Refuting fallacious ID arguments and explaining randomness in biology for students

Before Newton, they were sucked downward by the breathing of the giant tortoise upon which the flat earth rests.

Only after Newton were they pulled toward the center of the earth’s spherical mass by gravity.

Peace,
Chris

1 Like

No time to play today, but @EricMH and I have been through this all before. Perhaps he can summarize my arguments for me? :wink:

1 Like

When Paul was penning Romans 1, scientific knowledge was far less prominent that it is today. Would you agree?

Of course, the Epicureans were in Athens and they had a certain cultural cachet. Paul’s challenge to them is to think more broadly … to ponder with the heart … to imagine with faith. Paul is making a non-ID argument. At bottom, Paul is asking: How can anything so big and structured exist at all? Why is there a universe with regular and beautiful processes?

Perhaps you are confusing Paul with Paley, whose name is spelled quite similarly. But Paley did not come along for another 1800 years.

Peace,
Chris

1 Like

@Christy, one of my favorite demonstrations of the power of evolution is Genetic Cars, which is a simplified and supped-up version of the original BoxCar2D.com.

Genetic Cars runs 20 car generations simultaneously on a single track, and you can see the progression of developments in a much shorter span of time. This would be suitable for an in-class demo, letting it run behind you while you present on the topic.

BoxCar2d uses a simple physics engine and a genetic algorithm to “evolve” cars. There are lots of options, and Car Designer, and multiple tracks that will evolve different specialties. The drawback is that it is slow, running a single car at a time, sometimes requiring hours for major progress to develop. The greater flexibility might allow for interesting student projects.

There was mention (by Eric, I think) of Winston Ewerts Dependency Graph, which deserves praise for being the first (and only) ID paper to present and test a scientific hypothesis using accepted methodology. Unfortunately it suffers from some flaws and misconception. There was an extended discussion on the Dependency Graph at Peaceful Science some time back.

2 Likes

What difference does it make if something is “naturally occurring?”

David wrote in Psalm 139:13 (NIV2011)

13 For You created my inmost being; You knit me together in my mother’s womb.

Yet there is nothing to indicate that David and the Jews were ignorant of the “facts of life,” and the conception and birth of David were nothing other than a “natural event.”

God works through natural events and why not? God created the universe and all that is in it. God designed it and brought it into being. Of course we should not be foo0led into thinking that our earth is God’s ultimate design. All forms of the universe are cherished by God.
@Christy, @EastwoodDC, @EricMH, @Chris_Falter, @T_aquaticus
The universe was created through the Big Bang. Most scientists agree with this statement as do Christians. We cannot say from where the singularity that caused the Big Bang came, but Christians and science agree on the Big Bang.

In the same way we should be able to agree that evolution created humans and the other fauna and flora on our earth. Now we might disagree as to how evolution works, just as I disagree with some on survival of the fittest, but it is clear from the fossil record that that biota evolved over time through a natural process.

I believe that we can come to a consensus if we forget our ideologies and look to what we have in common, which is the logos. Logos is a philosophical term referring to the rational strect56ure or form of the universe. Science studies Biology, which means that science believes that life has a rational form or structure. Christianity worships the Logos Who gave form and meaning to the universe. All three agree as to the existence of a logos which gives form and structure to the universe. All three look at the logos from different perspectives.

We need to work together, rather than attack each other. . . .

1 Like

Excellent, I will check it out. Thanks.

SETI essentially examines certain accessible phenomena (In this case cosmic radio waves), but recognizes that certain patterns or attributes are more indicative of, and thus better explained by, intelligent or purposeful agency, rather than by any naturally occurring unguided process.

ID, similarly, examines certain accessible phenomena (In their case certain biological features), but recognizes that certain patterns or attributes are more indicative of, and thus better explained by, intelligent or purposeful agency, rather than by any naturally occurring unguided process.

So the relevance is, simply, they are using near-identical philosophical or epistemological standards and methods. I hear so often on this page that it is somehow inappropriate or impossible for “science”, as science, to try to detect intelligent agency. But then no one seems to object to SETI on the very same grounds.

