I think the thing to pay attention to is the differences between [A] and [B]. I think there is evidence for the existence of God … but I don’t believe that evidence can be categorized as Scientific evidence. So, [A] is awfully important… touching on what can be properly called science or not.
While in [B] I can say that in my opinion, the existence of consciousness is a crucial evidence for a cosmic mind!
“Fine Tuning”, on the other hand … is simply acknowledging the circular nature of knowledge! If you had a recipe for humans that required at least 10.5% iron … and all of humanity had 10…6% iron… is that proof of anything? No.
It is simply proof that the threshold for iron in making humans really is about 10.5%!