Just one more question, Roymond. It’s entirely possible that I’ve misunderstood your position, and if so, I apologize in advance.
But are you suggesting that bishops such as those discussed in this article should be given free rein?
Allow me to quote a passage from the article:
Asked if same-sex relationships were permissible, the German prelate replied: “Yes, it’s OK if it’s done in fidelity and responsibility. It doesn’t affect the relationship with God.”
As I said, I may have completely misunderstood your comment and what you were referring to. But if I haven’t, I think I can say with a fair degree of confidence that the less free rein German bishops have in matters of doctrine and the administration of the sacraments, the better. I have heard a number of them make statements that are plainly heterodox, including the one quoted above, as well as others concerning the Eucharist, women’s ordination (a door that has been definitively closed by John Paul II) and other doctrinal matters.
And as for Knor’s statement you replied to
As I have shown yesterday, unless he can demonstrate that the Protestant historian and theologian Adolf Von Harnack was wrong, the idea that the bishop of Rome is merely the head of the regional Church is not well supported (to put it mildly).
“From the close of the first century the Roman church was in a position of practical primacy over Christendom.” And at the end: “ it was a cardinal duty to “strengthen the brethren,” and this duty Rome amply discharged.”
Source: Adolf von Harnack, The Mission and Expansion of Christianity in the First Three Centuries, Vol. II, Book III, Excursus III, The Primacy of Rome in Relation to the Mission, p. 485. Adolf Harnack: Mission and Expansion of Christianity in the First Three Centuries - Christian Classics Ethereal Library
2. “Before general synods and patriarchs arose within the church, prior even to the complete development of the metropolitan system, there was a catholic confederation which embraced the majority of the Christian churches in the East and the West alike. It came into being during the gnostic controversies; it assumed a relatively final shape during the Montanist controversy; and its headquarters were at Rome. The federation had no written constitution. It did not possess one iota of common statutes. Nevertheless, it was a fact. Its common denominator consisted of the apostles’ creed, the apostolic canon, and belief in the apostolical succession of the episcopate.”
Source: Adolf von Harnack, The Mission and Expansion of Christianity in the First Three Centuries, Vol. II, Book III, Excursus II, The Catholic Confederation and the Mission, p. 483. Adolf Harnack: Mission and Expansion of Christianity in the First Three Centuries - Christian Classics Ethereal Library
3. “All these causes combined to convert the Christian communities into a real confederation under the primacy of the Roman Church”
Source: Adolf von Harnack, History of Dogma, Vol. II, Excursus Catholic and Roman, pp. 159–160. Adolf Harnack: History of Dogma - Volume II - Christian Classics Ethereal Library . Rome’s apostolic foundation and episcopal succession — BEFORE the quotation (pp. 153–154, 158–159)
Harnack considers Rome’s association with the apostles Peter and Paul, together with its early documentation of episcopal succession, an important element in its exceptional standing among the ancient Christian communities, he observes that Rome is the earliest Church for which historians can demonstrate the existence of a list of bishops extending back to the apostles. He also argues that the Roman bishops were among the first to employ the concept of apostolic episcopal succession as an institutional and doctrinal argument.
Most significantly, immediately before his statement about Roman primacy, Harnack returns to this subject. On page 159, he emphasizes that by approximately AD 180 the Roman Church could point to an episcopal succession tracing its origins to Peter and Paul.Thus, apostolic succession is not something Harnack introduces after declaring Rome’s primacy. It is part of the historical evidence he has already presented when he reaches that conclusion.
Harnack also argues that the Roman Church developed an especially clear and authoritative formulation of the apostolic rule of faith.
According to his reconstruction, by around AD 180 Rome possessed a precisely formulated baptismal confession regarded as a standard of apostolic teaching, which, during the Gnostic controversies, enabled the Roman Church to distinguish what it regarded as authentic apostolic Christianity from competing doctrines.
On page 159, immediately before his conclusion concerning Roman primacy, Harnack emphasizes Rome’s firmness during these controversies and her established rule of faith.
In other words, Rome’s doctrinal authority is not presented merely as a consequence of the city’s political importance. Harnack also regards the Roman Church’s perceived fidelity to apostolic teaching as an important reason for its influence throughout Christendom.
This is especially relevant because his historical argument concerns not only Rome’s prestige but also her role in establishing and maintaining doctrinal unity across different Christian communities.
Harnack describes the Roman Church as exercising an exceptional influence over Christian communities outside its own geographical region.
He discusses several pieces of evidence.
First, he examines the First Epistle of Clement, written to the Corinthians toward the end of the first century. Harnack interprets this intervention as evidence that Rome already exercised a particular responsibility for communities beyond its immediate jurisdiction.
Second, he examines Ignatius of Antioch’s letter to the Romans, arguing that Ignatius acknowledged Rome’s distinctive precedence among the Churches.
Third, he discusses Dionysius of Corinth, whose correspondence with the Roman bishop Soter illustrates the extensive assistance provided by Rome to Christian communities across the Mediterranean.
So, if Knor is willing and capable to substantiate his idea that the Church of Rome was merely the leader of a regional Church and didn’t have a practical (not merely ceremonial) primacy over the other Churches, I’m afraid he will have to do a considerable amount of work to demonstrate that the Protestant historian and theologian Adolf Von Harnack wasn’t offering a coherent and truthful historical account.
I provide historical evidence, if the counter argument to historical evidence is “methinks” I don’t know how much credibility this modus operandi possesses.
But if he possesses historical counter-evidence to the evidence Harnack (a Protestant historian and theologian, clearly someone with a vested interest in defending Rome…) provided , let him show such evidence.
I have urged him, actually I have begged him, to provide the evidence that the early Church, even the earliest pre-nicene Church, would have been compatible with his beliefs (Rome as a mere “churches among other churches”, symbolic Eucharist, private interpretation of the text that superseded and could contradict and oppose the interpretation of the Church etc etc etc) and would have supported them and judged them orthodox. So far, I have seen none of that.