John Walton’s Approach to the Book of Genesis

Continuing my examination of different interpretations of Genesis, I would like to turn to John Walton’s approach.

In our earlier discussions, particularly my exchange with Vinnie, we examined the functional and cosmic-temple readings of Genesis 1 in considerable detail. So I will not repeat that entire discussion here. Instead, I would like to focus on several questions that I consider particularly important.

Let me begin with what I see as a strength of Walton’s approach.

Walton rightly emphasizes the ancient Near Eastern cultural and intellectual context of Genesis. We should not automatically equate ancient language with modern scientific terminology, nor should we reduce the theological content of the text to a description of physical processes.

I also appreciate his effort to show that Genesis need not compete with the natural sciences.

But here I would make a distinction that is fundamental to my position.

I agree that understanding the original audience and its conceptual world is essential to interpreting an ancient text. Walton is right to insist on this.

Yet if we regard Genesis as divine Revelation, addressed not only to its original audience but also to subsequent generations, another question arises.

What justifies treating the intellectual horizon of the original audience as an exhaustive boundary on what that Revelation can refer to?

A person living in the twenty-first century is also an intended recipient of biblical Revelation, even though the text was not originally addressed to that person in the same historical circumstances.

Of course, this does not mean that Genesis must contain modern scientific terminology. But I find it difficult to accept that the cultural understanding of its first audience necessarily exhausts the reality to which divine Revelation may refer.

This is where my disagreement with Walton’s approach begins.

Consider the first day of Creation.

Walton interprets it primarily in terms of establishing temporal order, including the distinction between day and night.

I have no objection to recognizing this temporal function. If we are speaking of the creation of the universe, and time is one of the characteristics of the emerging physical order, then the establishment of temporal relations can reasonably be regarded as part of Creation.

But why should we stop there?

Spatial relations also belong to the world we observe, whether space and time are ultimately fundamental features of reality or emerge from a deeper order.

If the opening of Genesis concerns the creation of the universe, then the establishment of temporal order could be one aspect of that event rather than an exhaustive account of what the text conveys.

So my question is not why Walton identifies a temporal function.

I am asking what justifies moving from the recognition of that function to the conclusion that material origins and the broader structure of the created world are not part of what this narrative addresses.

A modern reader opens Genesis and encounters an account of the creation of the world. Then the reader encounters an interpretation according to which the primary subject of the account is not material origins but the establishment of functions and order.

What justifies that restriction?

I am not claiming that the functional interpretation is wrong. I am questioning whether it has been sufficiently established as exhaustive.

A similar question arises with the temple interpretation.

I understand why Creation, divine presence, sacred space, the temple, and God’s rest may be seen as interconnected themes.

But there is a difference between two claims:

“The symbolism of the temple reflects certain features of the created order.”

And:

“The Creation narrative was originally intended to describe the establishment of a cosmic temple.”

The first claim does not automatically establish the second.

That is why I find Walton’s more recent reconsideration of his own position particularly interesting.

In his 2025 book, New Explorations in the Lost World of Genesis, and in his conversation with Dru Johnson, Walton acknowledges an important limitation of his earlier cosmic-temple metaphor.

John Walton with Dru Johnson — Israel’s Rituals, God’s Needs, and the Covenant That Changed Everything, Ep. 223

A temple distinguishes an inside from an outside.
But if the entire cosmos is the temple, where does that boundary lie?

Walton accepts this as a legitimate problem. He now speaks more cautiously about sacred space and God’s presence without extending every feature of temple architecture to the cosmos as a whole.

He also qualifies the connection between the seventh day and temple rest, acknowledging that the relevant connection is less explicit in Genesis itself than his earlier formulation might suggest.

In my view, a scholar’s willingness to reconsider his own conclusions deserves genuine respect.

But it raises a question for us, as readers and participants in these discussions.

Walton’s approach has considerable support on this forum, and his earlier arguments have been cited repeatedly in our conversations.

Yet I do not think it is methodologically sound to retain conclusions based on the stronger version of the cosmic-temple interpretation while appealing to Walton’s revised and more cautious position as though the original grounds remained unchanged.

If the grounds for a conclusion have been revised, the conclusion itself must be reconsidered in light of that revision.

That does not mean that all of Walton’s earlier conclusions automatically become false. But their previous justification cannot simply be taken for granted.

Now let us turn to Genesis 2 and 3.

In his earlier work, Walton understood Adam and Eve as archetypal figures while also regarding them as real people who could have existed in the historical past. Eden was understood as sacred space, and their role there was described in terms of a special, including priestly, vocation.

In his 2025 work, Walton significantly revisits elements of this interpretation, particularly the priestly role of Adam and Eve and the central meaning of Genesis 3.

In the interview mentioned above, he explains that he now reads Genesis 3 primarily not as an account of the origin of sin, but as a narrative about humanity’s search for order.

