Logic, reason and Christianity

I am sorry to say that your verdict does not meet with Jesus’. This is what he said.

“I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them now. Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come.” (John 16:12–13)

And why did John tell us how to test the spirits?

“Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world. Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God:** **And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God: and this is that spirit of antichrist, whereof ye have heard that it should come; and even now already is it in the world.” (1 John 4:1-3)

I would suggest reading his entire book before you start objecting. Greber tested the spirit who taught him. The spirit taught him all the truth about Jesus and his message. He was told all the falsifications that the scribes and priests made and corrected the errors. Greber brought this to his superiors but they rejected him. So he left the Catholic church. Here is an online copy to read before it was falsified. https://tornbetweentwoworlds.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/GREBER.pdf

BTW, he was taught the same things that were taught by Origen of Alexandria, and declared anathema.

If this supposed “truth” contradicted biblical and apostolic teaching, then it was no truth at all. Even if he genuinely had spiritual experiences, those experiences could not have come from God if the messages he received contradicted what God had already revealed.

Scripture itself warns us that even Satan disguises himself as an angel of light (2 Corinthians 11:14).

Origen never claimed that his teachings were definitively authoritative and always submitted to the authority of the Church. That is a fundamental distinction. Moreover, I have already provided you with direct textual evidence from Origen’s own writings that prove what I am saying. I’ve provided those evidences here Logic, reason and Christianity - #6 by 1Cor15.54 .

He didn’t renounce his teachings during his lifetime simply because the doctrinal questions at issue had not yet been definitively settled by the Church, but his disposition was the very opposite to that of an heretic.

1 Like
  • John 16:12–13 does not authenticate Greber.
  • Jesus promises that the Spirit of truth will guide his disciples into all truth. But you assume that this promise extends to the particular spirit that allegedly communicated with Greber. That is precisely what you need to establish.
  • Nothing in John 16 identifies Greber, authorizes communication with deceased spirits, or establishes that a spirit claiming divine authority must be believed. Indeed, the passage identifies the promised guide as the Spirit of truth, not simply any spirit professing to communicate truth.
2 Likes

If he “tested” the spirit and didn’t realize that it was a treacherous spirit then I’m sorry for him. Especially because he should have never practiced spiritism in the first place unless you can show me how the biblical commands against spiritism can be reconciled with its practice.

2 Likes
  • Your appeal to 1 John 4:1–3 is incomplete. You quote John’s instruction to test the spirits, emphasizing the confession that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh. But you treat that confession as though it were a sufficient guarantee of authenticity.
  • The passage does not say that every spirit claiming to affirm Jesus must therefore be believed in everything it teaches. Moreover, the opening command is to test the spirits, not to accept their testimony merely because they make a particular confession.
  • The broader context of 1 John also emphasizes fidelity to the apostolic proclamation (1 John 1:1–3; 4:6). A spirit’s alleged confession of Christ cannot independently establish that its other theological claims are true.
2 Likes
  • The claim about Origen needs historical substantiation. You wrote: “He was taught the same things that were taught by Origen of Alexandria, and declared anathema.” This conflates several distinct historical questions.
  • Origen may have taught the preexistence of rational beings and their fall and restoration. But attributing repeated reincarnation into successive human lives to Origen is much more problematic.
  • Origen explicitly criticizes transmigration in his Commentary on Matthew, discussing the claim that John the Baptist was Elijah. He distinguishes Elijah’s spirit and power from the notion that Elijah’s soul passed into John’s body.
  • Furthermore, the history of the condemnations associated with Origen, especially those attributed to the Fifth Ecumenical Council in 553, is considerably more complicated than Shawn’s sentence suggests.
  • Similarity between selected Greber doctrines and selected Origenist doctrines does not establish that Greber faithfully recovered Origen’s theology.
1 Like
  • I am willing to examine Greber’s claims. But the question is not whether Greber believed that a spirit taught him the truth. The question is how you established that the spirit actually told him the truth. You cannot use Greber’s purported revelations to authenticate the spirit and then use the spirit’s supposed authority to authenticate Greber’s revelations. That would be circular reasoning.
2 Likes

There are also several accounts in the lives of the saints of the devil appearing in the guise of Christ Himself.

