors, including Ignatius, Irenaeus, Clement of Alexandria, Cyprian, and Origen.

He argues that neither the recognized Catholic Fathers nor various ancient dissenters provide evidence of the distinctive doctrinal system of the Protestant Reformation.

He specifically challenges the claim that the ancient Fathers shared Luther’s doctrine of justification, the Protestant conception of Scripture as the sole rule of faith, or the unrestricted right of private judgment.

This is an especially relevant historical argument because Newman wrote it while still defending Anglicanism.

8. The Protestant encounters an impossible difficulty when appealing to early Church history

Reference: Historical Sketches, Volume I, Primitive Christianity, Chapter V, “And what do the Apostolical Canons say?”, p. 417. Newman Reader - Primitive Christianity - Apostolical Canons

“With this object I have fallen upon the writers aforesaid; and, since they have been more or less accused of heterodoxy, I thought there was at least a chance of their subserving the cause of Protestantism, which the Catholic Fathers certainly do not subserve; but they, though differing from each other most materially, and some of them differing from the Church, do not any one of them approximate to the tone or language of the movement of 1517. Every additional instance of this kind does but go indirectly to corroborate the testimony of the Catholic Church. It is natural and becoming in all of us to make a brave struggle for life; but I do not think it will avail the Protestant who attempts it in the medium of ecclesiastical history. HE WILL FIND HIMSELF IN AN ELEMENT IN WHICH HE CANNOT BREATHE”.

Newman is referring specifically to a Protestant who attempts to establish the historical legitimacy of Protestant doctrine by appealing to the surviving records of early Christianity.

He argues that such an attempt encounters a fundamental difficulty: the documentary record depicts a visible, hierarchical, sacramental Church whose theological assumptions are profoundly different from those of the sixteenth-century Reformation.

Newman continues by arguing that, if a recognizably Protestant system, or one that was even remotely compatible with the later reformation, had existed in the apostolic age, one would have to explain its disappearance from the surviving historical record.

Significance: Newman considers early ecclesiastical history fundamentally inhospitable to the characteristic claims of the Reformation.

9. A serious study of history leads away from Protestantism

Reference: An Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine, Introduction, §5, p. 8. Newman Reader - Development of Christian Doctrine - Introduction

“And this one thing at least is certain; whatever history teaches, whatever it omits, whatever it exaggerates or extenuates, whatever it says and unsays, AT LEAST THE CHRISTIANITY OF HISTORY IS NOT PROTESTANTISM . If ever there were a safe truth, it is this. And Protestantism has ever felt it so. I do not mean that every writer on the Protestant side has felt it; for it was the fashion at first, at least as a rhetorical argument against Rome, to appeal to past ages, or to some of them; but Protestantism, as a whole, feels it, and has felt it. This is shown in the determination already referred to of dispensing with historical Christianity altogether, and of forming a Christianity from the Bible alone: men never would have put it aside, unless they had despaired of it. It is shown by the long neglect of ecclesiastical history in England, which prevails even in the English Church. {8} Our popular religion scarcely recognizes the fact of the twelve long ages which lie between the Councils of Nicæa and Trent, except as affording one or two passages to illustrate its wild interpretations of certain prophesies of St. Paul and St. John. It is melancholy to say it, but the chief, perhaps the only English writer who has any claim to be considered an ecclesiastical historian, is the unbeliever Gibbon. TO BE DEEP IN HISTORY IS TO CEASE TO BE A PROTESTANT”

Newman argues that Christianity must be investigated as an objectively existing historical religion with demonstrable institutional and doctrinal continuity.

His argument is directed particularly against the hypothesis that the Christianity established by the apostles disappeared or became fundamentally corrupt, only to be restored during the Reformation.

He maintains that the existence of historical continuity creates a substantial burden of proof for those who claim that the original Christianity was radically different from the Christianity documented in subsequent centuries.

Newman’s statement is a direct rejection of the idea that Protestantism simply restores the original religion of the apostles.

10. The Roman Catholic Church is the closest historical continuation of the Church of the Fathers

Reference: An Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine, Chapter II, §3, no. 5, pp. 97–98. Newman Reader - Development of Christian Doctrine - Chapter 2

“the present communion of Rome is the nearest approximation in fact to the Church of the Fathers”

Newman argues that the Roman Catholic Church represents the closest living continuation of the Christianity of the Fathers.

He then develops the comparison through the figures of Athanasius and Ambrose, arguing that these Fathers, if they returned to life, would recognize the Roman Catholic communion as the one most familiar to their own religious and ecclesiastical experience.

This is one of Newman’s strongest historical claims concerning the continuity between patristic Christianity and the Roman Catholic Church.

SO NOW, HERE IS MY QUESTION TO THE INDIVIDUAL WHO TELLS ME, “YOU HAVE THE BUILDINGS, BUT WE HAVE THE FAITH,” AS THOUGH HE WERE THE TRUE REPRESENTATIVE OF ORTHODOXY AND I WERE SOME MEMBER OF A HERETICAL SECT:

DO YOU EVEN RECOGNIZE THE SHEER HYPOCRISY OF INVOKING ST. ATHANASIUS AS THOUGH HE WOULD HAVE RECOGNIZED HIS OWN FAITH IN YOURS?

I’m not the one who wrote “TO BE DEEP IN HISTORY IS TO CEASE TO BE A PROTESTANT”. Neither am I the one who wrote “WE SEEK IN VAIN AMONG THEM (the fathers N.D.R) for the evangelical doctrines of the exclusive authority of the Scriptures, justification by faith alone, the universal priesthood of the laity””

This is the verdict of history. And history shows that the Church of the first millennium, whether before or after Nicaea, would never have recognized anything remotely resembling orthodoxy in your theology.

So your sanctimonious habit of quoting St. Athanasius as though he were on your side needs to stop. He was not. None of the Fathers were. Nor was the Church of the first millennium.