And here I encounter perhaps my most important question.

The text of Genesis uses a very specific expression: the knowledge of good and evil.

It describes a command from the Creator, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, and the violation of that command.

Why should these elements be understood primarily through the broader categories of the pursuit of order and wisdom?

Such a reading may have grounds in the ancient Near Eastern context and in the overall structure of the text. But I would like to understand what justifies making it the governing interpretation.

Interestingly, in his new work Walton himself speaks of humanity appropriating a divine capacity through an act driven by self-will.

I think this touches upon something extremely important in the Eden narrative.

There is, after all, a fundamental difference between the ability to distinguish good from evil and a claim to determine for oneself, independently of the Creator, what should count as good and evil.

The command in Eden already establishes a relationship to what ought to be done. Otherwise, it is difficult to understand what constitutes the conscious violation of the boundary set by the Creator.

So why should the search for order become the central interpretive category rather than the attempt to claim final moral authority independently of the Creator?

I am not saying that order and wisdom are irrelevant to the passage. I am asking why they should govern our understanding of the event when the text itself explicitly speaks about good and evil, a divine command, and its violation.

For me, this is not merely a terminological distinction. It affects what we regard as the actual content of the Eden narrative.

And that brings me back to the main reason I remain unconvinced by Walton’s approach.

His interpretation allows us to avoid directly correlating many images in Genesis with the physical history of the world. I understand why that can be attractive.

But does this create a problem in the opposite direction?

In freeing Revelation from the requirement to speak the language of modern science, might we also be restricting too severely the possibility of a substantive connection between Revelation and the actual history of the created world?

A text can employ ancient images while still referring to a reality expressed through those images.

And that reality need not be limited to the physical mode of existence familiar to us.

For this reason, I do not find it sufficient merely to establish that a particular image has a functional, temple-related, or theological meaning. I also want to ask what reality the image refers to and how confidently we can establish the boundaries of its meaning.

In closing, I would like to return to a suggestion already made in one of our discussions.

This is an interesting interpretive proposal. But as far as I can tell, it is St.Roymond’s own proposal, not an explanation Walton provided in the interview.

And here I would like to establish a boundary for further discussion.

I am not an advocate of Walton’s temple interpretation, nor am I in a position to develop it on his behalf. If someone believes that this additional scheme resolves a limitation Walton himself has acknowledged, I think the proposal should be put directly to him.

His publicly listed academic email address is john.walton@wheaton.edu.

It would be interesting to learn whether Walton accepts this extension or considers it inconsistent with his understanding of Genesis.

If anyone decides to contact him and receives a response, I would be genuinely interested in reading it here.

For now, my central question remains:

What grounds justify treating a functional, temple-based, or order-centered interpretation as an exhaustive account of the text’s meaning, if the possibility of a deeper connection with the actual history of Creation remains open?

That YHWH-Elohim is not a manipulator of minds and revelation is not a divine download.

That’s cultural snobbery, as though we happen to be the other generation for whom it was meant.
The telling things here is that people have always tried to read their science into Genesis, including when science held everything was made of four elements and all movement above the clouds was in perfect spherical sections. Why would God favor our science over anyone else’s – especially since science has nothing to say about the relationship between Yahweh and humans?
Trying to stuff science into the Creation accounts has nothing to do with revelation, it is just a human desire to have God chained to human interests. It is really idolatry, the notion that scripture has to conform to our cultural prejudices.

Because such a concept is irrelevant to the intent of the writer.
Material origins are only mentioned in passing; they are not what the text is addressing. The text is interested in taking the mytho-theology of the surrounding nations and essentially saying “All your gods are belong to Yahweh”, that they are nothing but pieces of or decorations in YHWH-Elohim’s own temple that He built for Himself.
That material origins are only barely relevant is shown in the fact that the sun and the moon are never mentioned, only their jobs. Looking closely at the rest of the text of that opening account, that’s true of all the items: everything is mentioned because it has a job to do, from shining to living. Walton is only taking the text and letting it speak for itself.
His big failure is to miss that the first Creation account is also a battle account – that’s not obvious without comparing to the rest of the ANE where so much of the making of the world is a matter of gods battling forces of chaos (and each other, which ironically shows that they are just forces of chaos themselves) to get things done. The difference is that YHWH-Elohim has no need of other elohim, neither to make them do any work or to defeat them; Yahweh merely decrees forms of order and they happen.

It’s not “symbolism of the temple”, it’s that the opening Creation account is a temple-inauguration account, told in common ANE terms: three days of building, three days of filling/decorating and making it function, the installation of the image in the temple, and the deity resting. The second claim to which you refer is merely what the text is, it is not a derivation from some notion of symbolism.

That’s your definition.

Why does there need to be an “outside”? An outside implies a realm not directly under the deity’s control, a realm of opposition. There only needs to be an outside if something has happened to restrict the deity’s realm.

