For those of us not inclined to attribute ultimate origins to the intentionality of an over God, that definition has always seemed facile and gratuitous. It tends to work well into a lot of circular logic.
I don’t get worked up over that. This is not some conspiracy as far as I’m concerned. I do believe that there is something real that gives rise to and continues to support God belief. Respecting that and promoting its importance in society seems like a good thing. I might be happier if this could be done on a more down to earth footing. But who knows how well that would work across a wide swath of society? I don’t know but I’m not optimistic about its chances. So if traditional approaches need some supernatural bells and whistles to work, maybe that is alright? But I applaud the efforts of this site to straddle the traditional and the frontiers of science. That is a step in the right direction I think.
I guess I was thinking whether the positing of God’s existence as a creator (there are a lot more roles) just pushes the question back further…it could have been that He evolved, too. Just conjecturing and musing. It is not my area of expertise.
Thanks for the article. From skimming there appears to be much I agree with there. Scientism is a mistake which stems from so much enthusiasm for an unreasonable adherence to rationality. Rationality is parasitic upon another human dimension which people generally under value. I don’t read any of the evangelizing atheist gurus because they epitomize that imbalance.
Not sure when I’ll get to it because McGilchrist’s The Master and His Emissary is drawing me back in and his analysis of all this is so much more worthwhile. But it is no page turner and I did just pick up my next novel from the library, Susan Choi’s Trust Exercise. Those of us not raised on scripture need to get more stories in their diet.
In this very thread, @MarkD pointed out that SETI researchers can draw on numerous electromagnetic radiation samples known to be of intelligent origin. These can provide the basis for a Bayesian analysis of electromagnetic radiation from extra-solar system sources.
On the other hand, we have exactly zero samples of known intelligent origin that would provide a proper Bayesian prior for genomic or phenotypic changes that occurred millions and billions of years ago. Unless you believe aliens might have stalked the earth millions and billions of years ago to conduct breeding experiments.
I think what I recalled as relevant to your question,
is the second Mangalwadi quote about halfway down the page below the heading Man has the Ability to Reason:
Much before the birth of the modern age, the medieval Augustinian monasteries began doing something that became unique to Christianity. When a young man devoted his life to seek and to serve God, the monastery required him to spend years studying the Bible, languages, literature, logic, rhetoric, mathematics, music, theology, philosophy, and practical arts such as agriculture, animal husbandry, medicine, metallurgy, and technology. Thus, the monastery – which was an institution for cultivating the religious life – began producing a peculiarly rational person, capable of researching; writing books; developing technology and science; developing capitalism; and developing complex, rational legal and political systems. The Bible became the ladder on which the West climbed the heights of educational, technical, economic, political, and scientific excellence.[15]
You might not want to miss reading the rest of the supporting material.
2 Likes
Klax
(The only thing that matters is faith expressed in love.)
191
Where does Dawkins use the term design apart from in a colloquial sense? Looking out the window I see the cut lawn and am reminded that the graminae have been designed by nature (evolution) not to have (stem) apical meristems as they wouldn’t survive grazing; they have intercalary meristems. That sort of thing.
My apologies if we are talking past each other, and absolutely no ill motive assumed. mainly i was responding to your original inquiry that “it appears to me that ID is asking science to find an area in the universe that science can’t explain.”
I suggested that this is indeed not what ID is suggesting, rather their method is essentially the same as SETI (which also is not seeking something science can’t explain). ID is indeed not theological nor metaphysical. there are agnostics who support ID. ID proper, as a scientific endeavor, makes no claims about the identity nor the nature of the intelligence under discussion - indeed, by its very nature it cannot. whether the designing intelligence be natural nor supernatural. And thus, indeed, it is not seeking “an area that science can’t explain,” any more than SETI is doing the same. It strictly limits its query to asking whether or not certain phenomena bear the marks of design, or if they are better explained by purely unguided, naturalistic processes.
