The Forgotten Calendar of Jesus - What Happened to the Biblical Festivals?

This denies the Gospel as presented in the OT, where the promise is for all nations.

Jesus made things holy by His mere presence, and that includes the days of the year. So since He lived on this earth for many years, every day of the year is holy.

Well said.

1 Like

And any celebration of the “victory of light” belongs not to any pagan deity, but to Jesus. So even if Christmas had started out as pagan, it was right to reclaim it for Jesus.

St.Roymond, I think we have reached the point where context itself has to become part of the discussion, because you have accused me of pulling out one part of the law while the texts being offered against my argument are themselves being isolated from the arguments in which they occur.

We cannot do responsible exegesis by extracting one sentence from Paul, assigning it a meaning, and then using that sentence to interpret everything else. We have to ask what question is being addressed, what comes before the statement, what comes after it, and whether our interpretation remains coherent with the rest of the passage and the larger scriptural record.

Take Acts 15. The controversy is stated at the beginning: “Except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved” (Acts 15:1). Verse 5 develops that dispute. Peter then addresses the salvation of the Gentiles through faith and grace. James renders his judgment and, within that same judgment, observes that Moses is preached in every city and “read in the synagogues every sabbath day” (Acts 15:21). That is the context. The council never says, “The appointed times of Yah are abolished.” If that is what Acts 15 means, then that conclusion must be demonstrated from the passage rather than inserted into it.

The same applies to Galatians 5. You cited Paul’s statement that the circumcised man is “a debtor to do the whole law” (v. 3). But Paul does not stop speaking at the end of verse 3. The very next verse identifies the issue: “whosoever of you are justified by the law; ye are fallen from grace” (v. 4). Paul is addressing circumcision and Torah observance as a basis of justification. I have never argued that keeping Passover, Tabernacles, Sabbath, or any other commandment purchases salvation. So quoting verse 3 while separating it from verse 4 does not answer my position.

Context also matters when Paul is interpreted against Paul. He says that faith does not make void the law but establishes it (Romans 3:31), calls the law holy and the commandment holy, just and good (Romans 7:12), and says that he delights in the law of Elohim according to the inward man (Romans 7:22). An interpretation of Paul that has him simply abolishing Torah must account for those statements rather than selecting only those sentences that appear to support abolition.

That is the method I am applying here: context before conclusion; Scripture interpreting Scripture; and no isolated verse being permitted to overturn the larger testimony without demonstrating that the text actually says what is being claimed for it.

Any further consideration of these questions must therefore engage the texts in their full context rather than simply restating conclusions that have already been addressed.

As for the Name, that is a separate subject and I am willing to discuss it separately. But changing the subject does not answer the question before us: What biblical text authorizes the abandonment or replacement of Yah’s appointed calendar? If there is such a text, identify it and let us examine it in its full context.

I agree that context should drive the interpretation. Yet, we should remember that even the claimed context may be an interpretation.

The ‘calendar’ you are speaking about belongs to the covenant between Israel and God; the covenant that was given through Moses. The covenant including circumcision as a sign.

Hebrews 9-10 is one passage speaking about the difference between the covenants. It tells that the regulations and customs of the covenant given through Moses are
“external regulations applying until the time of the new order” (NIV).
Hebrews 9-10 does not speak about the calendar but the calendar was tied to the covenant between Israel and God, like the priesthood, sacrifices, food regulations and washings.

Paul was a circumcised Jew and wrote that those who circumcise themselves need to fulfill the law in Torah. Although Paul probably lived according to the law of grace, I assume that he himself followed the laws in Torah, interpreted through his new understanding.
Paul rebuked Peter when he tried to distance himself from the pagan Christians:
“14 When I saw that they were not acting in line with the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas in front of them all, “You are a Jew, yet you live like a Gentile and not like a Jew. How is it, then, that you force Gentiles to follow Jewish customs?” (Galatians 2, NIV).
And he rebuked Galatians:
“9 But now that you know God—or rather are known by God—how is it that you are turning back to those weak and miserable forces[d]? Do you wish to be enslaved by them all over again? 10 You are observing special days and months and seasons and years! 11 I fear for you, that somehow I have wasted my efforts on you.”

The Christians that are not circumcised are not part of the covenant given through Moses, although they are sprouting from the roots that grow in the soil of OT. We live in the covenant of grace, given through Yeshua, and we follow the rules of that covenant, not the regulations and customs of the covenant given through Moses.

