So I was listening to , I think it was “ The Bible for Normal People podcast hosted by Pete and Jared, or maybe it was Tim and Jon’s “‘The Bible Project “. I am not sure because I listened to like 13 hours of theological podcasts in one day while working. I’ll look it up later .
Anyways they were discussing was Abraham’s “ faithful response”’ the best response. When Abraham heard Yahweh say sacrifice your son to me and he was about to do it and was rewarded for being faithful was there not a better option Yahweh was hoping for.
Consider how when Yahweh wanted Abraham’s to save lot and slow him to destroy rape village of Sodom Abraham pleaded repeatedly what
If we find 10, 9 and ect… will you spare it. Then consider how when Moses was told by Yahweh he was going to kill off the tribe and make it new through him. Should Moses have responded faithfully by saying “‘yes your will be done “ showing he loved Yahweh more than his tribe? Or was it better that Moses argued with God and sad no kill me instead. Just like Jesus did.
Should Abraham have pushed back and said something along the lines of “ No God kill me instead “ or maybe he should have countered with , “‘Yahweh I know you don’t want this. It makes no sense. I know you are not a God who wants human sacrifice. Your hate it “. Would Abraham had showed not only faith to Yahweh but also that he better understood Yahweh than to think he wanted a child sacrifice.
Makes me think of animal sacrifice. Did Yahweh truly want it?
Hosea 6:6
New American Standard Bible
6 For O desire loyalty rather than sacrifice,
And the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings.
Or when Jesus said this.
Matthew 9:13
New American Standard Bible
13 Now go and learn what this means: ‘I desire compassion, rather than sacrifice,’ for I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners.”
Perhaps when someone wronged another in the Jewish camp what God wanted was for the person to say no…. I forgive you”
Maybe the only reason Yahweh asked for a sacrifice was because of the hardness of human hearts.
Thoughts?
I guess Richard Middleton has this book out that talks about this in. Definitely on my list of books I want.
“ Abraham’s Silence: The Binding of Isaac, the Suffering of Job, and How to Talk Back to God”
This was the episode. It was the Bible project ep 303 with Carmen Imes.