From Cladograms to Variation Maps: Exploring Biblical Kinds with Genetic and Anatomical Data

I’m noticing multiple tensions in your reply. You affirm that providence and descent are not mutually exclusive, yet you need an explicit permission from Scripture to accept common descent despite the evidence from genetics. But if we accept that the world He created is intelligible, fine-tuned for discovery and reliable, that same fine-tuning forbids a young world and points to common descent. Do you believe we have to presuppose God actively deceives with a false History to test our faith?

You insist on the creation week framing, I genuinely want to see if you’re consistent with this reasoning by asking : Was there an end to the seventh day? The text closes six of them with an evening and a morning but it never closes the seventh.

So is God in a permanent rest to this day, or does it mean the text had a different purpose and accommodated itself to a pre-scientific audience, to convey theological truths about the meaning of our existence? None of that excludes a Genealogical Adam and Eve if that’s what you’re worried about.

I’m also noticing something more subtle. You’re not saying where you derive the assumption of finite boundaries for species, or whether an old universe wouldn’t leave room for the variation and renewal of species that Psalm 104 explicitly supports, as well as predation written there as a feature of the natural order and its ecological balance. You can see what is said in the text “lions roaring for their prey”, “everything fed in its season” and “you renew the face of the ground.”

Your perspective sounds to me like God is only a first mover, not the One who continually sustains reality while speaking things into existence from the beginning.

I’d like to touch on another thing you say:

What you’re missing here is the fact that in scientific inquiry we lean on the more elegant, harmonious explanation not on a presupposed conclusion. We infer the best explanation by accounting for the explanatory power of a model and its consistency with Occam’s razor. That’s what makes the difference between a metaphysical hypothesis and a scientific theory. Thing is they don’t abide by the same rules and Science also has epistemological boundaries which means, it will never say anything about the why of Creation. It might inform whether your metaphysics is justified but it can’t conclude one because it wasn’t designed to achieve something like that, unless we discard the principle of methodological naturalism.

Methodological naturalism presupposes no such competition with or replacement of God’s working in creation. In the seventeenth-century context, such neutrality functioned as an injunction to understand nature on its own terms, implying natural philosophers did not invoke God’s unmediated action in creation to explain events and patterns in creation. The ultimate purpose of MN was to glorify God through understanding secondary causes much in the spirit of Magnus.82

Then I hope you’ll understand why common descent is a scientific theory. It was produced by a body of experts making predictions, not individuals relying on their personal preference. Science accepts the examination of its hypotheses inside an intellectual immune system, and it arrived there by consensus with converging data. The category error is to think it is either nature or design.

To be clear, I’m not dimissing your app all I’m saying is, to propose a scientific model one needs to abide by the rules of science, overcome falsification and be testable. Natural theology doesn’t do that because God isn’t a “Force” nor a scientific object to begin with.

“For we can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth.”

