The logic or illogic of contradiction

Since you claim that I am pushing for Catholic supremacy without providing any indipendent proof, I have to ask you two things.

Was Von Harnack pushing for Catholic supremacy when he wrote the following?

Can Adolf von Harnack, a Protestant (who never converted to Catholicism) historian and theologian, be considered an “independent source of evidence,” or should he, despite being a Protestant, be regarded as a Catholic apologist who was deliberately distorting historical truth to make it conform to his own beliefs?

Von Harnack essentially shattered any claims that Rome was originally just another Church among many, with no preeminent authority whatsoever (a claim that many Protestants like to push). Was he doing so for confessional reasons, or because, as a historian, he had to respect the historical evidence if he wanted to retain any intellectual and professional integrity whatsoever?

Sure thing, Shawn. Why don’t you just found your own Church? The Church of Shawn of the Last Days? It would be just another man-made church in the morass of man-made churches, all contradicting one another, that emerged from the revolution that took place five centuries ago.

Before the Reformation, the principal division within European Christianity was between the ancient apostolic Churches of the Latin West and the Byzantine East. (Other ancient communions, including the Oriental Orthodox Churches and the Church of the East, had separated over earlier Christological controversies)

Yet the Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches are still incredibly close, despite nearly a thousand years of separation: both preserve apostolic succession, the sacramental priesthood, the historic episcopate, the Eucharist as a true sacrifice and the Real Presence of Christ, the seven sacraments or holy mysteries, the veneration of Mary and the saints, and the authority of Sacred Scripture and Apostolic Tradition.

These are not peripheral similarities. They concern the very foundations of Christianity.

The schism between Rome and Constantinople developed through centuries of political, cultural, jurisdictional, and genuine theological disagreements, rather than through an attempt to establish an entirely new Christianity. In 1965, Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I acknowledged the mutual responsibilities surrounding the excommunications of 1054, which had originally targeted individuals rather than entire Churches.

Even more significantly, Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew I reaffirmed their commitment to restoring full communion in November 2025, and Bartholomew reiterated that hope in September 2026.

Bartholomew knows perfectly well that the Catholic Church cannot simply renounce her definitively proclaimed dogmas, including those concerning papal primacy and infallibility, and his pursuit of reconciliation demonstrates that he does not regard their differences as necessarily beyond the possibility of theological resolution.

Rome and Constantinople are seeking to restore an ancient communion, not to invent a new Christianity.

Now compare this with the Protestant Revolution: the Reformation did not merely separate ancient apostolic Churches that continued to profess substantially the same inherited faith. It gave rise to a new Christianity, founded upon distinctive theological principles that challenged fundamental aspects of the Christianity inherited from the preceding fifteen centuries and from the very beginning of the Church.

Sola Scriptura revolutionized the relationship between Scripture, Tradition, and ecclesiastical authority. The Reformers introduced distinctive doctrines of justification, while many Protestant traditions rejected the sacrificial character of the Mass, the sacramental priesthood, apostolic succession, and other elements of the common Eastern and Western Christian inheritance.

These were not merely jurisdictional disputes, but fundamental disagreements concerning the nature of the Church, divine Revelation, salvation, and sacramental life.

Nor did the Reformation establish a single alternative Christianity. Luther, Zwingli, Calvin, and the Anabaptists disagreed on essential theological questions, while subsequent centuries produced Baptists, Methodists, Adventists, Pentecostals, and numerous independent denominations.

According to the Center for the Study of Global Christianity, approximately 53,000 Christian denominations and rites are estimated to exist worldwide in 2026. Although this figure includes organizational and geographical distinctions and is not exclusively Protestant, the extraordinary proliferation of Protestant and Independent denominations is a defining feature of post-Reformation Christianity.

The ancient schisms separated Churches that preserved an extraordinarily extensive common apostolic and sacramental inheritance, Churches that still today are so close that a restoration of communion is by no means impossible: the Protestant Revolution, by contrast, gave rise to a new Christianity altogether, built upon distinctive theological principles and subsequently fragmented into countless competing denominations.

So, Shawn, your own manmade church would just add one church to the already existing 53,000 ones. Go ahead, I’m (not) sure you will find some followers.

1 Like