I’m noticing multiple tensions in your reply. You affirm that providence and descent are not mutually exclusive, yet you need an explicit permission from Scripture to accept common descent despite the evidence from genetics. But if we accept that the world He created is intelligible, fine-tuned for discovery and reliable, that same fine-tuning forbids a young world and points to common descent. Do you believe we have to presuppose God actively deceives with a false History to test our faith?
You insist on the creation week framing, I genuinely want to see if you’re consistent with this reasoning by asking : Was there an end to the seventh day? The text closes six of them with an evening and a morning but it never closes the seventh.
So is God in a permanent rest to this day, or does it mean the text had a different purpose and accommodated itself to a pre-scientific audience, to convey theological truths about the meaning of our existence? None of that excludes a Genealogical Adam and Eve if that’s what you’re worried about.
I’m also noticing something more subtle. You’re not saying where you derive the assumption of finite boundaries for species, or whether an old universe wouldn’t leave room for the variation and renewal of species that Psalm 104 explicitly supports, as well as predation written there as a feature of the natural order and its ecological balance. You can see what is said in the text “lions roaring for their prey”, “everything fed in its season” and “you renew the face of the ground.”
Your perspective sounds to me like God is only a first mover, not the One who continually sustains reality while speaking things into existence from the beginning.
I’d like to touch on another thing you say:
What you’re missing here is the fact that in scientific inquiry we lean on the more elegant, harmonious explanation not on a presupposed conclusion. We infer the best explanation by accounting for the explanatory power of a model and its consistency with Occam’s razor. That’s what makes the difference between a metaphysical hypothesis and a scientific theory. Thing is they don’t abide by the same rules and Science also has epistemological boundaries which means, it will never say anything about the why of Creation. It might inform whether your metaphysics is justified but it can’t conclude one because it wasn’t designed to achieve something like that, unless we discard the principle of methodological naturalism.
Methodological naturalism presupposes no such competition with or replacement of God’s working in creation. In the seventeenth-century context, such neutrality functioned as an injunction to understand nature on its own terms, implying natural philosophers did not invoke God’s unmediated action in creation to explain events and patterns in creation. The ultimate purpose of MN was to glorify God through understanding secondary causes much in the spirit of Magnus.82
Then I hope you’ll understand why common descent is a scientific theory. It was produced by a body of experts making predictions, not individuals relying on their personal preference. Science accepts the examination of its hypotheses inside an intellectual immune system, and it arrived there by consensus with converging data. The category error is to think it is either nature or design.
To be clear, I’m not dimissing your app all I’m saying is, to propose a scientific model one needs to abide by the rules of science, overcome falsification and be testable. Natural theology doesn’t do that because God isn’t a “Force” nor a scientific object to begin with.
“For we can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth.”
2 Corinthians 13.v8