That’s silly – it’s about an interruption in Yahweh’s realm, the disruption of order, the origin of an “outside”.

You’re inventing a requirement and thereby setting up modern science as an idol.

Why does your “actual history of Creation” get a special place? You’re no different than earlier folks who found their science in Genesis.

Where does such certainty come from?

Have you somehow gained direct access to the ancient author’s intentions? Or are you offering your own reconstruction of those intentions, based on particular textual, historical, and cultural assumptions?

If the latter, why do you present the result of your interpretation as the established meaning of the text, leaving no room for discussion?

Let me remind you of our earlier exchange.

Now let’s turn to Walton.

No. This is not an arbitrary definition I invented for this discussion. It is precisely the objection raised against Walton’s cosmic-temple interpretation, and Walton himself acknowledged that it was legitimate.

In his conversation with Dru Johnson, Walton explained that the distinction between inside and outside was one reason he reconsidered how far the cosmic-temple metaphor could be extended.

You are free to reject that objection, just as you are free to disagree with Walton’s revised position. But then you need to address the substance of the objection, rather than dismiss it as merely my personal definition.

Furthermore, you write about his interpretation of Genesis 1:

And regarding his revised understanding of Genesis 3:

Fine. You have every right, as do I, to criticize Walton.

But what do these objections to Walton have to do with refuting my position?

I am not the author of his interpretation, and I have no intention of defending on his behalf conclusions that he himself is revising.

Here is the academic email address I included in my article:

john.walton@wheaton.edu

Write to him. Explain what he has missed in his own interpretation and why you consider his revised conclusions silly.

I do not need to answer for his research.

Now let’s return to what I actually wrote in my article.

So where, exactly, did you find the position you are so vigorously condemning?

I did not claim that modern science should determine the meaning of Scripture. I asked why the intellectual horizon of the original audience should be treated as an exhaustive boundary on the reality to which divine Revelation may refer.

Those are two entirely different questions.

You attributed to me a position I do not hold and then proceeded to refute it. That is a classic straw-man argument.

And before accusing someone else of idolatry, I would suggest that you look in the mirror.

For when you declare your own reading of Genesis to be not an interpretation but simply “what the text is,” a rather obvious question arises:

Are you not elevating your own interpretation to the status of a truth that can no longer be questioned?

Because no ANE writer would have any concept of modern science and thus could not write it.

Walton is wrong – he is applying the definition of a temple that pertains to a fallen world, not a pristine one.

We should start by trying to understand how the original audience understood what they heard. The messages to the original audience is the primary goal of the narrative.

When we understand - as far as we can understand - what the primary messages were, then we can start to speculate whether the narrative includes also secondary messages.

We should remember that the text was not written to us. We can learn from it, like we can learn from an old letter written to someone else. Taking the narrative as it would be written also to us is egoistic thinking - the world does not revolve around us and our modern questions.

Revealing the material details of the universe or earth do not seem to be important points in the OT texts. It is a book (library) that revolves around God, His will and His relationship with humans and the other creation. Assuming that the Genesis narrative is revealing the ‘scientific’ details of the origin of the material universe is forcing our interests and modern questions into an ancient text that was not written for that purpose.

The temple approach may increase our understanding but it may also restrict our thinking. This kind of ancient creation narratives have also been viewed as ‘mytho-narratives’. That term may be a supplementary description of the creation story. AI described mytho-narrative in the following way:
“A mytho-narrative (or mythological narrative) is a traditional or sacred story that uses gods, supernatural figures, or heroic archetypes to explain natural phenomena, origins, and fundamental cultural values.”

It should be noted that a mytho-narrative can include truthful teachings, assuming that God is real and the text is inspired by God.

2 Likes

I’ve always thought Walton’s approach was good and valuable, but that he perhaps took it a bit too far, and excluded other possibilities. Nothing is as simple and one dimensional as it seems. I really enjoyed the book The Manifest Beauty of Genesis One by Gregg Davidson and Kenneth Turner. It includes Walton’s approach but expands to look at other dimensions.
I have not read Walton’s latest with his musings as to how his views have changed, but sounds like I need to do so.

2 Likes

Metaphors always tend to break down if extended too far. They are meant to help provide context and a framework for understanding, but so long as one thing is not another, that framework cannot be extended indefinitely. Thus the temple framework is helpful is understanding the theology revealed by the author is his day and time, but not as well to us, who must try to put ourselves in the original audience’s place.

3 Likes

Hello, knorKai.

But I think we need to distinguish two questions:

1. To whom was the text originally addressed?

2. For whom is the divine Revelation conveyed through that text intended?

Here I must disagree with you.

You present this as an established fact. But on what grounds do you assign precisely this hierarchy of purposes?

If you are referring to the original communicative purpose of the ancient author, I do not dispute that such a purpose existed. But you describe it as the primary goal of the narrative.