The covenant of grace is rooted in the covenant between God and Abraham (Galatians 3). According to the covenant of grace, the ‘calendar’ follows the rules written in Romans 14:
“5 One person considers one day more sacred than another; another considers every day alike. Each of them should be fully convinced in their own mind. 6 Whoever regards one day as special does so to the Lord. Whoever eats meat does so to the Lord, for they give thanks to God; and whoever abstains does so to the Lord and gives thanks to God.” (NIV).

2 Likes

Kai, thank you. This is much closer to the kind of engagement I have been asking for because you have presented a covenantal argument and identified the texts from which you believe that argument follows.

But that also allows us to test the argument rather than merely exchange conclusions.

First, we need to distinguish text, interpretation, and inference.

The text is what Scripture actually states. An interpretation explains what those words mean in their grammatical, historical, and literary context. An inference is a conclusion drawn from what the text states even though the conclusion itself is not expressly stated.

There is nothing inherently illegitimate about interpretation or inference. We all interpret Scripture. But an inference must be demonstrated from the text, and an interpretation must account for the whole testimony of Scripture. We cannot insert a proposition Scripture never states and then use that proposition as though Scripture itself had said it.

This is particularly important because Yahshua established a controlling principle for biblical interpretation: “the scripture cannot be broken” (John 10:35).

That leaves us with an unavoidable methodological requirement. An interpretation of Paul cannot contradict Moses. An interpretation of Hebrews cannot contradict the Prophets. An interpretation of the New Covenant cannot contradict Yah’s own definition of that covenant. And none of them can require Yahshua to contradict the Scriptures that he expressly declared cannot be broken.

Scripture must remain coherent: Yah, Torah, Moses, the Prophets, Yahshua, and the Apostles must be allowed to testify together.

Now let us apply that standard to your argument.

You wrote that the calendar belongs to the covenant given through Moses and that Christians “live in the covenant of grace, given through Yeshua” and therefore “follow the rules of that covenant, not the regulations and customs of the covenant given through Moses.”

But Scripture does not define the New Covenant that way.

Yah defines it before Hebrews ever discusses it:

“I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah… I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts.” (Jeremiah 31:31–33)

And this is not merely an Old Testament text that Christians are free to leave behind. Hebrews itself quotes this very prophecy when explaining the New Covenant (Hebrews 8:8–12).

Therefore the proposition that the New Covenant replaces Yah’s Torah with an entirely different body of “rules” cannot simply be assumed. The prophetic definition says that Yah writes His law upon the heart. Hebrews adopts that definition. Any interpretation of Hebrews must account for it.

Now consider Hebrews 9:10. You cited the NIV’s “external regulations applying until the time of the new order.” But what does the passage actually identify?

The immediate argument concerns the tabernacle, priestly access, gifts and sacrifices, purification of the conscience, food, drink, various washings, and regulations pertaining to the body. Hebrews 9:10 itself identifies “food and drink and various ceremonial washings—external regulations.”

The appointed calendar is not stated there.

Your argument therefore makes an additional inference: because the appointed times were commanded within the Mosaic covenant, whatever Hebrews says was temporary in Hebrews 9:10 must necessarily include the appointed times.

But that conclusion is precisely what must be proved.

You cannot place Passover, Unleavened Bread, Weeks, Trumpets, Atonement, and Tabernacles into Hebrews 9:10 when the author did not place them there, and then cite Hebrews 9:10 as proof that the author removed them. That is circular: the conclusion has first been inserted into the premise and then recovered from it as though the text supplied it.

Galatians 4 presents an equally serious contextual problem.

Paul does not begin his argument at verse 10. He first reminds the Galatians:

“when ye knew not God, ye did service unto them which by nature are no gods” (Galatians 4:8).

He then asks why they are turning back again to the “weak and beggarly elements” under which they had formerly been enslaved (4:9), and only then says:

“Ye observe days, and months, and times, and years” (4:10).

These Gentiles had not previously been covenant-observant Israelites keeping Yah’s appointed times. Paul explicitly describes their former condition as serving beings “which by nature are no gods.”

Therefore simply asserting that the “days, months, seasons and years” of verse 10 are Yah’s appointed times does not establish it. The identification itself must be demonstrated from Paul’s argument, including his repeated language of returning to something that had enslaved them before they knew Elohim.

Romans 14 has the same evidentiary problem.

