So say you. In practice in most churches, the doctrine of original sin has no practical effect because it really doesn’t mean anything since we all sin and thus have our own goofs to worry about.
My response to someone worrying about original sin comes from the movie Meatballs: “It just doesn’t matter.”
Only if you deny the authority of scripture. That we are made in/as the image of God is not just found in the opening Creation story.
And it shouldn’t feed anyone’s vanity, it should feed humility because it is a terrible burden.
I’m not convinced at the moment that God is such a lawyer. Even if God did for some reason count the sins of parents against the children, it just doesn’t matter: Jesus dealt with that, so we stand or fall by our own sins.
I think a Jewish rabbi would nod in agreement (in principle) because the effects of that first rebellion were one of the things Messiah was expected to fix. I can just imagine one of the rabbis I knew in grad school asking, “If you think Messiah fixed it, why so worried are you?”
Yes, humans have a level of self-awareness (metaconsciousness) that animals lack, which allows us to deliberate over behavioural (and moral) alternatives and choose behaviours that are not in our evolutionary best interest (like true altruism).
Unbiblical not found in, authorized by, or based on the Bible
Well last time I looked Genesis 2-4 was in the Bible
Unauthorised? By whom? You?
Unorthodox, yes. Unbiblical, No.
You admit that Genesis 1-2 is Myth, because it suits you. Is that authorised?
Unfortunately you are desperate for parts of the Garden Narrative to be literal, and I know why.
The Passion does not rely on The Fall. We are perfectly capable of sinning without Adam’s help or some vane notion of humans being created special.
How can we be an image of a being who has no visible structure in this reality. You know the answer to that as well, of course but that doesn’t matter either. Of course, even that claim makes humans special.
Why must humans be special (Scripture aside). What evidence is there that we are any different from the rest of nature?
None
So we must be fallen QED.
There is no need to continue on with Eternity.
God wouldn’t dream of accommodation.
And we can’t have misunderstood something that crucial!
I am not sure that is the Orthodox view Original Sin or no.
If I have sinned I am a sinner. Once that sin is forgiven, I am not a sinner.
That is the Gospel.
Otherwise, why bother repenting at all! It makes a mockery of the Sunday Service. If we are still sinners then God is still separated from us so the prayers cannot reach Him and neither can He reach us. (Orthodoxy)
Exactly – and it is not “pre-revelation myth and legend”. As to literature it is myth, in the literary sense, it is not legend, and it is not “pre-revelation”
Because that’s a literary category it falls into.
What suits me is what a kind of literature it is.
False.
No, it relies on the three OT rebellions, not just one.
You have this fixation on sin and humans being special that rely on misrepresenting/ignoring scholarship. And “humans being created special” is not vain, it is revealed – and if you have the wit to recognize it, it is nothing to be vain about anyway, it is a severe burden.
The same way a piece of polished stone could be an image of a being with a totally different structure. A visible structure “source” is not necessary for being a material image.
Try getting an education about the concept of “image” in the ANE.
You have a wuss for a deity.
Not in the least: we are as close as ever, since on the Cross Jesus was simul iustus et pecator. As Paul put it, Jesus became sin for us.
You abandon a lot of the richness of God’s grace with your demotion of the sscripture to what you want to see it as.
I agree with everything else you wrote but this deserves an important qualification, because calling Christ simul iustus et peccator is a profound theological error if it means that He was personally both righteous and sinful. Scripture explicitly declares that He “knew no sin” (2 Corinthians 5:21), “committed no sin” (1 Peter 2:22), and was “holy, innocent, undefiled” (Hebrews 7:26).
Christ bore our sins without becoming a sinner, and His righteousness was intrinsic and perfect, not merely attributed to Him. Confusing the assumption of our guilt with personal sinfulness completely distorts the nature of His sacrifice (i’m not sure that’s what you were doing, you probably weren’t, but still, a qualification was warranted).
Furthermore, divine grace does not merely conceal a sinner’s corruption beneath an external declaration of righteousness. God actually makes us righteous. Scripture declares that we become “a new creation” (2 Corinthians 5:17), are “washed, sanctified, justified” (1 Corinthians 6:11), and are inwardly renewed by the Holy Spirit (Titus 3:5). Romans 5:5 teaches that God’s love is poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit.
Augustine likewise taught that God justifies the ungodly by making them righteous through His grace (On the Spirit and the Letter).
Justification is not divine make-believe or sweeping the filth under the rug, and God does not merely declare filthy souls clean while leaving them unchanged: He truly cleanses, sanctifies, and transforms them. The righteousness He gives is a real participation in His grace, not merely an external status.
Sure, sin remains a possibility, but grace genuinely renews the soul.
Exactly. It is revealed in the plainest and clearest way. Scripture lends itself to contradictory interpretations on many points: human being created special is not one of them, it is stated in the most unambiguous way.
If with this you mean that human nature is wounded by original sin and consequently inclined toward evil, I agree.
Simply put, we inherit a fallen human nature, deprived of original holiness and justice and wounded by original sin, but we do not inherit personal culpability for sins we ourselves have never committed, and our personal sins arise from our own free choices, not from an irresistible compulsion (as James 1:14–15 explains, temptation leads to sin through the individual’s response to desire. Moreover, God’s grace genuinely heals and strengthens our wounded nature, enabling us to resist sin and freely cooperate with Him).
Well, there’s a dismissal of both Paul and Peter. Did God choose the wrong people?
It is human oral tradition that God wanted written down for us to learn from. And saying “The Apostles were wrong, I know better” is not a place to start for learning!
Sorry, but all of Christianity for two millennia disagrees.
The Doctrine of the Fall was first proposed by Justyn Martyr in the second Century (Not Peter or Paul who were Jews and Judaism dose not have either the Fall or Original Sin)
It did not become Fully Orthodox until the 6th Century by the Second Council of Orange AD 529
Original Sin was primarily encouraged by “Sunday Gustine” but may not have been Orthodox as such until the Great Schism of 1054 and even that is open for debate.
(Info via AI)
So it would appear that you are a little previous and definitely exaggerating.
Richard
Looks like they both Evolved, one deviation at a time
Having had my theology drawn out and criticised by AI it would appear that I am by no means alone and there is historical support that points in the direction I have headed.
I am happy to send a copy of the transcript in the form of a theological summary to anyone who is genuinely interested in my thought processes and reasoning as opposed to just dismissing or claiming it illogical;
My theology is, apparently rounded, logical and robust with Scriptural backing and Christian intent, but would be considered unorthodox by Catholic or Protestan alike.