Continuing my examination of different interpretations of Genesis, I would like to turn to John Walton’s approach.
In our earlier discussions, particularly my exchange with Vinnie, we examined the functional and cosmic-temple readings of Genesis 1 in considerable detail. So I will not repeat that entire discussion here. Instead, I would like to focus on several questions that I consider particularly important.
Let me begin with what I see as a strength of Walton’s approach.
Walton rightly emphasizes the ancient Near Eastern cultural and intellectual context of Genesis. We should not automatically equate ancient language with modern scientific terminology, nor should we reduce the theological content of the text to a description of physical processes.
I also appreciate his effort to show that Genesis need not compete with the natural sciences.
But here I would make a distinction that is fundamental to my position.
I agree that understanding the original audience and its conceptual world is essential to interpreting an ancient text. Walton is right to insist on this.
Yet if we regard Genesis as divine Revelation, addressed not only to its original audience but also to subsequent generations, another question arises.
What justifies treating the intellectual horizon of the original audience as an exhaustive boundary on what that Revelation can refer to?
A person living in the twenty-first century is also an intended recipient of biblical Revelation, even though the text was not originally addressed to that person in the same historical circumstances.
Of course, this does not mean that Genesis must contain modern scientific terminology. But I find it difficult to accept that the cultural understanding of its first audience necessarily exhausts the reality to which divine Revelation may refer.
This is where my disagreement with Walton’s approach begins.
Consider the first day of Creation.
Walton interprets it primarily in terms of establishing temporal order, including the distinction between day and night.
I have no objection to recognizing this temporal function. If we are speaking of the creation of the universe, and time is one of the characteristics of the emerging physical order, then the establishment of temporal relations can reasonably be regarded as part of Creation.
But why should we stop there?
Spatial relations also belong to the world we observe, whether space and time are ultimately fundamental features of reality or emerge from a deeper order.
If the opening of Genesis concerns the creation of the universe, then the establishment of temporal order could be one aspect of that event rather than an exhaustive account of what the text conveys.
So my question is not why Walton identifies a temporal function.
I am asking what justifies moving from the recognition of that function to the conclusion that material origins and the broader structure of the created world are not part of what this narrative addresses.
A modern reader opens Genesis and encounters an account of the creation of the world. Then the reader encounters an interpretation according to which the primary subject of the account is not material origins but the establishment of functions and order.
What justifies that restriction?
I am not claiming that the functional interpretation is wrong. I am questioning whether it has been sufficiently established as exhaustive.
A similar question arises with the temple interpretation.
I understand why Creation, divine presence, sacred space, the temple, and God’s rest may be seen as interconnected themes.
But there is a difference between two claims:
“The symbolism of the temple reflects certain features of the created order.”
And:
“The Creation narrative was originally intended to describe the establishment of a cosmic temple.”
The first claim does not automatically establish the second.
That is why I find Walton’s more recent reconsideration of his own position particularly interesting.
In his 2025 book, New Explorations in the Lost World of Genesis, and in his conversation with Dru Johnson, Walton acknowledges an important limitation of his earlier cosmic-temple metaphor.
A temple distinguishes an inside from an outside.
But if the entire cosmos is the temple, where does that boundary lie?
Walton accepts this as a legitimate problem. He now speaks more cautiously about sacred space and God’s presence without extending every feature of temple architecture to the cosmos as a whole.
He also qualifies the connection between the seventh day and temple rest, acknowledging that the relevant connection is less explicit in Genesis itself than his earlier formulation might suggest.
In my view, a scholar’s willingness to reconsider his own conclusions deserves genuine respect.
But it raises a question for us, as readers and participants in these discussions.
Walton’s approach has considerable support on this forum, and his earlier arguments have been cited repeatedly in our conversations.
Yet I do not think it is methodologically sound to retain conclusions based on the stronger version of the cosmic-temple interpretation while appealing to Walton’s revised and more cautious position as though the original grounds remained unchanged.
If the grounds for a conclusion have been revised, the conclusion itself must be reconsidered in light of that revision.
That does not mean that all of Walton’s earlier conclusions automatically become false. But their previous justification cannot simply be taken for granted.
Now let us turn to Genesis 2 and 3.
In his earlier work, Walton understood Adam and Eve as archetypal figures while also regarding them as real people who could have existed in the historical past. Eden was understood as sacred space, and their role there was described in terms of a special, including priestly, vocation.
In his 2025 work, Walton significantly revisits elements of this interpretation, particularly the priestly role of Adam and Eve and the central meaning of Genesis 3.
In the interview mentioned above, he explains that he now reads Genesis 3 primarily not as an account of the origin of sin, but as a narrative about humanity’s search for order.
And here I encounter perhaps my most important question.
The text of Genesis uses a very specific expression: the knowledge of good and evil.
It describes a command from the Creator, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, and the violation of that command.
Why should these elements be understood primarily through the broader categories of the pursuit of order and wisdom?
Such a reading may have grounds in the ancient Near Eastern context and in the overall structure of the text. But I would like to understand what justifies making it the governing interpretation.
Interestingly, in his new work Walton himself speaks of humanity appropriating a divine capacity through an act driven by self-will.
I think this touches upon something extremely important in the Eden narrative.
There is, after all, a fundamental difference between the ability to distinguish good from evil and a claim to determine for oneself, independently of the Creator, what should count as good and evil.
The command in Eden already establishes a relationship to what ought to be done. Otherwise, it is difficult to understand what constitutes the conscious violation of the boundary set by the Creator.
So why should the search for order become the central interpretive category rather than the attempt to claim final moral authority independently of the Creator?
I am not saying that order and wisdom are irrelevant to the passage. I am asking why they should govern our understanding of the event when the text itself explicitly speaks about good and evil, a divine command, and its violation.
For me, this is not merely a terminological distinction. It affects what we regard as the actual content of the Eden narrative.
And that brings me back to the main reason I remain unconvinced by Walton’s approach.
His interpretation allows us to avoid directly correlating many images in Genesis with the physical history of the world. I understand why that can be attractive.
But does this create a problem in the opposite direction?
In freeing Revelation from the requirement to speak the language of modern science, might we also be restricting too severely the possibility of a substantive connection between Revelation and the actual history of the created world?
A text can employ ancient images while still referring to a reality expressed through those images.
And that reality need not be limited to the physical mode of existence familiar to us.
For this reason, I do not find it sufficient merely to establish that a particular image has a functional, temple-related, or theological meaning. I also want to ask what reality the image refers to and how confidently we can establish the boundaries of its meaning.
In closing, I would like to return to a suggestion already made in one of our discussions.
This is an interesting interpretive proposal. But as far as I can tell, it is St.Roymond’s own proposal, not an explanation Walton provided in the interview.
And here I would like to establish a boundary for further discussion.
I am not an advocate of Walton’s temple interpretation, nor am I in a position to develop it on his behalf. If someone believes that this additional scheme resolves a limitation Walton himself has acknowledged, I think the proposal should be put directly to him.
His publicly listed academic email address is john.walton@wheaton.edu.
It would be interesting to learn whether Walton accepts this extension or considers it inconsistent with his understanding of Genesis.
If anyone decides to contact him and receives a response, I would be genuinely interested in reading it here.
For now, my central question remains:
What grounds justify treating a functional, temple-based, or order-centered interpretation as an exhaustive account of the text’s meaning, if the possibility of a deeper connection with the actual history of Creation remains open?