Paul discusses disputes involving eating, abstaining, regarding one day above another, conscience, and believers judging one another. But Romans 14:5 never says:

Passover is now optional.

It never says:

Tabernacles is now optional.

It never says:

Yah’s appointed calendar has been abolished.

And it never says:

The New Covenant replaces Yah’s appointed calendar with whatever days each individual Christian personally chooses to regard.

Those propositions are not in the text.

They are interpretations being inferred from the text. Therefore they carry the burden of demonstration; they cannot themselves serve as the proof.

This brings us back to the question I have deliberately kept narrow throughout this discussion.

I am not asking whether circumcision justifies Gentiles.

I am not asking whether animal sacrifices continue unchanged.

I am not asking whether the Levitical priesthood continues unchanged.

I am not asking whether believers earn salvation by observing Torah.

And I am not asking whether the New Covenant exists.

Those are different questions.

The question before us is:

What biblical text authorizes the abandonment or replacement of Yah’s appointed calendar?

If the answer is Hebrews 9–10, then demonstrate where Hebrews places Yah’s appointed times among the things being removed.

If the answer is Galatians 4, then demonstrate contextually that Paul’s “days and months and seasons and years” are Yah’s appointed times, while accounting for his statement that these Gentiles were returning to something associated with their former bondage when they “knew not God.”

If the answer is Romans 14, then demonstrate where Paul identifies Yah’s appointed times as the disputable days he is discussing and where he transfers Yah’s authority to appoint sacred times to individual preference.

That is the evidentiary burden.

And because “the scripture cannot be broken,” the resulting interpretation must remain coherent with Yah’s Torah, the Prophets, Yahshua, and the Apostles. It cannot merely solve one Pauline passage by creating contradictions elsewhere in Scripture.

If the text establishes the proposition, then the text should decide the matter. But if the proposition exists only after something has been added to the text, then we must distinguish clearly between what Scripture says and what an interpreter has concluded that Scripture must mean.

  • Knor, the challenge question is: “What biblical text authorizes the abandonment or replacement of Yah’s appointed calendar?”
  • If the appointed times remain binding upon New-Covenant believers, what does Paul mean when he says, in Colossians 2:16-17, “Let no one judge you … with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath”?
1 Like

Knor, Terry’s interjection raises a proposition that has already been addressed at least twice in this exchange, but it is worth stating the distinction again because it is central to the argument.

Yah’s rejection of Israel’s festivals, new moons, Sabbaths, sacrifices, prayers, and assemblies was not a rejection of the appointed calendar He Himself commanded. It was a rejection of people offering outward religious observance while simultaneously living in transgression against Him. Their observance had become lip service.

Isaiah makes the reason explicit: their hands were full of blood; they were doing evil and neglecting justice and righteousness. Yah therefore rejected what they were bringing before Him—not because His appointed times had suddenly become illegitimate, but because their worship was illegitimate. He called them to wash themselves, cease doing evil, learn to do good, and practice righteousness.

The distinction matters. Rejecting a hypocritical observance is not the same thing as abolishing the command being hypocritically observed. Just as an insincere “I’m sorry, please forgive me” does not invalidate repentance itself, corrupt observance of Yah’s appointed times does not constitute their repeal.

Yah wanted His appointed times honored in earnest, in obedience, and in righteousness, rather than performed ceremonially by people whose lives contradicted the covenant.

So we return to the question that has governed this discussion from the beginning: What biblical text actually authorizes the abandonment or replacement of Yah’s appointed calendar?

That proposition still requires a text that says or demonstrates it. A text condemning corrupt worship does not do so.

Again, context is everything. We cannot isolate a single verse from the argument in which it appears and then manufacture from it a conclusion the text itself never states. The passage must be read as a whole, within its immediate and broader scriptural context. An inference drawn from a text is not the same thing as what the text actually says.

  • Knor, I cited neither Isaiah nor a text condemning corrupt worship. I cited Colossians 2:16–17. My question is simply: If the appointed times remain binding upon New-Covenant believers, what does Paul mean by “Let no one judge you … with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath”?
2 Likes

Terry, you are correct. Your question concerned Colossians 2:16–17, whereas my preceding response addressed the prophetic passages concerning Yah’s rejection of corrupt worship. Those are separate arguments, so let me answer the passage you actually cited.

Paul says: “Let no one judge you” with regard to food, drink, a festival, a new moon, or a Sabbath. The text does not say, “Do not observe a festival, new moon, or Sabbath,” nor does it say that Yah’s appointed times have been abolished or replaced.

