Because the 318 bishops gathered at Nicaea had a poorer understanding of the Bible than you do, and since they were not protected by the Holy Spirit at all, they imposed erroneous doctrines on everyone.
think it is important to show everyone where sola Scriptura can lead. You have rejected the Trinitarian faith to the point of considering the matter âsettled.â
If this is not proof of the unimaginable errors that can arise from your approach, I donât know what is.
Anyway, you have authoritatively concluded that:
The 318 bishops gathered at Nicaea fell into error.
You have arrived at a more accurate understanding of Scripture than they did.
You consider the matter settled.
For all intents and purposes, you are your own Church.
There really is no point of continuing, with you and anyone else like you. Bye bye.
P.s: but I do think that you should serve as a cautionary tale to show where sola Scriptura can lead, since you rejected the trinitarian faith on the grounds of sola Scriptura ( which is the most venomous and poisonous pile of fuming horseshit ever invented in the entire history of Christianity, on top of being of being a guarantee of division, errors, and heresies).
As C. S. Lewis noted, when the great teachers of the church speak with one voice, we must conclude that this is the voice of the Spirit.
I donât think the citations Massimiliano provides establish the Immaculate Conception of Mary, but they at least support my view, that by the virtue of the Incarnation Mary became the true Temple and was therefore cleansed of sin â the very same thing we look forward to.
Nor do I think his position vis a vis Rome is established, but at the very least the absolute authority of the councils through Chalcedon follows. Thus the Creed and the Definition are not to be challenged.
Thatâs not what the promise says. Jesus explicitly said that there was more teaching to be had, and that the Spirit would bring it.
And Paul taught that the Spirit gives teachers to the church. Those have to be sought among the unanimity of the voice of the Fathers.
Neither do I. They do not establish it beyond reasonable doubt, but they do provide a biblical foundation for it. In short, it is certainly not something that contradicts Scripture.
At most, it contradicts certain interpretations of Scripture.
Iâm not saying that the Immaculate Conception is the only rationally and biblically possible interpretation, but it is certainly a possible one, if we consider Scripture + Tradition.
So from Scripture + Tradition it could be established as a possible interpretation, not as an interpretation necessarily commanded by the text
But I do not believe that the Holy Spirit would have allowed this doctrine to be solemnly defined as dogma if it were false.
If it had not been dogmatized, I would consider the matter non liquet, in the sense that there would still be reasons to accept this doctrine, just as there would be reasons to hold a different position.
What is decisive for me is the fact that it has been solemnly defined as dogma. And, as I said, I do not believe the Holy Spirit would have allowed the Church to dogmatize something false.
Again, that denies the promise Jesus made, and scoffs at the teaching of Paul.
Since when were they ever considered teachers of the church?
Just BTW, in the context wherre that was said it wasnât a defensive promise, it was an offensive, mission-field promise â not the church defending against Hell, but Hellâs minions falling before the âonslaughtâ of the Gospel.
True â but that has nothing to do with the promise Christ made.
The only way to escape the authority of those the Apostles appointed to succeed them is to show that the conditions of the promise were broken â and thereâs nothing in the first, second, or third century that remotely qualifies.
Youâre missing the point: Jesus made a promise that the Apostles would teach the truth, a promise that is meaningless unless they had successors. That has nothing to do with being immune to sin; a bishop (hypothetically) could have been a drunken gay slave owner and that does not nullify the promise.
In effect your are denying the power of the Word.
And Jesus had them corrected.
Your position even denies the point from the Old Testament that Yahweh will not leave His people without a testimony.
Unfortunately that is contrary to the Bible! If the Holy Spirit gives teachers to the church, to not even seek out those teachers is disloyalty.
Right â it applies to the seventy-two. Nothing says it applies to anyone not appointed to ministry.
And self-appointment doesnât count: "No one takes this honor upon himself; he must be called by God, just as Aaron was.â
Luther at least had a degree and was authorized to teach the scriptures. What do you have?