Demons are deceivers by their very nature, what distinguishes the saints from those who fall prey to such deception is, above all, humility: the saints understand that neither they nor anyone else has the authority to alter the truth and It is this humility, and their fidelity to the apostolic faith, that enables them to recognize and reject deceptive spirits.

Those with a very different disposition are far more vulnerable to deception, i‘m thinking particularly of those so consumed by pride that they imagine themselves uniquely capable of discovering truths that somehow remained hidden from generations of ignorant sheeps before them: they convince themselves that they possess an extraordinary insight denied to the ignorant masses, whom they regard as intellectually or spiritually inferior.

And it is this conviction of their own superiority that makes them so susceptible to being deceived.

Pride is regarded as the gravest of the seven deadly sins for a reason. On top of being the sin that condemned the fallen angels.

Proverbs 16:5: “The LORD detests all the proud of heart.”

James 4:6: “God opposes the proud but shows favor to the humble.”

Proverbs 16:18: “Pride goes before destruction, a haughty spirit before a fall”

Luke 1:51: “He has performed mighty deeds with his arm; he has scattered those who are proud in their inmost thoughts.”

Pride is the very opposite of obiedence, the devil has always been helpless against Mary because She has always been obedient to God, pride never touched Her heart even for a second.

Also in 1 Peter 5:5–9 we have a very clear connection between humility and resistance to the devil.

Peter exhorts Christians to clothe themselves with humility, reminding them that God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble, he then urges them to humble themselves under God’s mighty hand He warns that the devil prowls around like a roaring lion, looking for someone to devour, and he instructs them to resist the devil, standing firm in their faith.

In short: Peter’s exhortation to humility immediately precedes his warning about the devil and his instructions for resisting him.

Humility is not merely an admirable moral quality, but an essential spiritual disposition to resist the devil and his temptations (and many associate temptations with the the sins of the flesh, but the most dangerous, and less obvious to recognize, temptations, are the temptations that involve the intellect and the spirit).

3 Likes

Excuse me, where do you read any of the Apostles and Fathers believed in anything resembling to

Or

Where is reason, logic and more importantly, Christianity in any of that? I mostly smell a gnostic perfume in your doctrinal views which is something Ireaneus had to dismantle. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if by the end of the conversation, you happen to think satan actually is the hero of the story.

1 Like

Do you know what the restoration of all things teaches? Lucifer is the one who started the Fall of 1/3 of the Heavenly host, so no, he is not the hero of the story. Jesus, the King of Heaven, is the hero of the story. It is the King of Heaven who incarnated as human to defeat Lucifer and open the gates of the Heaven for the fallen to start returning home.

Yes, this is how you can see that it is the spirit of truth, through humility. Greber was extremely humble. As was Origen.

Uh… That’s a pretty niche group with academic backing. They haven’t gotten a lot of traction outside their small area which tends to include psychology people. I’d like to see that work better fleshed out and repeated with appropriate design for confounders.

Does the proposal that people are reincarnated at a faster rate that correlates with the unexpectedness of the original death seem to jibe with Biblical or Christian understanding of soul transference to fetuses?

1 Like

But you want Satan and his angels in heaven, to be blunt that’s pure unbiblical fantasy

“And the angels who did not keep their proper domain, but left their own abode, He has reserved in everlasting chains under darkness for the judgment of the great day; ”

Jude 1.v6

1 Like

There was an enormous difference between the two, like I said. You can’t compare the two at all.

Have you actually studied both?

The cases that Stevenson and Tucker have investigated are front end of the bell curve. These are people who died a violent death that left scars and then reincarnated to finish a lifetime that was cut short. The average time between incarnations is about 300 years.

1 Like

I have already provided you with direct evidence from Origen’s own writings. He never practiced spiritism, and he had profound respect for the authority of the Church. He would never have presumed to place his own judgment above it.