If we regard Genesis as divine Revelation, does such a statement not presume knowledge of the place the original audience occupies in the Creator’s purpose? Can you justify that claim?

And why should we regard the original communicative purpose as an exhaustive expression of the divine intention?

You later acknowledge the possibility of secondary messages. I welcome that, but it does not provide grounds for the hierarchy you have asserted.

I do not dispute that the ancient author used language and images familiar to his contemporaries. Nor am I suggesting that Genesis should be read as though it had been written by someone living in the twenty-first century.

However, if we regard this text as divine Revelation, why should subsequent generations see themselves merely as bystanders drawing lessons from a letter addressed to someone else?

For me, divine Revelation is addressed not only to the contemporaries of Moses. It is intended for us and for the generations that will come after us. Not because our age holds some privileged position, but precisely because I do not regard any one historical audience as the exclusive recipient of divine Revelation.

I therefore see no egocentrism in this position. On the contrary, it recognizes the equal significance of all generations to whom the Creator’s word is addressed.

I largely agree with you here. In fact, I expressed almost the same thought in my earlier comment

But I do not see why the predominance of one theme should imply the exclusion of another.

The first chapter of Genesis opens the biblical narrative with Creation. And if we acknowledge that Revelation speaks of the Creator’s relationship with the created world, why should the very origin of that world fall outside the actual content of the text?

I am not claiming that the first chapter reveals scientific details of the origin of the universe. I am asking why its theological meaning should exclude the possibility of a substantive connection with the actual history of Creation.

Recognizing that much of Scripture concerns the relationship between God and humanity does not, by itself, establish the limits of the reality to which the first chapter of Genesis may refer.

That is why I am interested not in finding modern scientific concepts in an ancient text, but in the grounds on which we determine what reality that text may refer to.

Now let me turn to your comment about the temple interpretation.

As you can see, I was not defending the second claim as my own position. It was one of two claims I was explicitly distinguishing.

My question was why recognizing temple symbolism should establish that the Creation narrative was originally intended specifically to describe the inauguration of a cosmic temple.

So I broadly agree with your observation that the temple interpretation can both deepen and restrict our understanding.

As for your proposed description of the text as a “mytho-narrative,” I would make another distinction.

Similarity in the literary form of ancient texts does not mean that they have the same theological status.

For me as a Christian, Genesis is not simply one ancient cosmogonic work among others. Jesus Christ appeals to Genesis 1:27 and Genesis 2:24 as authoritative Scripture (Matthew 19:4–6). If we acknowledge Christ as God, this has fundamental significance for how we understand the authority of these texts.

Jesus of Nazareth is not merely a figure within an ancient account of the gods. He is a historical person, and Christianity confesses him as God incarnate.

This matters profoundly. If we acknowledge Jesus Christ as God incarnate, then his appeal to Genesis has a significance fundamentally different from a comparison between ancient literary traditions.

Within the Christian understanding of Revelation, the authority of Genesis is therefore not based merely on its antiquity, its literary form, or its resemblance to other ancient cosmogonies. It is also affirmed through the testimony of Jesus Christ.

We have no comparable grounds within Christianity for attributing the same divine authority to Greek, Egyptian, or other ancient cosmogonies.

I do not deny that we can study the literary forms and cultural parallels of Genesis. But such a classification should not quietly replace the question of its status as divine Revelation.

Moreover, the definition you obtained from AI does not, by itself, justify applying that particular genre category to Genesis.

So I return to my original distinction.

The historical circumstances in which Revelation was communicated are fundamentally important to understanding it. But it does not follow that they determine the hierarchy of the Creator’s purposes or establish the ultimate limits of the reality to which Revelation refers.

It is precisely those further claims that I am asking to see justified.

Secondary messages are possible but if you communicate to an audience through an oral narrative, you communicate it to that audience, not to unborn generations that may live thousands of years later. The narrative includes lasting lessons but it would be a wild idea to think that it was originally coded for people who would live several thousands of years later, in a very different world and asking questions that the original audience did not ask or think.

Please remember that the culture, as any ANE culture, was basically an oral culture. Written versions of the oral narratives were mostly later records of what was told orally. The alternative is that the written version was a novel, previously unknown story when it was written.

The traditional view has been that Genesis was written by Moses, crudely 1400 BCE. One problem with this interpretation is that the Hebrew language formed much later, so if Moses wrote something, he could not write the Hebrew text we know.

A modern scholarly view is that the final Hebrew form of Genesis was compiled and edited from multiple oral and written sources during or after the Babylonian Exile, crudely 500 BCE (some think that it happened between 600-200 BCE).

Do you know any OT text that reveals such details of the material universe that the original audience could not know but we know?