So i was merely trying to point out that, in the same manner that SETI proceeds and limits itself to what science alone can say, ID limits itself similarly, and makes no claims whatsoever about anything being divine, supernatural, or the like.
if we as Christians want to, by faith, independently of science, identify the intelligent causal agent as God, then we may very well do so, and I think we would indeed be quite right to do so… but this step is taken by faith and trust in God and what he has revealed, not through “science.” at that point we have indeed left science behind. Thus I would agree with what you wrote above, and I would agree, as well as with what Mark wrote above: science as science could indeed not confirm that something was in any sense “supernatural.”
(Now, I think I may be missing something in what you wrote above, because philosophically, if a (mere?) “person” was responsible for having created the universe, as I understand the terms, this “person” could simply not be the result or product of the very universe he created. A person could not start the evolutionary process and then emerge from the very process he began?)
So can I propose an alternate scenario: If God, for whatever reason, decided to start communicating with people through cosmic radio waves, and began somehow sending clearly, discernible and coherent messages through the natural medium of cosmic radio waves…
The Scientists at SETI, using all their scientific methods and procedures and principles:
1] Could indeed detect and recognize “intelligent agency” in those transmissions. but
2] Could not, through any scientific means, identify the sender of these messages as the supernatural creator of the universe, nor of being of divine or supernatural agency. science would not and could not be examining “God” in any sense, they could only examine a phenomenon existing within the physical world, and recognizing “intelligent agency” within that medium.
In this manner I am suggesting ID is near identical in approach and methods scientifically to the methods of SETI. Neither is, nor could they, trying to find “something science cannot explain.” They are seeking something that unguided, undirected natural processes cannot explain, and which are better explained by purposeful, intelligent agency.
2 Likes
Klax
(The only thing that matters is faith expressed in love.)
193
No it isn’t. Whereas ID is making up something that science can’t explain that doesn’t exist. ET does of course, but SETI can never detect it. Directed panspermia is science fiction as is panspermia above chemicals.
infinite regress may be a philosophical problem, but the possibility of an infinite regress should never keep scientists from doing science.
if there were, in fact, “designed aspects within organisms”, a scientist should be able to recognize that phenomenon without worrying about any possible philosophical consequences, no?
Francis Crick hypothesized his “directed panspermia” hypothesis, and it is also open to that criticism, of “well, where did the designing aliens come from?” But I would say that science, as science, should not shut down his hypothesis on the mere basis that it may lead to further questions.
I am so sorry, Colleagues. @Dale just pointed out something I had missed. I had written something above that sounded snarky and changed it. I had written "Just saying"when I really had intended “just musing,” or something like that. I was tired and did not realize what I had written. I did not grow up in a current American culture most of the time till I was 19, and sometimes I have found myself missing things like this, even though I have been here a long time. Maybe that is it…or maybe I am just dense. Either way, I am horrified by the way that sounded. I did not mean that at all. I appreciate the good attitude of all of you. Thanks so much for pointing it out @Dale. @moderators@Daniel_Fisher@Chris_Falter@MarkD@Klax
Be absolved of your sins, Randy, … says the sinner to the saint.
Do we need a Biologos ‘confessional’ for conscientious folks like you? Somebody like Hillary could don a large authoritative hat, and tell you to recite five Hail Marys and the first two laws of thermodynamics … or something like that. Not sure we can accommodate with holy water right now, though.
Thank you I wanted to put it publicly, because I was worried that it would give a bad atmosphere to the discussion. I was trying to find a clip I remember from Andy Griffith, where he grabbed his foot and said, “Do you see this big foot? How did it get from down there into my mouth?” --but haven’t found it.
The distinction between what SETI does and what ID does has been hashed out many times before. I think we can avoid repeating that, but Google if you must.
With a single exception (Ewert’s Directed Graph test) there are no hypotheses proposed by ID that are testable and distinguish between ID and evolution. This is the root of most ID/Evolution arguments, because most people arguing against ID miss this point and argue from a false premise (that ID is testable).
You might argue a contradiction this way (presuming ID is true), IF there were any definition of Designer/Designer to contradict. But of course, ID doesn’t do that.
Agreed. There is no disproving the influence of God/Designer in this process, and little point in arguing about it. Claims of “proof” are another mater.