Either it is indeed possible to use the scientific method to detect signs of intelligent agency, or it isn’t. If it is valid for SETI to attempt to do so, it must be valid for ID to do attempt such as well. If it is invalid for ID to seek or argue evidence of intelligent agency, then it is just as invalid for SETI to do the same, and SETI must be rejected as being “unscientific”.

Otherwise, it starts to look very much like nothing more than special pleading.

But SETI looks for something natural and comprehensible, namely indications of transmission data similar to what we ourselves produce. So we have lots to go on. But indications of Designer produced data has no such basis to go on. All ID results must ultimately be indeterminable between divine and alien origins.

5 Likes

Massimo pigliucci in “Nonsense On Stilts” argued it isn’t quite science. May be worth a read

2 Likes

Picking at nits, the Big Bang happened after the creation of the universe. The universe already existed as a singularity before it began to rapidly expand (i.e. the Big Bang, which was actually very small and did not make a bang).

Agreed. We can argue over the natural mechanisms, and we can have different beliefs about the deeper metaphysical and philosophical meanings. However, it is entirely different to reject well established and strongly evidenced natural explanations in favor of supernatural explanations.

4 Likes

True. In addition, I have never seen a formal definition of an ID-generated hypothesis that would distinguish between observations explained by evolution and observations that could only be explained by ID.

Peace, Chris

4 Likes

Right, getting back to the question of what has shaped the life we see on the planet it isn’t about aliens. It’s about ruling out natural processes. Seems like the ID answer always boils down to “but how else?” And that just locks the question up in a mysterious black box. Answering who did it isn’t the same as answering the how question.

Edited to add that The Who question isn’t even a point of contention between the views espoused here and ID. Just how.

3 Likes

That is precisely correct, and quite readily acknowledged by most ID-supporters as I understand it. and the problem with this is, what, exactly?

out of curiosity, have you seen a formal definition of a SETI-generated hypothesis that would accomplish something similar in said field?

Well I’m used to being told by the religious how an infinite regress must be avoided at all cost. If the apparent designed aspects within organisms were merely and always the work of earlier aliens we’d still have to account for the alleged design aspects present in the earliest aliens. (The same can be said about relying on God as a first cause, of course.).

1 Like

I am dismayed at this note, yet I don’t understand. Where did I say it is invalid to look for intelligence? Please let me know if I am still not communicating well. Thanks.

Suppose we found, by SETI or any other means, evidence not only of intelligence, but also a code that came from a Person, saying they had created the universe…and on top of that, this code extended to everything else in the universe we observed, confirming that was the case. It still would not be possible, to my understanding, to say to science, “There is no further question to ask here of how this intelligence evolved from inanimate things.” Science does not, to my understanding, affirm any such thing. I am not trying to be difficult. It is a sincere question. Using science, how would anyone find a question which had a divine element above questioning?
Thank you for not ascribing ill purpose to me.

The post by @markd also seems relevant.

In reformed epistemology, It is believed that internal witness can confirm a given set of beliefs. The thorny part is trying to get others with a similar passionate certainty, with opposing beliefs, to agree with you.
Sometimes reasoning from observations of the outside world can clarify these questions. Sometimes it can not. I am grateful to God for His mercy and compassion, that He knows exactly our frailty, as He made us this way, and struggled like as we do…so we do not have to fear to question. Further, with this understanding, we can attribute well meaning to those who do not agree with us…as I am sure you also have.

Thank you.

1 Like

Very well put, I think! Thanks.

1 Like

Kind of not, because God, pretty much by definition, is uncaused.

1 Like

Well, John Lennox said the same thing in a debate with Richard Dawkins, so many do accept that concept…but for many, at one time (particularly with Greek philosophy) I think that was not the case. And can science say anything is uncaused? It seems to me it is a tool to ask questions and find out answers? Thanks. I am still learning.

I didn’t mean to suggest that it could. And in modern Western conversations, I don’t think we’re typically debating polytheism. (The interview with Praveen was good.) I suppose conceptually you could have a panoply of uncaused beings, but again, that is not really the conversation we are having. And if God isn’t uncaused, then he is just an alien. Of course, he is alien to many’s desired way of thinking, but that’s another sense of the word (not to mention another part of speech :slightly_smiling_face:).

1 Like