It is surprising how little the fundamentals of the material universe get attention in the biblical texts. What is written seems to be accommodated to the prevailing worldview of the audience, that is the ANE beliefs that we see as outdated. My conclusion from this observation is that God cares much more about our relationship with Him than how wrong our beliefs of the material universe are. Flat or round earth, hard firmament or open sky above the earth, geocentric or heliocentric worldview - who cares if the relationship with God works well.

Jesus tells that God created us as man and woman, and cites the verse that speaks about the marital relationship between man and woman. That does not reveal much about Genesis 1-3.

Jesus lived according to the guidelines that were based on Tanakh (Torah, prophets and writings). His recorded comments show that he took Torah as an authoritative text behind the covenant between God and Israel but interpreted some parts in a different way than the scribes and leaders of the Jews.
For example, in the Matthew 19 you cited, he tells that Moses added the possibility to divorce because of the pressures and hopes of Israelites but that the divorce rules in the Torah were not the original will of God.

The comments of Jesus about Genesis 1-3 are rare and do not reveal what type of scripture that part of Torah is. Authoritative, yes, but for the comments of Jesus, it does not matter whether the narratives were accurate descriptions of what happened, or theological teaching in the form of a narrative.

1 Like

I can offer an example of a correspondence that I consider worthy of attention.

In the first chapter of Genesis, light appears on the first day of Creation (Genesis 1:3–5), whereas the heavenly luminaries appear only on the fourth day (Genesis 1:14–19).

Modern cosmology establishes that electromagnetic radiation existed in the early universe long before the first stars formed. Thus, the biblical text presents a sequence that has a certain correspondence with the scientific reconstruction of the history of the universe.

I am not claiming that the ancient author knew about photons or the physical processes of the early universe. But that is not the point of my argument.

My question is different: can an ancient text, through images accessible to its original audience, convey content whose significance becomes clearer only in the light of later knowledge about the world?

Nor am I suggesting that the sequence of light preceding the luminaries is unique to Genesis.

For example, there is an ancient Sumerian text from Nippur (tablet NBC 11108) in which the heavens are described as shining independently of the heavenly luminaries. This is an interesting parallel, and I see no reason to ignore it.

Moreover, I do not consider the absence of individual parallels to be the primary evidence of what makes Genesis distinctive.

In my article, Genesis Among Ancient Cosmogonies, I examine precisely this question.

Mesopotamian cosmogonies contain images of primordial waters and the separation of cosmic realms. In Egyptian tradition, we encounter creation through the spoken word. Some versions of Zoroastrian cosmogony present a sequence of seven creations that can be structurally compared with the biblical account.

But I am interested in more than isolated similarities.

In Genesis, these and other motifs form a distinctive, coherent composition. A single Creator acts without needing to struggle against a divine opponent equal to Himself. Natural forces are not independent gods. Creation receives distinctions, functions, and blessings.

Humanity occupies a special place. Human beings are created in the image of God and endowed with dignity, freedom, and responsibility. Their purpose is not reduced to serving the needs of gods, as depicted in some Mesopotamian accounts. The subsequent biblical text also develops the theme of humanity’s personal relationship with the Creator.

Even Zoroastrian cosmogony, which offers a particularly interesting structural parallel, differs substantially in its theological content: its account of creation is embedded in a conflict between beneficent and destructive principles. In Genesis, there is no evil principle equal to the Creator whose existence is necessary for the world to come into being.

Therefore, I see the distinctiveness of Genesis not in the absence of motifs shared with other ancient traditions, but in the way those motifs are combined and transformed within a coherent theological composition.

And it is this composition, rather than a selection of conveniently chosen correspondences, that I propose we consider when comparing the text with the actual history of Creation.

Now I would like to clarify several of our underlying theological premises.

First. Do you agree that Jesus Christ is God?

You rightly point out that Christ does not confirm every detail of Genesis. I have never claimed that He does.

But in Matthew 19:4–6, Christ appeals to Genesis as an authoritative witness to the Creator’s original intention.

If we acknowledge Jesus Christ as God incarnate, then His testimony carries a unique significance for us.

For me, this is a substantial reason to regard Genesis not merely as a document of ancient religious thought, but as genuine divine Revelation.

And here I see a fundamental difference from other ancient cosmogonic traditions.

In Greek mythological tradition, we also encounter accounts of gods coming to human beings and interacting with them. Christianity, however, connects the authority of Genesis with the testimony of the historical Jesus, whom it confesses as God incarnate.

Within the Christian faith, this is a fundamentally different kind of basis for recognizing the divine authority of a text.

That is why I would like to understand whether you recognize Genesis specifically as divine Revelation, and what significance you attach to Christ’s testimony.

Second. Do you agree that the Creator does not deceive human beings?

For me, this is a fundamental principle. I hold that divine Revelation is not intended to mislead humanity about the Creator or the world He created.

Third. Do you agree that modern science genuinely reveals certain aspects of the history and structure of the created world?

Of course, our scientific knowledge is not exhaustive. But many conclusions of modern science are supported by independent observations and experiments.

