The purpose of this post is not to change the mind of the OP’s author, but to draw the attention of the curious and innocent, casual reader who thinks he or she has found a ‘treasure trove’ of truth and/or useful information in the unusual opinions of the OP’s author. Abandon that hope, all ye who read this thread.
- The OP’s author wrote:
- As I showed Bharat in my reply to his post (# 389)
- You sort of did and didn’t.
- You’ve said you “love Jesus”; and I asked you which one? The one whom Christians say was crucified, died, buried, and raised from the dead? Or the one whom Allah himself said in the Qur’an, was neither killed nor crucified? And you said : Tentative answer: Both."
- You show little regard for “the law of Non-contradiction” when you answer–even tentatively–“Both.”
- Granted, you haven’t discussed “Jesus matter”, whatever that is. But you clearly and definitely expressed a very unusual opinion when you affirmed that you love" the crucified and “never crucified” Jesus . Whether you like it or not: you only have three options:
- You agree with Christians that Jesus was crucified and died as the result of that crucifixion;
- You agree with Muslims and deny that Jesus died as the result of his crucifixion; or
- You agree with Jews and atheists who say that they don’t care.
- I suppose you could, in spite, of the information available, claim that you don’t know and, therefore, don’t have an opinion.
- You sort of did and didn’t.
- Bharat appears be confused and fails to realize that his previous claim: that YHWH and Allah are the same “God” and the claim that he simultaneously "loves “the Christians’ Jesus who was crucified and died as a result of that crucifixion” and “the Muslims’ Jesus who was neither crucified nor died as a result of that crucifixion” are “blanket statements” And I reject both of his claims.
- As for his first claim: “that YHWH and Allah” are the same “God”, I reject it–at the risk of being incorrectly called an “Islamophobe”–because:
- In Exodus 3:6. when Moses first encounters YHWH/, face-to-face, as it were: YHWH tells Moses: "I am the God of your father—the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob.” Then Moses hid his face, for he was afraid to look at God…
- A Jew would know that verse; a Christian should know that verse; and a Muslim would–I think–find that a strange thing to tell Muhammad.
- The likelihood of Allah telling Muhammad that that’s what he told Moses, is 0 (zero) %.
- In Exodus 3:6. when Moses first encounters YHWH/, face-to-face, as it were: YHWH tells Moses: "I am the God of your father—the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob.” Then Moses hid his face, for he was afraid to look at God…
- As for his first claim: “that YHWH and Allah” are the same “God”, I reject it–at the risk of being incorrectly called an “Islamophobe”–because:
- In response to my rejection of Bharat’s claim: “that Moses led the first people of the Exodus out of the Indus Valley”, Bharat wrote:
- The evidences consist of re-locating geographical locations and events, recorded in Exodus, to the Indus Valley and other locations, in effect: changing Biblical geographical locations and rewriting Exodus. Rather than present his opinions to a Jew-filled forum, he continues to evoke contention in Biologos with it/them.
- In all likelihood, a Jew, especially one who is a citizen of the modern state of Israel, would reject his theory. Moreover, Christians and Muslims would probably do so, too.
- Here, I share a definitely-Jewish perspective: Red Sea or Reed Sea: Where is Mount Sinai?.