I still have one of your posts that I have to address, can you remind me which one?
I am reluctant to copy wholesale AI but here is a link to my request for arguments against the Law of Contradiction
They are substantive and I do not claim to fully understand all of it. There is a lot of paradoxes, including the one suggested by @roy above.
This the the summary
- Paradoxes: Certain self-referential statements appear to generate genuine contradictions.
- Dialetheism: There may be propositions that are simultaneously true and false.
- Paraconsistent logic: Contradictions do not necessarily make all reasoning meaningless.
- Dialectical philosophy: Contradiction may be an essential feature of change and development
Richard
This can be true, if understood as a means to clarify and establish the truth.
Dogmatic definitions did not emerge out of nowhere. They arose from the need to clarify and establish the authentic meaning of the apostolic faith when certain Christians began advancing alternative doctrines (sometimes supported by serious, sophisticated, and perfectly reasonable arguments drawn from Scripture itself) that challenged the Church’s received understanding of that faith.
Of course, once you reject the very idea that God has provided the Church with the means to determine definitively what the apostolic faith is, what it actually teaches, and how the many genuinely ambiguous passages of Scripture are to be understood, the whole framework collapses. What remains is a theological free-for-all, in which everyone is ultimately left to decide for themselves what Christianity is supposed to mean.
Also, regarding this point specifically
I have never argued that every theological disagreement must necessarily be settled by a definitive judgment establishing which position is right and which is wrong. Not because objective truth does not exist, but because some disagreements concern matters of secondary importance, and because human knowledge is inevitably limited. We cannot expect to know everything.
What I reject is the idea that God would promise us the Holy Spirit to guide us into the fullness of truth, and that Christ himself would pray for the unity of all believers, only for Christians to be left without any reliable means of establishing a common faith even on the most fundamental questions of Christian doctrine.
Christ explicitly promised that the Spirit of truth would guide his disciples into all the truth (John 16:13 ). He also prayed that those who would come to believe in him through the apostles’ message might all be one, just as he and the Father are one.
But how could that prayer for unity be meaningfully fulfilled if Christians were left without any divinely protected means of reaching agreement on something as fundamental as the very nature and divinity of Christ himself?
This makes zero sense, even more so when we remember Efesians 4:5-6; “One Lord, one faith, one baptism, One God and Father of all, who is above all, and through all, and in you all.”
Do we really profess the same faith as the Arians, or as those modern evangelicals who reject the divinity of Jesus?
The answer is clearly no. Just as Christians who believe that the Eucharist is truly Christ himself do not profess the same faith as those who regard it as a merely symbolic commemoration, Nicene Christians and Arians cannot meaningfully be said to share the same faith concerning the nature of Christ.
And this brings us straight back to square one.
Was Christ somehow contradicting himself when he prayed that his followers might all be one, while knowing perfectly well that such unity could never be reliably achieved? If those who deny the Church’s infallible teaching authority are correct, Scripture can be (and demonstrably has been) interpreted in fundamentally contradictory ways, with no divinely guaranteed means of definitively resolving even the most consequential doctrinal disputes.
Was Christ, then, praying for a unity that he had provided his Church with no dependable means of attaining?
And what are we to make of Scripture itself, which explicitly condemns dissensions and factions as works of the flesh (Galatians 5:19–21)?
Would God really condemn Christians for divisions and factions while simultaneously leaving them without any infallible means of resolving the doctrinal disagreements that give rise to those divisions?
Would he command them to preserve the unity of the faith, warn them against being carried away by every wind of doctrine, and condemn those who promote divisions, while providing no definitive means of establishing what that faith actually teaches?
In other words, would God demand doctrinal unity while withholding from His Church the very means necessary to establish it whenever sincere and competing interpretations of Scripture prove irreconcilable?
That is the fundamental difficulty I see in your position. It is not merely that doctrinal disagreements exist. It is that, on your understanding, even disagreements concerning the very identity of Christ could remain permanently unresolved *, while Scripture nevertheless commands Christians to profess one faith and condemns the divisions that follow from their failure to do so.
To me, that is an impossibly difficult position to reconcile with Christ’s promises to His Church.
*And the moment we acknowledge that possibility, we must also confront its profoundly unsettling implications: for two thousand years, we may have been worshipping a creature rather than the Creator. In other words, we may have been guilty of idolatry all along.