2 Corinthians 13.v8

2 Likes

I know Bishop’s paper, including its qualifications. One detail deserves particular attention: on page 22, footnote 36, Bishop explains that Boyle did not extend methodological naturalism to the origin of matter or living creatures, which Boyle regarded as immediately created by God. This does not establish my biological proposal, but it shows that the historical case you cite for studying secondary causes does not itself require common descent. On pages 13–14, Bishop describes that method as serving a particular, limited purpose. I accept investigating natural processes. What I contest is treating acceptance of that method as already settling the historical and theological conclusions under discussion.
Your appeal to an intelligible and reliable creation does not, by itself, establish either an old earth or common descent. Those conclusions require their own empirical arguments. Likewise, saying that a different history would make God deceptive adds a theological judgment. Which specific observations would require a fabricated history rather than a different starting condition? That needs to be argued case by case. I cannot establish my alternative merely by proposing it, but neither does the accusation of divine deception settle the comparison.
On scientific method, elegance and harmony are not sufficient criteria. Observation, explicit hypotheses, testable predictions, independent checks and possible failure matter. Occam’s razor helps compare explanations; it does not turn the preferred explanation into a deductive certainty. For the ERV argument, the relevant discussion is therefore about what particular models predict, which observations test those predictions, and how sensitive the conclusions are to their assumptions. Historical inference can be scientific without replaying the past. But the distinction between directly testing a mechanism and reconstructing a particular history still matters. Neither expert consensus nor theological confidence removes that distinction.
You also describe my view as reducing God to a first mover, despite my explicit affirmation that God continually sustains creation. My synthesizer analogy concerns the relationship between an originating design and subsequent variation. It is not a complete account of God’s relationship to the world. Please address the position I have stated rather than extend the analogy into a denial I have never made. Psalm 104 is entirely compatible with my belief in continuing divine provision. Its descriptions of predation and renewal do not independently establish either universal ancestry or the original condition of creation.
Regarding the seventh day, the absence of the evening-and-morning formula deserves interpretation. But your alternatives are not exhaustive. A completed seventh day and a continuing state of rest from the initial creative work are not logically incompatible. Nor would a distinctive literary treatment of the seventh day automatically remove temporal meaning from the preceding six. You still need to explain why your conclusion follows and how it relates to Exodus 20:11.
My proposed biological boundaries need empirical definition; calling them biblical does not supply that definition. Equally, calling your account providential does not make its theology an experimental result. Bishop’s distinction between scientific investigation and metaphysical naturalism is useful precisely because it prevents that conflation. I am asking for the same precision throughout: which claims are observations, which are tested historical inferences, and which are theological interpretations? Your scientific case should stand on its evidence, and your interpretation of Genesis should stand on its textual arguments. Neither should be treated as established merely by borrowing the authority of the other.

Boyle is correct, science doesn’t explain the ultimate origin of matter, what it does is describe natural processes within the order of secondary causes without negating intelligent causation per se. The difference between us and him though, is that we now have genetics and the paleontology tree converging with a history of descent, leaving remnants such as shared pseudogenes and ERVs. I’m not arguing those are junk, the research keeps discovering adaptive mechanisms consistent with common ancestry.

What you’re doing though, is setting an arbitrary boundary between natural processes and a presupposed conclusion derived from theology that we can’t really justify from Scripture. You merely assume the age of the cosmos from the genealogy of Adam, with the premise of God creating in 24h solar days even before the lights that were made to mark the days were set in place on the fourth day. I’ll let you judge if this is more robust than observations from radioactive decay, redshifts, or the neutrinos and light we watched arrive from Supernova 1987A, 168,000 years after that star died.

Hugh Ross and the guys at Reason to Believe could explain to you better than me why Exodus 20:11 doesn’t imply a young universe, i’m not going to argue that point quite frankly.

What I’d like to know is why you dodged my question about where the assumption of boundaries within species comes from. So let me put the question this way :
How do you test the idea of a young universe, or your alternative for descent, if we have to assume the laws and their constants are unreliable? You’ll never get at the how of Creation with that premise, because any data can be read as proving your point, which again isn’t compatible with scientific inquiry in a Popperian sense.

My approach is the same one as Augustine, the world was created complete in potential form from the beginning, the natural order is purposeful (teleological) and mortality serves that order otherwise there is no need for renewal in accordance with Psalm 104. Augustine called those potencies rationes seminales, meaning seed principles unfolding in time. That is actually close to what you call created starting systems, but the difference between us is that I let the genome say how far those potencies ran, while you fence them for theological reasons at a line you have not yet drawn. That’s what you’ve said and keep implying.

Still, what you’ve done is reduce your hypothesis to a metaphysical speculation, while setting aside the work of experts reported in peer reviewed papers as if their converging inference were only a naturalist worldview. Is it honest to the truth?

1 Like

It says nothing about animal diets.

Papers on the subject about. Unloaded, it would have broken apart from hogging and twisting; loaded it would have splintered from sagging and twisting.

From what I’ve seen they did an analysis assuming the structure was sound and testing the seaworthiness as a rigid block – which showed good proportions for high seas but preferably with a tiller.

Are not about numbers and days, they are about balance and order and rhythm.

Is not talking about astronomy.

Which does not compare human days to human days, it compares human days to divine days.

All three of your expressions show that your starting point is modern science.

Rests on treating it as a science book or at least a scientifically accurate report – that’s revealed with you phrase “what God actually did”, which is a piece of MSWV.

But you’re not taking them seriously, you’re turning them into science – and modern science is an alien worldview, with a different definition of what constitutes truth at the root of it.