As for why he did not renounce his speculative theological views during his lifetime, the explanation is quite simple: the doctrinal questions at issue had not yet been definitively settled at the time.

1 Like

If you did you’d see the difference is not on the shelf of humility, it is on the ground of correction.

Origen, in one of his homilies on Luke, said it himself, “As for myself, my wish is to be truly a man of the Church, to be called by the name of Christ and not that of any heresiarch.”

He argued from the Scriptures, inside the Church, and when he drifted the fathers answered him the same way they answered the gnostics, with the Scriptures. Methodius of Olympus wrote a whole Discourse on the Resurrection to answer his teaching on the body, walking through 1 Corinthians 15 and 2 Corinthians 5 verse by verse. Epiphanius catalogued his errors in the same medicine chest where he catalogued the gnostic heresies, because that is where he judged they belonged and he treated them with the same remedy.

When the speculation matured into the doctrine that ‘angels become men’ and ‘men become angels again’, the anathemas of 553 answered it with the apostle’s own rule, “Though we or an angel from heaven preach any other gospel, let him be anathema” (Galatians 1.v8).

If anyone shall say that Christ, of whom it is said that he appeared in the form of God, and that he was united before all time with God the Word, and humbled himself in these last days even to humanity, had (according to their expression) pity upon the various falls which had appeared in the spirits united in the same unity (of which he himself is part), and that to restore them he passed through various classes, had different bodies and different names, became all to all, an Angel among Angels, a Power among Powers, has clothed himself in the different classes of reasonable beings with a form corresponding to that class, and finally has taken flesh and blood like ours and has become man for men; [if anyone says all this] and does not profess that God the Word humbled himself and became man: let him be anathema.

Greber, by your own account, went the other way. You wrote that he was told the falsifications the scribes and priests made, “corrected the errors”, brought it to his superiors, but left when refused. Origen took the Church’s correction and wanted no name but Christian. Greber claimed the Scriptures needed his spirit’s correction, and left when the Church declined. Humility receives correction, it does not hand it out to the scribes thinking it knows better while tampering Scriptures.

The two men do not sit on the same league and the difference is visible in the very thing you praised them for.

That’s pure speculations about mysteries, not everything is knowable nor has to be known. That’s why I think you’re onto mystery religions and neo gnosticism than actual Christianity.

1 Like

Yes, he didn’t reject some of his erroneous doctrines while he was still alive but only because he still wasn’t sure as to whether they were actually erroneous or not. So, while he was still alive, it was effectively legit to believe what he believed, although many other fathers weren’t on board with some of his opinions.

He was wrong but through no fault of his own.

  • Argon, I think both questions are well taken. In spite of the fact that the subject matter is not “mainstream science” or “orthodox (with a small “o”) Christianity”, the research certainly deserves careful examination, particularly with respect to independent replication, appropriate controls, and alternative explanations. Even if a correlation between unexpected deaths and shorter intervals before alleged reincarnation were established, that would not, by itself, establish the transmigration of souls.
  • Personally, my inclination is to admit the possibility that a sudden, tragic death might result in a “do over” life, but I certainly don’t imagine crowds joining me.
  • Your second question raises a different problem. Christianity has no universally agreed account of precisely when or how a soul becomes associated with a developing human being. But neither does the New Testament provide an account of deceased souls repeatedly entering developing fetuses.
  • I think I remember a Jewish notion of selective reincarnation, followed by a bit of folklore: i.e. the little curve in an upper lip is the result of an angel tapping the child to cause it to forget everything before birth.
  • Back to the distinction between reincarnation and resurrection: Paul describes the resurrection of the dead as a transformation from mortality to immortality (1 Corinthians 15:42–54), not a succession of additional mortal lives.
  • I would therefore distinguish three questions:
    • What has the research actually established?
    • Does reincarnation adequately explain those findings?
    • And what, if anything, establishes reincarnation as a Christian doctrine?
  • Regarding the last question: again, I don’t expect to see a huge crowd voicing agreement.
3 Likes