That distinction is precisely the issue under examination. If Paul intended to announce the cessation of these appointed times, where does he actually say so? “Let no one judge you with regard to” something and “you are no longer to observe” that thing are not equivalent propositions.

Verse 17 likewise calls these things “a shadow of things to come.” Whatever theological significance one assigns to “shadow,” the word itself does not mean “abolished,” and Paul’s wording still requires interpretation before it can be made into a command to abandon the appointed times.

So my answer to your question is straightforward: Paul is telling the Colossians not to permit others to judge them concerning food, drink, festivals, new moons, or Sabbaths. That is what the text says. The further conclusion—that New-Covenant believers therefore are no longer to observe Yah’s appointed times—is an inference that must be demonstrated from the passage.

And that returns us to the original question: What biblical text authorizes the abandonment or replacement of Yah’s appointed calendar?

Again, context is everything. We cannot isolate a single verse from the argument in which it appears and then manufacture from it a conclusion the text itself never states. The passage must be read as a whole, within its immediate and broader scriptural context. An inference drawn from a text is not the same thing as what the text actually says.

To wrap this discussion up, I sincerely appreciate everyone who has contributed, including those who have challenged my argument and offered contrary interpretations. The purpose of posting this article was to subject the proposition to examination, and I have tried to engage the objections presented.

But at some point, the evidentiary question has to remain the evidentiary question.

Before introducing another passage as proof that Yah’s appointed times are no longer applicable, please demonstrate that the passage actually establishes that proposition. I am looking for a text that says, in substance: Yah’s appointed holy days have been abolished, are no longer to be observed, or have been replaced by another calendar.

It is not sufficient that a passage mentions festivals, Sabbaths, new moons, shadows, days, sacrifices, judgment, or the New Covenant and that we then infer abolition from those words. The conclusion must be established by the text, not supplied by the interpreter.

If such a passage exists, I am willing to examine it in its complete context. But simply recycling passages already discussed, while repeatedly importing the same unstated conclusion into them, can continue indefinitely without ever answering the original question.

So this is where I will leave the discussion: Show the text that actually abolishes Yah’s appointed times. Show where Scripture authorizes their abandonment or replacement. If the text does not say that, then an interpretation asserting that it does is not the same thing as the text itself.

I appreciate the discussion and everyone’s participation. But without that textual evidence, I believe we have reached the natural end of the exchange.

  • Michael, I haven’t argued that Paul says, “Do not observe the appointed times.” I asked whether they remain binding upon New-Covenant believers. Those are not equivalent propositions. Your answer establishes that Paul does not prohibit their observance. Fine. But if their observance remains obligatory, my question remains: how can Paul tell believers, “Let no one judge you … with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath”?
  • “An inference drawn from a text is not the same thing as what the text actually says.” So where does the New Testament actually say that Yah’s appointed calendar remains binding upon New-Covenant believers?
1 Like

Terry, I understand the distinction you are making, but this simply reverses the burden of the original question.

Yah already established His appointed times. He does not need to restate Himself in the New Testament for His command to have existed or to remain authoritative. Yah declares, “I change not” (Malachi 3:6), and Yahshua and the apostles continued to recognize and observe the appointed times.

So the burden is not upon Scripture to say again, “What I commanded before is still commanded.” The burden remains exactly where I placed it from the beginning: if an existing command of Yah ceased to be binding under the New Covenant, show the text that makes that change.

Colossians 2:16–17 does not say that. “Let no one judge you” does not say “these appointed times are no longer binding.” That conclusion still has to be supplied by the interpreter.

I don’t believe there is anything further to add. Yah stated the command. If the claim is that He subsequently abolished it, the text establishing that abolition is what must be produced.

  • “An inference drawn from a text is not the same thing as what the text actually says.”
  • Malachi 3:6 says, “I change not.” It does not say, “Every command Yah gives remains binding upon every subsequent covenant community until Scripture explicitly repeals it.” That is your inference from the text.
  • So before asking me for a text repealing the appointed calendar, where does Scripture establish your controlling premise: that a command given to Israel under the Sinai covenant remains binding upon New-Covenant believers unless it is explicitly abolished?
1 Like

A final observation for readers of the thread.