That is is two kinds of ancient literature at once – brilliantly done as polemic – and not anything remotely resembling a news report.

Already dealt with: six divine days requiring a reflection in Creation of six human days makes the command of the Sabbath “more real” in ANE terms that treating deity as following human days.

There you go looking at it with a MSWV again, like it’s a newspaper report. It isn’t.

Historical reference (1) is incidental and (2) not done in the modern worldview you are starting from.

Yes, all the low flat land on the known world of the earth-disk is portrayed as flooded. That fits a monster Mesopotamian flood perfectly.

For starters, eretz does not mean “globe”, it means "land:, i.e. the dry land known in the original context. To read it as “globe” is to introduce material from a MSWV.
And to read “all” is literal when it isn’t in nearby chapters does the same thing; it tramples not just context but Hebrew vocabulary usage.

No, the “global” reading is a linguistic artifact of translation from one language to a second and to a third (or fourth) and from one corresponding worldview to another. In context, the Hebrew only indicates that the known world of the writer(s) and initial audience was flooded.

Yes, evolution being one of those.

Which is historical propaganda.

1 Like

And does rest require the cessation of work?

There is a direct methodological parallel here that is overlooked in your demand for the establishment of boundaries. We lack an exhaustive account of what a given biological system can produce through recombination and environment-dependent epigenetic regulation alone. The fact is that, even in the absence of mutation, there exists a finite range of variation that allows for significant adaptation. While mutation would expand this range, it would be impossible to determine which phenotypes were already part of the mutation-free variation potential and which emerged by transcending those limits through mutation. Consequently, an observed change cannot be classified, a priori, as either an expression of pre-existing potential or a step beyond its previous boundaries. To make such a distinction, we would first need an independently defined description of the variation potential derived solely from recombination and epigenetics. This is precisely the difficulty you point out in relation to my proposed “variation spaces.” Recombination can rearrange existing genetic material, and epigenetic responses are contingent upon the system’s biological capacities; yet, these constraints do not provide a complete overview of all attainable phenotypes. The introduction of mutations alters the question without automatically answering it: what additional forms become accessible—through which viable intermediate steps and under what conditions? A finite experiment can never fully encompass every conceivable developmental path. Thus, you face a problem quite similar to mine: you cannot ascertain the full extent to which evolution is possible, and I cannot substantiate the precise limits of the variation potential inherent to “basic types”.
The uncertainty therefore cuts both ways: the absence of an observed transition does not establish a permanent boundary, while observing adaptation does not, by itself, establish the full range of transformations a lineage can undergo. This does not make the historical evidence for competing accounts equally strong. It does mean that demanding an exhaustive map of my proposed variation limits goes beyond asking whether a particular boundary hypothesis is testable. Specific hypotheses can be tested without either side possessing a complete account of biological possibility. You may argue that common descent is better supported, but that case must rest on evidence that distinguishes finite variation from mutation-based evolution — not simply on my inability to establish an absolute limit of variation that evolution would alledgedly have exceeded. Also the absence of a demonstrated limit of evolution is not, by itself, evidence that a particular transition occurred.

St.Roymond, repeatedly calling my reading a “modern scientific worldview” does not establish that it is one. People understood claims about actual events long before modern science existed. A text can convey theology, use literary patterns and challenge other religious beliefs while still referring to things that happened. You need to explain why those features rule out the historical claims I see here. There is also a straightforward problem with your statement that Genesis 1:29–30 says nothing about animal diets: verse 30 explicitly assigns green plants as food to the animals it describes. Whether that establishes an exclusively vegetarian original creation is a further interpretive question, but saying it says nothing about their food is incorrect. Regarding the Ark, Hong and colleagues did include a structural analysis involving wave-induced bending and the required thickness of structural members. Describing the study as merely testing a rigid block leaves that out. Its assumptions can be challenged, but please identify the engineering papers you invoke and explain which calculations establish inevitable failure for the proposed construction. On the creation days, order and rhythm do not exclude duration. Calling them “divine days” rather than ordinary days is itself an interpretation requiring support. Exodus 20:11 explicitly grounds the human working week in God’s creation and rest. What in that passage establishes that the two sets of days have different durations? Nor does reading God’s actions as real events imply that he needed six days; my position is that he chose to create as the text describes. On the Flood, my argument does not depend on translating eretz as “globe.” It depends on the combined scope of the mountains, the waters and the destruction described in Genesis 7. A word’s ability to mean “land,” and the nonliteral use of “all” elsewhere, do not by themselves establish a local meaning here. You describe all the low, flat land being flooded, but the passage expressly mentions mountains being covered. How does your reading account for that wording? Regarding your second post, rest need not mean that God ceases every activity. Genesis 2 connects his rest to the completion of his creation work; continued providence does not contradict that completion. An ongoing rest also does not, by itself, establish the duration of the preceding six days. These are disagreements over what the passages mean. Labelling my interpretation modern, or yours ancient, does not resolve them. What I am asking for is the textual argument that makes your reading preferable.