I know you accept it. But accepting a position doesn’t, in itself, make that position coherent, let alone rationally defensible.
My position is unquestionably internally coherent. Someone may still believe that I’m wrong, but that is an entirely different matter from demonstrating an internal contradiction.
Can the same be said of your position? Is it internally coherent in the first place?
I preffered your first wording, it was less onfrontational.
The answer is yes.
(But you have already proven not to nderstand it)
Richard
How so? Stating something doesn’t make it true. My position is internally coherent and I can demonstrate it, you haven’t demonstrated the internal coherence of your position AT ALL.
Your position might be internally coherent were it not for the biblical passages that explicitly command Christians to preserve doctrinal unity, insist upon “one faith” (Ephesians 4:5), and condemn dissensions and factions as works of the flesh (Galatians 5:19–21).
You have yet to provide a rational defense of your position that adequately accounts for both the existence of these passages (including the explicit demand for unity of faith* in Ephesians ) and your conviction that the Church possesses no infallible means of definitively establishing the correct interpretation of Scripture, even when fundamental doctrines are at stake.
Simply accepting these two propositions is not enough. You need to explain how they can be reconciled without contradiction.You need to explain how your belief that there is no reliable means of achieving unity in the faith or definitively ruling out doctrinal error can be reconciled with Scripture’s explicit commands to preserve that very unity.
*If you can explain how Christians can genuinely profess one faith while holding mutually contradictory beliefs about fundamental doctrines, I’ll personally nominate you for a Nobel Prize.
you claim to support your position and do not.
Richard
'fraid not - I can’t remember one.
Fair enough Roy, I can’t remember either.
Your Scripture demonstrates your position it neither proves it nor disproves mine, because everything depends on how you understand the passages. Your understanding of the passages is based on your position.
My beliefs are coherent within my framework not yours.
It is fallacious to try and disprove my position by insisting on any part of your position.
You have been reported for the public accusation.
Richard
Cruel cruel world must I go on?
The answer, when dealing with someone like you, is an unqualified NOPE.
Sure, they are consistent within a framework that doesn’t aknowledge nor accounts for the incredibly clear biblical passages I have provided. If you pretend that those passages don’t exist and if you ignore almost the entire history of Christianity, then yes, your framework can be internally coherent.
Unfortunately for you, those passages exist. Even more unfortunately, they are very clear (which isn’t very usual for the Bible, the Bible is many things but self-evident clarity is really something that is not abundant in the Bible)
Precisely.
No, it only ‘assumes’ that a thing can be both itself and not itself at the same time.
No – a contradiction would be if you believed that a council was both ecumenical and non-ecumenical at the same time.
- Name a philosopher who claims that the law of non-contradiction is not necessarily always true.
- The most prominent contemporary example is Graham Priest, a philosopher and logician associated with dialetheism.
- Priest argues that some contradictions can actually be true—that there can be propositions \(P\) for which both \(P\) and \(\neg P\) are true. Thus he rejects the unrestricted/universal Law of Non-Contradiction (LNC).
- Importantly, Priest does not claim that every contradiction is true. Rather, he argues that some are. His principal examples involve logical and semantic paradoxes, especially the Liar paradox which is: “This sentence is false.”
- If the sentence is true, then what it says is the case, so it is false. If it is false, then what it says is not the case, which appears to make it true. Priest’s dialetheist position is that in cases of this sort, the proposition may genuinely be both true and false.
- He combines this with paraconsistent logic, which blocks the classical principle of explosion: from \(P\) and \(\neg P\), one cannot infer just anything whatsoever. Consequently, accepting one true contradiction doesn’t make every proposition true.
- Priest provides a very good counterexample to the idea that the Law of Non-Contradiction is simply an unquestionable prerequisite for all possible rational thought. One can construct a rigorous logical system in which LNC does not hold universally.
- But there is an important distinction: “the LNC is not necessarily universally true” is very different from “contradictions don’t matter.” Priest’s entire project depends upon distinguishing the relatively rare contradictions he regards as true from the enormous number of contradictions that are simply false.
HOW MANY MORE TIMES!
You rely on your view of the passages! And your view of truth, And your view of logic. And your insistence that there cannot be more than one view of…
Scripture, The Church, Theology, reality, Faith, Logic, Truth, In fact anything that you beleive
Richard
Blablabla. I gave you one more chance. I was wrong. Goodbye.
