The logic or illogic of contradiction

  • Not to alter your point too much, but there’s a 1902 essay by Franz Pieper, a German-born, American Missouri-Synod Lutheran, that he presented at a Synodical Conference, entitled The Essence of Christianity - Franz Pieper [1902].
  • It’s relevance? Ask ChatGPT what Pieper says about Harnack.
1 Like

I took the time to read it myself, and what I found was a critique of von Harnack’s theology, but I don’t see how that refutes his historical research. I’m actually quite critical of von Harnack’s theology myself, especially considering that he never converted to the true Church despite the historical evidence he himself uncovered, documented, and acknowledged. :joy::joy::joy:

I’m too much of an exclusionary Christian to give a Lutheran theologian any credit for anything if he or she doesn’t believe in the resurrected Jesus.

1 Like

Sure like I said his theology is lousy but historical research is another field entirely. The important point is that he certainly had no vested interest in the historical conclusions he established. And him being a lousy theologian doesn’t make him a bad historian. Those two fields are unrelated. Pope Benedict XVI’s work on the historical Jesus for example was terrible, but he is one of the best theologians in the 20th century.

  • Guess I’m not giving him a chance. IMO, it would be like assuming someone knows a lot about India, China, or the Middle East just because they can find them on a map.

Well that’s a subjective assessment, Terry. I don’t think theological competence and historical competence are inextricably linked at all, otherwise an atheist would not be able to be an historian of the Church.

Even though I left the Catholic Church 52 years ago at the age of 14, I can still recite all the creeds. What you call belief is for me blind faith. The virtue of faith comes through experience, not indoctrination.

What date do you consider “early church” before or after Constantine?

How Early Christianity Lost Its Spirituality After Constantine | Shawn T Murphy

I was an atheist until the 20th of July 2014. I was 25 years old.

1 Like

The Church was already hierarchical and sacramental way before Constantine.

1 Like

If so, that points towards universalism.

Reasonably well, I’d say.

I’d forgotten about that; Harnack was a bad theologian, and really cannot be considered a Christian – which makes him a dubious representative of ‘Protestantism’ – though still a good historian as I recall.

Yes – the influence of Constantine is vastly overrated.

1 Like

Exactly. His theology matters zero, what matters is his historical expertise. Pope Benedict XVI was a lousy historian but one of the greatest theologian the Church ever had.

They can hardly be the case when even the anglicans have signed a joint declaration some time ago that the papacy might be in accordance with divine providence. Of course there are other obstacles even with them (especially because of their ecclesiology and other stuff) but still that is significant (I will provide the source of course).

I will go through Knor’s article as well, just like I have gone through Busenitz and his lies and distortions. We shall see if that article if different.

It is often overrated by those who want to push the idea that Protestantism (usually the denomination they belong to, one of the thousands existing ) has recovered ancient Christianity before evil Rome gained power and paganized Christianity.:rofl:

Too bad that it doesn’t hold any water and the early Church had nothing to do with Protestantism or anything its thousands denominations stand for.

If you read the Catholic version of history, but this is far from the truth.

There wasn’t a single, unified Christian organization that split neatly into denominations each century. Early Christian communities differed over belief, practice, leadership, and how to interpret scripture; historians’ labels can also oversimplify a more varied picture. In particular, “orthodox” and “heretical” often reflect later judgments. (cambridge.org)

1st century (c. 30–100)

The main divisions were debates within the Jesus movement, not fully separate denominations:

  • Jewish-oriented Jesus followers — maintained Jewish practices and debated how Gentile converts should relate to Jewish law.
  • Pauline or Gentile-inclusive Christians — associated especially with Paul’s mission; generally did not require Gentile converts to be circumcised or keep the whole Mosaic law.
  • Other local Christian communities and teachers — differed in leadership, worship, and belief. It is difficult to map these into stable, empire-wide factions. The separation of Christianity from Judaism was gradual and uneven. (cambridge.org)

2nd century (c. 100–200)

Christianity became more diverse, while communities increasingly defined their boundaries:

  • Emerging “proto-orthodox” Christians — a modern label for communities that emphasized continuity with the apostles, shared scripture, and the authority of bishops. They were not yet one fully uniform bloc.
  • Jewish-Christian groups — including groups later called Ebionites and Nazarenes; their beliefs and practices varied.
  • Marcionites — followers of Marcion, who sharply distinguished the God of the Hebrew scriptures from the God revealed by Jesus and used a distinctive collection of Christian writings.
  • Groups later labeled “Gnostic” — diverse movements that offered distinctive accounts of creation, revelation, and salvation; “Gnostic” can be an overly broad catch-all.
  • Montanists — a prophetic movement emphasizing new revelations and strict moral discipline.
  • Other disputes — including disagreements over the date of Easter and church authority. (cambridge.org)

3rd century (c. 200–300)

Debates over church authority, discipline, and the nature of God became more prominent:

  • Emerging catholic/mainstream churches — increasingly organized around bishops and shared teaching, though still diverse.
  • Monarchians — a broad label for efforts to emphasize God’s oneness. Some, often called modalists, described Father, Son, and Spirit as modes or manifestations of the one God; others took different approaches.
  • Adoptionist or “dynamic monarchian” teachers — explained Jesus’ divine status in terms of God’s power or adoption, rather than the same account used by later Nicene theology.
  • Novatianists — a rigorist schism in Rome over whether Christians who had renounced their faith under persecution could be readmitted to the church.
  • Continuing Montanist and other regional movements — alongside disputes over scripture, bishops, and Christian identity. (oca.org)

4th century (c. 300–400)

After Christianity gained imperial favor, disputes became more public and politically consequential:

  • Donatists — especially in North Africa; they disputed the legitimacy of clergy who had compromised during persecution and argued over the church’s purity and authority.
  • Nicene Christians — upheld the Council of Nicaea’s claim that the Son is homoousios (“of the same substance”) with the Father.
  • Non-Nicene Christians — not one united “Arian” faction. Positions included:
    • Homoiousians: the Son is “like in substance” to the Father.
    • Homoians: the Son is “like” the Father, while avoiding claims about substance.
    • Anomoeans: the Son is unlike the Father in substance.
    • Arius and his supporters: associated with the view that the Son was not coeternal with the Father, though the label “Arian” was often applied broadly to differing opponents of Nicaea.
  • Pneumatomachians (“Spirit-fighters”) — disputed the full divinity of the Holy Spirit.
  • Novatianist and other schismatic churches — continued in some regions. By the end of the century, Nicene belief had gained imperial backing, but disagreement did not disappear. (saet.ac.uk)

In brief: The first century’s central tensions concerned Jewish law and Gentile inclusion; the second century saw competing interpretations and scriptures; the third brought sharper disputes over authority and God’s oneness; and the fourth was dominated by Trinitarian controversies and church schisms.

Horseshit. Adolf Von Harnack is far from a Catholic. He wasn’t even a proper Christian, properly speaking.

1 Like

I did not reference Harnack in my post. Any serious researcher looks at independent sources.

Define “independent”. Are you claiming that the Protestant (and heretical even for the protestant standards which is saying something) historian Adolf Von Harnack was somehow a Roman apologist? Because otherwise “indipendent” looks like “whoever confirms the version that I like”.

1 Like

Reread my post. I listed the major divisions in Christianity in the first 4 centuries to demonstrate that Catholicism was not the only belief as you indicated. After killing all the heretics, they might have been the only Christianity left until the Reformation, though. These are two very different views of history, and I am trying to enlighten you, but the room is still dark.

Where did I state it was the only belief? It was the only orthodox and apostolic belief. That’s the difference.

1 Like