  • Michael has repeatedly insisted upon an important distinction: “An inference drawn from a text is not the same thing as what the text actually says.”
  • That principle ultimately brought the discussion to what I think is its central unresolved question. Michael’s argument depends upon the premise that a command given to Israel under the Sinai covenant remains binding upon New-Covenant believers unless Scripture explicitly abolishes it. Malachi 3:6—“I change not”—does not state that proposition; the proposition is itself an inference from Scripture.
  • So, I asked where Scripture establishes that controlling premise. No text establishing it has been offered.
  • That seems to me an appropriate place to leave the argument. If inferences must be distinguished from what a text actually says, that distinction should apply equally to the arguments on both sides.
1 Like

Malachi 3:6 by itself does not contain the entire proposition you have formulated. So let us apply the same standard consistently.

Yahshua says: “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them” (Matthew 5:17), and continues that until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest part passes from the Law until all is accomplished, followed immediately by his warning concerning relaxing even the least of the commandments (Matthew 5:18–19).

And when Scripture explicitly defines the New Covenant, Jeremiah does not say Yah’s law disappears: “I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts” (Jeremiah 31:33). Hebrews repeats that very description of the New Covenant (Hebrews 8:10).

So my premise is not simply “Malachi says Yah does not change; therefore I infer that nothing can ever change.” The textual sequence is much more specific: Yah gives His law; Yahshua expressly denies that he came to abolish it; and the New Covenant is expressly described as Yah writing His law upon the heart.

Therefore, if the narrower claim is that Yah nevertheless removed His appointed times from that law under the New Covenant, we arrive exactly where we began: show the text that makes that particular change.

I think that is an appropriate place for me to leave the discussion as well. I appreciate the challenges and everyone’s participation.

  • What is the difference between a law that Jesus did not abolish and one that Jesus fulfilled?
1 Like

I think the problem is not in the text, it is in the interpretation of the text. You seem to assume that the Torah is valid even for the Christians that live in the New Covenant. You interpret the texts through your assumption and if the calendar of the Covenant through Moses is not explicitly mentioned, you claim that the texts speaks of something that is not relevant for your claim.

The Covenant between Israel and God, given through Moses, was a specific covenant between two parties. Before that covenant, there was the Covenant between God and Abraham, a different covenant with different rules. When Yeshua fulfilled the law, died and resurrected for us, he set up a New Covenant. A different covenant, with different rules than the previous covenant. God is the same but the regulations of the covenant changed because the New is a different covenant. If you try to apply the guidelines and customs of the previous covenant to the new covenant, you mix the covenants in a way that is misleading.

The calendar in the Torah is among the customs of the previous covenant. Fully comparable to the other customs written in Torah. If you do not follow all the regulations and customs of the previous covenant, why lift up one particular set of customs and claim that it stayed although much was abandoned?

1 Like

Yes – Moses and the Torah are not the roots, they sprout from the roots. The roots begin with Abraham and the covenant of faith.

2 Likes

You’ve quoted a spot where abandoning the old calendar & kosher laws is authorized by God; it’s where Paul makes them all optional. There are more, however.In Acts Peter has vision of non kosher animals and is encouraged to eat them. The angel tells him: call nothing God has made unclean." This is why the church at large has aways regarded the Jewish worship calendar and kosher restrictions as requirements that have been done away. Making them optional does them away in exactly the sense you deny: they are no longer requirements.

2 Likes

Roy, Acts 10 actually illustrates the distinction I have been making between what the text says and what is inferred from it.

Peter initially did not understand the vision (Acts 10:17). But when he did, he told us explicitly what Yah had shown him:

“God hath shewed me that I should not call any man common or unclean.” (Acts 10:28). Unclean foods were the Gentiles…

Peter does not say that Yah abolished the dietary laws. He says the revelation concerned people. He then concludes that Yah accepts those who fear Him “in every nation” (10:34–35), and Acts 11:18 confirms the point: “Then hath God also to the Gentiles granted repentance unto life.”

That accords with Paul’s explanation that salvation came to the Gentiles to provoke Israel to jealousy (Romans 11:11; cf. Deuteronomy 32:21).

The same distinction applies to Colossians 2:16. “Let no man judge you” concerning food, festivals, new moons, or Sabbaths does not say those things were abolished, made optional, or replaced.

So I return to the narrow question of the article: Where does Scripture actually authorize the abandonment or replacement of Yah’s appointed calendar?

I think the principal texts offered in response have now been presented. Readers can examine them and determine whether they actually state that conclusion or whether the conclusion is being inferred from them.

Thank you for the discussion, Roy.