The ID movement’s large-scale view of evolution: America is at stake

Ben Carson was the keynote? Wow. How the mighty have fallen.

The ID movement crashed and burned when their “teach the controversy” push against evolution in science curricula also crashed and burned in 2018-19. (I wrote about it back then for ASA: Teaching the Controversy in Texas.) The Texas State Board of Education (elected) approved it for the 9th grade biology curriculum, which is when high school biology is taught in Texas, but textbook publishers refused to include the BS, and teachers sued because they were on their own to find materials and the DI’s suggested stuff (like population genetics and organic chemistry) was far beyond 9th-graders’ heads. Courts agreed that it was ridiculous.

With its education initiative and academic journal, Bio-Complexity, dead in the water, Discovery has spent the last five years unsuccessfully trying to latch itself onto the MAGA culture war, hence the “America Is at Stake” tag on the conference and Ben Carson as the keynote speaker.

Discovery Institute is playing in the minor leagues now. They’re irrelevant to the larger conversation.

3 Likes

There seems to be a delusion that ID = YEC and or ID excludes any Evolution. Neither being true.

As for ID affecting politics?

:rofl:

Richard

Give ID is mostly old earth creation I don’t see how people could make this mistake.

Pretty sure it does exclude macro-evolution but includes micro-evolution.

More like 50:50 old vs young earth, based on lists of DI fellows and conference presenters.

The ID leadership deliberately don’t discuss age-of-earth topics in order to maintain their marquee and not lose a lot of their support. Some of them, eg Stephen Meyer, are extremely cagey regarding their views.