It is not anacronistic. I’m covering the entire faith of the first millenium. Can you find a single Church father who believed that a Christian could contradict the teaching of the Church on the basis of his own understanding of the meaning of Scripture? Even evidences from the ninth century are ok.
Precisely. Can you find me a single evidence that in the first 15 centuries of Christianity the universal priesthood of the laity was an interpretation that was compatible with the faith of the Church?
Otherwise we run in circle .
I have provided ample historical documentations that show that the fathers were virtually universally “realist”. Here and here
They were not seen in this reductive manner. They were seen as assemblies of ordained Bishops that were protected from error by the Holy Spirit. Do you have any evidence to the contrary?
Again let me quote Schaff
Schaff explains that the doctrinal decisions of ecumenical councils came to be regarded as infallible because the Church understood them as enjoying the promised guidance of the Holy Spirit.
Schaff also said
“The authority of these councils in the decision of all points of controversy was supreme and final.”
Can you find me evidences that ecumenical councils in the early Church were actually believed to be authoritative but far from infallible gatherings of elders who were merely expressing their own “human all too human” interpretations of the Scriptures?