Eddie, if I rushed out to read every new book involving evolution from scholarly presses, I would be broke and never have time for anything else. My admittedly quick assessment seems entirely accurate. In my view, yours is the partisan one, frequently implying that Shapiro, etc are major players in evolutionary theory. That is just not true. How about applying your professional standards to my field? Look at what is really happening in evolutionary biology. Look at whether your heroes are really contributing something novel that shakes the foundations of evolutionary theory.
And above all, if you think my assessment of Wagner was inaccurate, tell me what was inaccurate about it. That would be the scholarly approach.