Now let us consider these propositions together.

If Genesis is divine Revelation, if the Creator does not mislead humanity, and if the Creator Himself certainly knows the actual history of the world He created, why should we rule out in advance the possibility that the biblical text refers in a substantive way to that history?

I agree that Revelation was communicated through language and images accessible to its original audience.

But why should this mean that those images cannot refer to a reality that we are now able to investigate in much greater detail, including through scientific methods?

I am not proposing that we search an ancient text for modern scientific formulas. I am asking why you regard such a substantive connection as unjustified merely because the original audience did not possess modern scientific knowledge.

For me, these remain two different questions.

Roman, I agree with you that the meaning of Genesis need not be exhausted by what its original audience consciously understood, and I also agree that Walton’s functional reading, however valuable, shouldn’t automatically be treated as the whole story, where I’m less convinced is in the move from that possibility to specific scientific correspondences.

Yes, electromagnetic radiation existed before the first stars, but ancient people could also imagine light existing before the luminaries, as the Sumerian parallel you mention shows, so the correspondence is interesting, but it doesn’t establish that Genesis was referring to the physical history of the early universe.

I have a similar difficulty with your Seven Acts model: once the ontological significance of the fourth biblical day is assigned to an earlier stage in cosmic history, what independently determines which biblical image corresponds to which scientific transition? Without a clear criterion established beforehand, how do we distinguish a genuine correspondence from one constructed retrospectively?

And since we’ve already discussed Adam and Eve elsewhere, I still think there’s a more fundamental theological issue.

I appreciate that you affirm a real Fall, but Romans 5 speaks of Adam’s disobedience as a personally attributable act: If the Adamic and Eveic distinctions were not yet two distinct persons before the Fall, how can the original transgression be personally attributed to the two individuals who emerge afterward?

Likewise, if the complete imprint of the original Edenic ground corresponds to each individual human soul, what accounts for the existence of each distinct soul?

To me, these are more important questions than whether an ancient text could contain meanings that become clearer to later generations. I don’t dispute that possibility, what I’m questioning is whether your particular reconstruction has been adequately established.

1 Like

Amen! . . . :+1:

This seems to assume that the point of revelation is to impart information and/or to satisfy human curiosity.

So does the text also carry information bits for Aristotelian science? And how can it do that without moderns scoffing at such primitive views?

It’s telling us what is important about the actual history of Creation: that YHWH-Elohim made it all, and made it all to serve Him, and out us in the middle of it all to be His family.

You’ve got it backwards: there is no “temple symbolism”, the whole thing is a temple inauguration account (while, brilliantly, also being a ‘royal chronicle’ account). We don’t decide that the opening Creation account is about a temple because of some symbolism derived from temple, we learn what a temple is by reading the opening Creation account.

So? It still means what its worldview, literary type, vocabulary and grammar convey – indeed if it didn’t it could have no authority because without those it is essentially lacking any meaning.

That’s a false dichotomy. Its authority does not come in spite of the literary and cultural aspects, it comes through those things.

Especially when those questions have nothing to do with the original message!

That’s conceding that He cares about communicating concerning the material universe at all. The thrust of the narrative is such that anything about the material universe is there only in passing, to give referents for the narrative – the thrust of the narrative is the relationship between YHWH-Elohim and what He has made, concluding with dropping the incredible burden of being God-images on the centerpiece of what He made!

Or, as some ancient rabbis noted, whether the narrative speaks of events that “actually happened” – its authority lies not in some supposed relationship to material ‘reality’, but in its source and its intent to aid in understanding the real relationship that matters – that between the Creator and the Created.

That’s a ‘parallel’ that helps understand why light is mentioned in the Genesis narrative: it is to establish that light is also one of YHWH-Elohim’s creatures, not something independent, and it shines where He assigns it.

Because nothing in the text – or in any other scripture text! – suggests that He cares about communicating such things.

1 Like

Of course, you are entitled to question the justification of any model, including mine.

In my view, a substantive evaluation requires first establishing what a model actually proposes, and then examining its internal consistency, arguments, and specific weaknesses or insufficiently justified claims.

You can see examples of how I try to approach the critical examination of other people’s ideas in this article on Walton, in my analysis of Ethan’s model, and in my questions to Shawn T. Murphy.

I also intend to publish a separate examination of what I find unconvincing in Thomism.

As for EPT, I have already explained its main claims and discussed these questions at considerable length in the first thread, including in our earlier exchange. I do not intend to repeat that discussion here.

For now, I’ll leave you to your other conversations.

Your interpretation about this verse is interesting but not what the text tells. To reach that conclusion, you need to detach the verse from its context, move it to a different context and define the meanings in a novel way. That demands quite subjective hermeneutics.

I have read that in ANE, light was not seen as tightly tied to the two large lights on the sky (sun, moon). There could be light even without sun or moon.