Hello Henry,

In thread on John Walton’s approach to Genesis, St.Roymond explained and defended his understanding of Genesis 1, particularly its emphasis on order and temple imagery:

You might find it useful as additional context for your discussion.

Arvis, your ERV argument needs to distinguish biological inheritance from the reuse of a shared starting design. Consider separately built software products that use overlapping sets of libraries and templates. They can share unused code, disabled functions and even identical errors in corresponding places. If those templates are themselves organised hierarchically, their reuse can also produce nested patterns. The finished products need not descend from one another for those patterns to exist, although their code does have a shared source. Applied to my proposal, different created prototypes could contain shared modules, followed by inheritance and modification within each kind. That is a different explanation from repeated independent infections coincidentally hitting the same sites. I am not claiming that this analogy establishes the biological explanation or reproduces the full ERV dataset. It shows why shared positions, disabled sequences and nesting do not logically exclude a shared-design account. The remaining question is comparative: what does each specified model predict, and which observations favour one over the other? My proposal needs those predictions, but your argument also needs to distinguish inheritance from this alternative rather than from independent insertion alone.

Hi,

There’s an asymmetry you’re not seeing. On one side sits a research program that’s been making and passing predictions for more than 160 years, one that already does its work with emergence, co-option, exaptation, horizontal gene transfer, genetic drift and epigenetics inside an extended synthesis.
On the other side, the YEC side, sits a metaphysical bet that a line exists somewhere in descent with modification offered so far without a rate, without a number, without a definition, and without a theological justification.

Your symmetry plea tries to present those two as carrying the same burden, but they clearly don’t my friend. One side keeps handing over data that pass the popperian barrier of entry while the other only is poking holes over the missing ones as an opportunity to smuggle an hypothesis that cannot abide by the rules of scientific inquiry.

My ERV argument, you say, needs to “distinguish biological inheritance from the reuse of a shared starting design”. So, you propose that libraries get reused for function but so far ERV insertion sites have no function to recommend them. They’re contingent occurrences and their addresses have no reason to match any tree.
You did ask for the right thing though which is evidence that distinguishes “finite variation from mutation-based evolution”.

Fair enough, the evidence exists and whales are carrying it :

Molecular fossils illuminate the evolution of retroviruses following a macroevolutionary transition from land to water

You can look up the peer reviewed study, they went looking for whether the virus fossils in cetacean genomes record the move from land to water. Twenty-eight lineages turn up as orthologous insertions shared between whales and the hippopotamus. Twenty-six more, on both sides of the toothed/baleen split. All the rest, 244 of them, got the full phylogenetic test:

“For all the 244 lineages, we found ERV phylogenies are statistically congruent with the cetacean phylogeny (P < 0.01).”

That’s the nested pattern recovering a family tree from pure contingency. In the same study, 69.80% of the land-to-water lineages sit closest to the hippopotamus ERVs, right where common descent has always put the whale’s nearest living kin, and “these ERVs transitioned to aquatic environments within their host genomes”.

It means the viruses entered the ocean inside the animals, so the walking ancestors were already carrying them. The authors didn’t assume the alternatives away either. They modeled host switching and loss quantitatively.

Shared modules get reused because they do something. A contingent address that writes itself onto a family tree across an ocean crossing doesn’t do anything.

What does the preloaded-prototype model predict about whales’ virus fossils? I’m all hears.