Finally got the time to listen straight through and it is interesting. I’d pulled a few different passages but in the end the question of how to apply the Bali example to our case brings up a bigger worry for me.
In most of the world, someone’s faith tradition, the way in which they experience the world is part and parcel of their day to day reality. Here in the United States, and in much of the Western world, we have this weird thing between secular and religious, like we divide out like, well, I’m religious on Sunday, but the rest of the time I’m secular. That’s absurd. That’s not the way belief works, right? In that case, it’s not actually belief, it’s something else. So if we recognize that what people believe, and let’s use, you know, faith traditions here in this context, or who they are in the world, how they see and feel and interpret and perceive the world for real, then connecting those interpretations, those experiences and thinking through them with scientific data, or other kinds of insights or information, and finding places where they join and touch and shape one another, that’s powerful.
What I worry is that our numbers create real problems of scale for working to address real and present problems such as what we are experiencing in trying to address this pandemic. It doesn’t seem that our common values and understandings are all that common or all that compelling across the population. Even within just the Christian population of this country there are so many schisms not only denominationally but also in terms of degree to which faith commitments are something which only bear on ones life on Sundays while secular options vary widely.
Early on in the conversation I was interested to know how what I had just read last night in McGilchrist’s The Master and His Emissary about human belief would mesh with what the guest had to say. But I guess really comparing the two was beyond me even though both are thought provoking in their own way. There again the search for a common understanding comes up short at least for me.