Kai, thank you. This is much closer to the kind of engagement I have been asking for because you have presented a covenantal argument and identified the texts from which you believe that argument follows.
But that also allows us to test the argument rather than merely exchange conclusions.
First, we need to distinguish text, interpretation, and inference.
The text is what Scripture actually states. An interpretation explains what those words mean in their grammatical, historical, and literary context. An inference is a conclusion drawn from what the text states even though the conclusion itself is not expressly stated.
There is nothing inherently illegitimate about interpretation or inference. We all interpret Scripture. But an inference must be demonstrated from the text, and an interpretation must account for the whole testimony of Scripture. We cannot insert a proposition Scripture never states and then use that proposition as though Scripture itself had said it.
This is particularly important because Yahshua established a controlling principle for biblical interpretation: “the scripture cannot be broken” (John 10:35).
That leaves us with an unavoidable methodological requirement. An interpretation of Paul cannot contradict Moses. An interpretation of Hebrews cannot contradict the Prophets. An interpretation of the New Covenant cannot contradict Yah’s own definition of that covenant. And none of them can require Yahshua to contradict the Scriptures that he expressly declared cannot be broken.
Scripture must remain coherent: Yah, Torah, Moses, the Prophets, Yahshua, and the Apostles must be allowed to testify together.
Now let us apply that standard to your argument.
You wrote that the calendar belongs to the covenant given through Moses and that Christians “live in the covenant of grace, given through Yeshua” and therefore “follow the rules of that covenant, not the regulations and customs of the covenant given through Moses.”
But Scripture does not define the New Covenant that way.
Yah defines it before Hebrews ever discusses it:
“I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah… I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts.” (Jeremiah 31:31–33)
And this is not merely an Old Testament text that Christians are free to leave behind. Hebrews itself quotes this very prophecy when explaining the New Covenant (Hebrews 8:8–12).
Therefore the proposition that the New Covenant replaces Yah’s Torah with an entirely different body of “rules” cannot simply be assumed. The prophetic definition says that Yah writes His law upon the heart. Hebrews adopts that definition. Any interpretation of Hebrews must account for it.
Now consider Hebrews 9:10. You cited the NIV’s “external regulations applying until the time of the new order.” But what does the passage actually identify?
The immediate argument concerns the tabernacle, priestly access, gifts and sacrifices, purification of the conscience, food, drink, various washings, and regulations pertaining to the body. Hebrews 9:10 itself identifies “food and drink and various ceremonial washings—external regulations.”
The appointed calendar is not stated there.
Your argument therefore makes an additional inference: because the appointed times were commanded within the Mosaic covenant, whatever Hebrews says was temporary in Hebrews 9:10 must necessarily include the appointed times.
But that conclusion is precisely what must be proved.
You cannot place Passover, Unleavened Bread, Weeks, Trumpets, Atonement, and Tabernacles into Hebrews 9:10 when the author did not place them there, and then cite Hebrews 9:10 as proof that the author removed them. That is circular: the conclusion has first been inserted into the premise and then recovered from it as though the text supplied it.
Galatians 4 presents an equally serious contextual problem.
Paul does not begin his argument at verse 10. He first reminds the Galatians:
“when ye knew not God, ye did service unto them which by nature are no gods” (Galatians 4:8).
He then asks why they are turning back again to the “weak and beggarly elements” under which they had formerly been enslaved (4:9), and only then says:
“Ye observe days, and months, and times, and years” (4:10).
These Gentiles had not previously been covenant-observant Israelites keeping Yah’s appointed times. Paul explicitly describes their former condition as serving beings “which by nature are no gods.”
Therefore simply asserting that the “days, months, seasons and years” of verse 10 are Yah’s appointed times does not establish it. The identification itself must be demonstrated from Paul’s argument, including his repeated language of returning to something that had enslaved them before they knew Elohim.
Romans 14 has the same evidentiary problem.
Paul discusses disputes involving eating, abstaining, regarding one day above another, conscience, and believers judging one another. But Romans 14:5 never says:
Passover is now optional.
It never says:
Tabernacles is now optional.
It never says:
Yah’s appointed calendar has been abolished.
And it never says:
The New Covenant replaces Yah’s appointed calendar with whatever days each individual Christian personally chooses to regard.
Those propositions are not in the text.
They are interpretations being inferred from the text. Therefore they carry the burden of demonstration; they cannot themselves serve as the proof.
This brings us back to the question I have deliberately kept narrow throughout this discussion.
I am not asking whether circumcision justifies Gentiles.
I am not asking whether animal sacrifices continue unchanged.
I am not asking whether the Levitical priesthood continues unchanged.
I am not asking whether believers earn salvation by observing Torah.
And I am not asking whether the New Covenant exists.
Those are different questions.
The question before us is:
What biblical text authorizes the abandonment or replacement of Yah’s appointed calendar?
If the answer is Hebrews 9–10, then demonstrate where Hebrews places Yah’s appointed times among the things being removed.
If the answer is Galatians 4, then demonstrate contextually that Paul’s “days and months and seasons and years” are Yah’s appointed times, while accounting for his statement that these Gentiles were returning to something associated with their former bondage when they “knew not God.”
If the answer is Romans 14, then demonstrate where Paul identifies Yah’s appointed times as the disputable days he is discussing and where he transfers Yah’s authority to appoint sacred times to individual preference.
That is the evidentiary burden.
And because “the scripture cannot be broken,” the resulting interpretation must remain coherent with Yah’s Torah, the Prophets, Yahshua, and the Apostles. It cannot merely solve one Pauline passage by creating contradictions elsewhere in Scripture.
If the text establishes the proposition, then the text should decide the matter. But if the proposition exists only after something has been added to the text, then we must distinguish clearly between what Scripture says and what an interpreter has concluded that Scripture must mean.