First, answers to your questions:
I believe that Jesus was both a human and God, one with our Heavenly Father.
I believe that God, the Creator, does not deceive.
I assume that scientific research can reveal certain aspects of the creation. The methods available for science restricts this information to the material universe.

I take the narratives in Genesis as being inspired by God. What that means is an interesting question in the case of Genesis.

There were no humans witnessing the creation, so the information was either revealed by God or God inspired the writer to write something that reveals the important lessons about the Creator and His relationship with humans and the other creation.

I do not believe that the biblical scriptures would generally be dictated word-by-word to the writers. They are inspired by God but not Word of God in the sense that every word would come directly from God.

I do not either believe that Genesis 1-3 would be a detailed and accurate report of what happened, in the sense of modern reports or modern history writing. The focal point is in the theological teachings, not in the detailed description of what happened or in the teaching of how our visible universe formed a long time ago. The teaching is told so that the ancient people could receive and understand the most important teachings. Apparently for that reason, the narratives are told in the cultural context and language of the original audience.

We are curious about the formation of the visible universe. That is natural but I do not think that our curiosity is a very important factor in the plans of God. It is ‘nice to know’ information for most of us, not something we necessarily need. From this viewpoint, it is quite understandable that God did not waste communication bandwith to ‘nice to know’ details. Especially as the original audience was not as interested as we are about this kind of ‘nice to know’ information

1 Like

You are right about one thing: I am indeed offering an interpretation. But the fact that it is an interpretation does not, by itself, show that it takes the verse out of context or arbitrarily changes its meaning.

And isn’t the claim that something is simply “what the text itself says” also an interpretation?

Let’s place different readings side by side and examine which one better explains the text as a whole, requires fewer additional assumptions, and leaves fewer substantial questions unanswered.

That seems to me the only reasonable way to compare interpretations. I am not asking anyone to assume in advance that mine is correct.

And if someone repeats a thousand times that their interpretation is not an interpretation but simply “what the text says,” repetition alone will not turn it into an established truth.

This brings me to another interesting question.

Consider the transition from Genesis 1 to Genesis 2–3. We encounter two significantly different ways of presenting Creation and humanity.

If, as you suggest, these accounts underwent a long process of oral transmission and subsequent editing, why were they not harmonized into a single, more logically consistent narrative?

Perhaps those differences were preserved deliberately. But why? What was the purpose of preserving them in this particular composition?

Isn’t this a reason to consider whether differences in the imagery might also point to differences in the reality those images express?

I agree. But consider for a moment what we actually mean when we say that God “revealed” something or “inspired” an author.

Can you imagine even one internally coherent account of how this might have happened?

I cannot. And that is precisely why I am reluctant to declare with confidence what could or could not have been communicated through Revelation.

And another question about oral transmission.

If the narrative was passed down from generation to generation, who exactly was its original audience?

Suppose Moses first communicated it to his listeners. Then their children, grandchildren, and later generations heard it as well. Were they no longer recipients of the message? Or did each new telling address a new audience?

And if the final written text appeared much later, why should the intellectual horizon of the earliest listeners determine the limits of its meaning for everyone else?

That is certainly a position you are entitled to hold.

But consider how many people, across centuries, have struggled to understand these chapters. Even on this forum, we keep returning to questions about their meaning.

And here is what I find myself thinking.

We cannot demonstrate the existence of a transcendent Creator, the soul, or divine Revelation in the same way that we establish ordinary empirical claims. We experience our own inner lives directly, but try presenting your soul to someone else and proving that it exists.

If we could arrive at an internally coherent reading of Genesis that explains its imagery and structure reasonably well, wouldn’t that be worth considering?

Of course, such an interpretation would not prove the existence of God.

But perhaps it might encourage at least a few people to reflect on their own relationship with the Creator.

Sometimes that might require very little: before saying something or taking an action, simply pause for a moment and ask yourself, “Would this be good in the eyes of the Creator?”

That would not save us from every mistake. But perhaps the world would become a little kinder.

We are so often in a hurry to live, preferring to decide for ourselves what counts as good and evil rather than bring our own will into relation with the Source of good.

An ancient greeting from Eden.

Perhaps. But how well do we really know God’s plans to determine confidently what matters within them and what does not?

And that leads me to another, much more personal question.

Here I am, a person living thousands of years after the first listeners of Genesis. Today I might do something morally good. Or I might do something morally reprehensible.

Does my action today matter to the Creator?

Or am I merely a fly on a windowpane to Him?

I genuinely do not know what place my actions occupy in His plans. But isn’t that precisely why I should take this question seriously?

What do you think?

1 Like

Fair enough Roman, and I understand your reluctance to revisit a discussion you’ve already devoted considerable time and effort to.

I also appreciate the thought you’ve put into developing and explaining your ideas, even where we disagree, and I agree that any serious criticism should begin with a fair and accurate understanding of the position being examined.

