The logic or illogic of contradiction

Go read how the Fathers of the Church treated the Arians and heretics in general. They didn’t exactly use the most polite words, believe me. They used very harsh words. Very.

Because they saw them as a threat to orthodoxy and unity in the faith. And with good reasons. Very good reasons.

1 Like

ok, well water and ice. The same substance but one solid and one is liquid.

Are liquids and solids the same? Or are they contradictory in nature.

The stem is gassiuos. Different again and has rules contrary to the other two. Yet in one place they all exist?

Well maybe it depends on your perspective. Not that I would claim one for certain.

Would probably need to be specific.

That would appear to be the case, yes. Otherwise it is meaningless.

And any specifics you claim will not universalise the definition. Each one is assessed on its own merit, oh dear , that is not a popular principle with you is it. You prefer to relate it to who said it.

Try again.
Richard

John 16:13. Care to address those words from Jesus Himself.

So insults are justifiable. All you need is good reason?

Would you like me to throw some your way? With good reason?

I guess it would be justifiable from your words to me, but…

Forum rules aside, I always thought insults were a sign of you losing and running out of arguments, A bit like repeating justifications over and over as if they would mean something different.

Or maybe I should ask AI! I’m sure it could come up with some real doozies.

Richard

Calling someone a heretic is not, in itself, an insult. I, too, am a heretic from a Muslim perspective (and emphatically so). Likewise, many Protestants have called me an idolater, accusing me of worshipping idols and praying to them, among other allegations that are not even factually accurate.

There is a certain irony in such accusations, considering that many of these man-made ecclesial communities seem perfectly willing to bow before what is arguably the greatest idol of all: the world itself (which is why many of them accommodate the Gospel to the demands of the world in homosexuality, remarriages, women ordination, sometimes even abortion and I could go on and on). Perhaps that also helps explain why they are so readily accepted and embraced by the world. Yet Christ’s warning in Luke 6:26 could hardly be clearer: “Woe to you when everyone speaks well of you, for that is how their ancestors treated the false prophets.”

Furthermore, the Seventh Ecumenical Council explicitly condemned iconoclasm and pronounced anathemas against its defenders. Yet why should those who have established entirely new forms of Christianity feel bound by the judgments of an ecumenical council? After all, they have effectively created their own versions of the Christian faith.

But returning to the central point: to describe someone as a heretic in relation to the orthodox Christianity of the first millennium, including the faith professed by the earliest Church, is not necessarily to insult that person. It is to make a doctrinal assessment against a historically identifiable standard.

Just as a Muslim would regard me as a heretic (and might even accuse me of polytheism, since Islamic theology generally rejects the Trinity as incompatible with absolute divine unity) so too can your beliefs be evaluated against the doctrinal standards of historic apostolic Christianity.

Your theological positions are objectively heretical when measured against the orthodox faith of the first millennium and the doctrines preserved and transmitted by the historic apostolic Churches—not merely the Catholic Church, but also the Eastern Orthodox and other ancient apostolic communions.

That is not a personal insult. It is a description of the doctrinal incompatibility between your beliefs and those of historic apostolic Christianity. The term heresy has a precise theological meaning; it is not merely an expression of personal contempt.

And again, I am equally a heretic in the eyes of Muslims. I do not flinch, take offense, or consider myself personally insulted when they describe me that way. I simply recognize that, according to their theological framework, my beliefs are incompatible with what they consider orthodox doctrine.

Doctrinal disagreement is not the same thing as personal disrespect, and identifying a theological position as heretical is not inherently an act of hostility toward the person who holds it.

ACTUALLY IT IS AN ACT OF CHARITY.

1 Like
  • “Try again”? Not in a million years.
  • The fact that you responded to my post and did not accuse me of misunderstanding your nonsense is evidence of … your nonsense. :laughing:
2 Likes

Also whether the conditions for that promise to function can be broken.

“and the gates of hell shall not prevail against her”

False dichotomy. The nature of the two is the same: to behave in a manner consistent with their molecular structure.

Has nothing to do with teaching authority.

It has a lot to do with that. If the Church could become something that feeds scorpion and snakes to the children of God, the gates of Hell would most definitely have prevailed.

But that will never happen.

All human institutions are born and, at some point, crumble. The Catholic Church will still exist in AD 30,000 if humanity is still around by then (which I doubt, to be honest. IMHO, the Second Coming is only a few centuries away)

And give you a few atta-boy compliments to boot. :wink:

1 Like
  • Not quite; reunion with loved ones and reconciliation with my enemies.
    See
1 Like

Not contradictory, just different.

1 Like

Presenting beliefs as facts leads to subsequently presented facts being mistaken for beliefs.

Of course I cannot prove this, but I’m sure the Catholic Church will endure until the end of humanity because she was founded by our Lord Himself.

You could enthrone Luther himself to the papacy and he wouldn’t be able to destroy the Catholic Church or impose his heresies on her and on catholics *. That’s my belief. I cannot conclusively prove it but I’m sure of it, because of my faith in the Holy Spirit and His protection.

*And I’m not sure Pope Francis was significantly more orthodox than Luther, on a personal level … like…at all. Pope Francis’ orthodoxy and Catholic faith is one of the things I’m absolutely LESS sure about. May God forgive me if I’m wrong.

  • Thank God you Tommies are not all the same. :laughing:
1 Like