I still have some questions and reservations about your model, but there’s certainly no need to address them here if you’d rather not.

Just know that, whenever you feel like continuing our conversation, whether in this thread or any other thread of your choosing, I’ll be more than happy to pick it up again.

No pressure whatsoever, and thank you for the exchanges we’ve had so far.

1 Like

They are consistent – they only appear to be inconsistent when viewed through the lens of an alien worldview. There is a logical flow that connects them, we moderns just don’t see it because we arrogantly think the flow has to fit our worldview.

Some of the flow is evident even in translation and to modern eyes: from the universe-wide “heavens and earth”, a way of saying “everything that exists”, the first account narrows to focus on the earth, then narrows further to the installation of the image in Yahweh’s temple. The second account comes after this, with the making of a special pair of images/imagers, who are installed in a temple within a temple, a saacred space where they can walk with God. They are not the first humans, they are the first representatives of all humans – the first priest-kings. The focus has gone from “everything that exists” to a specific individual, who is given a helper, and with this duo the focus shifts from the relationship between Yahweh and all things to that between Yahweh and a special people.

Two very different things. Inspiration does not consist of God dumping information into someone’s brain, it consists of that someone’s unfolding of understanding gained through a relationship with God. Peter’s words show us that inspiration consists of being “moved by God” to write; there is no indication that the writers set down anything from outside their own experience – except on rare occasions when they explicitly report otherwise.

Yes: God chose someone while still in the womb, guided his life circumstances, then provided an impetus to write out of what he had learned.

Interestingly this doesn’t matter a whole lot given that the culture from clear back as far as Abraham right up through the return from Exile had a pretty consistent worldview; it wasn’t until Alexander came whomping across the land that a shift occurred.

This makes the mistake of conflating meaning with message: the meaning remains the same, the message shifts as audience changes. But the meaning cannot be unhinged from the original audience.
Things become subtle as the text (in the broad sense) gets edited, but the editorial alterations remained within the same worldview. For example, Hebrews in the time of Moses and in the time of Ezra would have all recognized that the first Creation account was both a temple inauguration and a ‘royal chronicle’ and understood it accordingly, despite the fact that Moses would have been thinking in terms of the Egyptian deity set in Genesis 1 while Ezra would have been thinking of the Babylonian (and possibly Assyrian) set. No change in the meaning occurs since the two deity sets differed only in names, not in nature.
But the message comes from application of the meaning to the circumstances of audiences. To use Moses and Ezra again, in the situation with Moses the gods of Egypt had just been thrashed thoroughly as Egypt was brought to ruin, whereas in the situation with Ezra the gods of Babylonia were practically ignored; in the first case due to a ruler who refused the will of Yahweh, in the second due to one who bowed to His will. In both instances the people are coming from “a strange land” back to their promised land, but in the first instance they never really had the land before while in the second they understood it as their heritage; the difference in message there could be summed up as the difference between “Yahweh will bring you to” as opposed to "Yahweh will bring you back to.
And that skips over all the intervening prophets and events.

1 Like

@St.Roymond gave already one possible answer. I can also think of additional ways how God can speak to humans. God has many ways, like giving messages through dreams, through messengers, as ‘internal speak’, like in the case of prophesying, or through lifting revealing images or words into the mind.

I have some background in charismatic circles and have received teaching and some experiences of how God tells messages to believers today. If it happens today in the case of ordinary believers, God certainly could tell revealing messages to those he chose to tell lasting messages.

My current church environment is charismatic in a fairly balanced way. We believe that God acts and speaks even today and encourage telling of what God has spoken but within orderly and sober limits.

Expressions like ‘Thus says the Lord’ are not encouraged and the trained persons never use such expressions because these give a false impression of how prophesying works today. One teacher (pastor) illustrated the phenomenon by telling that half of the spoken prophesy may come from the Lord but the other half comes from the prophesying person. God reveals messages but the way how the prophesying person delivers the message reflects her/his personality and experiences. The core of the message may be accurately from God but the rest of what is spoken could be called ‘the taste of the vessel’.

In the case of revealing images, delivering the message becomes even more subjective because both the receiving person and the listeners need to interpret what the image actually tells. In such cases, use of cautious expressions is wisdom.
We can see this kind of revealing images in Revelation. John was shown something and he wrote what he saw with the words and concepts he knew.

From this background, I can easily imagine how God could have given messages or inspired persons to tell or write something according to the will of the Lord. The message comes from God but how the receiving person tells or writes about the message reflects the language, experiences and worldview of the human. In this way, it happens in cooperation (symphony) between the Spirit of God and the human.

What I wrote above reflects subjective understanding about the topic. You may dismiss it as a ‘heretical’ belief but it shows that there are potential explanations of how God could speak to ancient people in ways that are judged to be outdated by us, the modern readers.

3 Likes